That different world. Enrico Giovannini and Fabrizio Barca urge us to fight for a fairer and more sustainable future

That different world. Enrico Giovannini and Fabrizio Barca urge us to fight for a fairer and more sustainable future

Culture & lifestyle · ·

How should we steer our development model after coronavirus? The dialogue between economists Enrico Giovannini and Fabrizio Barca yields various proposals, in the name of sustainability.

Our development model had been creaking for some time, exposing its weak points in an increasingly obvious way: a rampant climate crisis systematically relegated to the back burner of the political agenda, fractures in the social fabric, GDP as the sole (and fallible) yardstick for measuring wellbeing, and an illusory faith in the market's ability to self-regulate. The crisis triggered by coronavirus has brought this model crashing down. We still do not know where this new phase of history will take us, but it is now clear that we can no longer wearily rely on the old economic and intellectual models. It is a painful trauma, certainly. But also a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to leave behind what has not worked and build a better tomorrow.

Quel mondo diverso. Da immaginare, per cui battersi, che si può realizzare, published by Laterza, is a dialogue between two economists: Fabrizio Barca, former chair of the OECD Territorial Policy Committee and Minister for Territorial Cohesion in the Monti government, now a member of the assembly of the Forum disuguaglianze diversità, and Enrico Giovannini, former chief statistician of the OECD, president of Istat and Minister of Labour in the Letta government, now co-founder and spokesperson of the Alleanza italiana per lo sviluppo sostenibile (ASviS), the largest network of civil society organisations ever created in Italy to spread awareness of the Agenda 2030 and the culture of sustainable development. We recommended it among the reads to discover or give as gifts at Christmas, and now we explore its contents in depth together with Enrico Giovannini.

20 libri da regalare a Natale: Quel mondo diverso – Fabrizio Barca ed Enrico Giovannini
Quel mondo diverso – Fabrizio Barca ed Enrico Giovannini

Interview with Enrico Giovannini

The response to the 2008 crisis was centred on austerity. In the face of coronavirus, the opposite approach was adopted instead, based on investment and expansionary policies. Is this the right path?
It is the essential path, for two reasons. First of all because, as even the most neoliberal economists acknowledge, in a period of depression and crisis public spending must increase for investment rather than for current expenditure.

There is also another consideration to make. We are in the middle of an ecological transformation of many production processes and of how we organise our lives: the circular economy, electric mobility, the shift to renewable energy. This transition can be beneficial from both an environmental and an economic standpoint because, once up and running, it reduces costs; and it must be carried out alongside the digital transformation. This is the moment to accelerate these transformations, also because they can generate new jobs which, in the current situation, are fundamental for social sustainability as well as economic and environmental sustainability.

Finance, too, is rapidly steering in this direction. This is an opportunity to channel the enormous liquidity created by the expansionary monetary policy of recent years. Securities such as social bonds and green bonds are attracting the interest of savers who, despite the crisis, still have a great many resources at their disposal.

REmini2020 – Enrico Giovannini, fondatore Asvis

Sapevate che le persone sono molto più attente alle tematiche di sviluppo sostenibile rispetto ai media (tranne noi 😀) e alla politica? Ne è convinto Enrico Giovannini, fondatore e portavoce di ASviS – Alleanza Italiana per lo Sviluppo Sostenibile. life.gt/giovannini-asvis#REmini2020 – #FuturoCircolare – #Meeting18 – #Conai

Posted by LifeGate on Thursday, August 23, 2018

Various analyses highlight the fact that, in the stimulus packages designed to steer economies out of the coronavirus crisis, the green transition carries only marginal weight. One of the few exceptions is the European Union. What are the opportunities we cannot afford to miss?

It is not surprising that the ruling class of so many countries, shaped by the neoliberalism of the past forty years, finds it difficult to think in new terms. The response seen in many countries is therefore an old-fashioned response.

