Web tax in Italy: what it is, how it works and how it has changed

Web tax in Italy: what it is, how it works and how it has changed

Economy & innovation · ·

Halved rate and no e-commerce: the web tax will officially arrive in Italy in 2019, but it will be very different from what was originally planned.

It was supposed to be the definitive method for making web giants based abroad pay taxes in our country, once and for all. After countless discussions and a lengthy legislative process, it was finally approved with the 2018 budget law, albeit with several changes from its official version. Let us analyse the web tax in detail, to find out how it works, when it will come into force and who will be subject to it.

What has changed for the web tax

The first significant change concerns the rate, which in the amendment tabled by Massimo Mucchetti of the Pd stood at 6 per cent but has now been halved, coming down to 3 per cent. This tax will be applied to all those entities that exceed 3,000 digital service transactions per year (a threshold that automatically excludes small and medium-sized enterprises). The range of "digital transactions" has been significantly reduced, because e-commerce has been struck out — thereby cutting out a giant such as Amazon.

In the first version, it was established that Italian customers of these web services should withhold this 6 per cent from the invoice, pay it to the treasury and enjoy a tax credit of the same amount; under the new version of the tax, the tax credit is abolished and the 3 per cent is collected by applying a withholding tax at source. The "day X" for the launch of the web tax remains unchanged, set for 1 January 2019.

Who criticises it and why

These revisions have attracted criticism here and there, as they would have made the measure far less effective at flushing out any tax avoidance by web giants. The website lavoce.info pulls no punches