Europe is an extraordinary exception in this regard. The fact that the new Commission placed sustainable development at its centre meant that when the crisis broke out, things moved almost automatically in the direction that had already been identified as the future. The choice of decarbonisation by 2050 and the raising of ambition on emissions cuts by 2030 have meant that, by now, even businesses and public administrations have all oriented their recovery and resilience plans in this direction.

With the official adoption at the #ENVI Council we are ready to submit the new EU nationally determined contribution under the #ParisAgreement. Cutting emissions -55% by 2030 sets us on the path to #ClimateNeutralEU and raises the bar for global #ClimateAction

All of this has also stimulated international competition. China has announced its intention to decarbonise by 2060, and other countries have done likewise with different deadlines. This shows that the European Union is setting the standard.

In the book you put forward many proposals for a new economic, social and political system: from moving beyond GDP to taxing the web giants. Can you name one that is nearing completion and, conversely, one that you feel has been overlooked?
In my 2018 book Utopia sostenibile and in the 2019 report Uguaglianza sostenibile, written with Fabrizio Barca and other European experts, there is a series of proposals that are becoming the European mainstream. Among them, for example, the proposal to orient the so-called European Semester towards Agenda 2030, or the importance of resilience as a guiding principle for policies, as a "compass" for European policies, as one reads in the recent Commission report. In short, some things that only three years ago seemed, precisely, an absolute utopia are now being realised.

Il primo Rapporto @ASviSItalia su #territori e #Agenda2030 ha evidenziato l'impegno fondamentale di Regioni, Province e Città per raggiungere la sostenibilità economica, sociale e ambientale entro i termini stabiliti dal piano d'azione Onu. Scopri di più > bit.ly/2WvfsHX

There is still little awareness, however, of how much investment in human capital makes a difference not only in terms of providing jobs, but also in terms of seizing the new opportunities offered by digitalisation and the circular economy. In our accounting systems we continue to regard the purchase of a computer as an investment and the training of a person as a cost that reduces a company's profits. This gives an idea of how outdated our accounting system is, in keeping with a twentieth-century vision of the economy and society. There are some steps forward on this front, such as the obligation on companies to provide non-financial reporting, but the need for a profound change in the way we measure overall wellbeing has not yet been fully grasped.

La pandemia ci ha costretto a ripensare la nostra quotidianità affrontando problemi finora accantonati: l’inefficienza del sistema Italia, il futuro dell’Europa, la necessità di impegni globali per clima e migrazioni.

L'editoriale di @Dospe.

asvis.it/editoriali/128…

In your book you talk not only about economics but about our entire way of life. And it is clear that Covid-19 has brought to the surface a great many situations of fragility and loneliness. Beyond the welfare measures that are indispensable when one is in the middle of an emergency, how can we overcome them in a lasting way?
Our lives depend on many factors. There are, of course, economic factors, because people who have lost their jobs see their life plans fall apart. But then there are many other elements. Let us think of the unpaid work of volunteers who brought food to people locked at home during lockdown, or of the care work of mothers and fathers towards their children, penalised by the lack of schooling.

What this crisis is making dramatic, however, is the rise in inequalities between men and women, young and old, rich and poor. When we come out of it, we will have taken serious steps backwards from this point of view. This means we will need to rebuild the various forms of human, economic and social capital, because, even if we were to return to pre-crisis GDP but without the same human capital (which was already insufficient in quantitative and qualitative terms), we would still find ourselves poorer, weaker and more exposed to the next shock.

I welcome last night’s agreement on the Recovery and Resilience Facility.

The Facility is at the heart of our recovery plan - #NextGenerationEU - and will finance the investments & reforms we need for a stronger, more resilient Europe.

This need to look not only at flows (of income, GDP, etc.) but also at stocks — which are precisely what makes a country resilient in the face of crises — has not yet been fully taken on board. It is no coincidence that people speak of a "recovery and resilience plan," and this is why part of the European funds must be invested in tackling inequalities and in human capital: it is people who make a society and an economy resilient to crises, not machines.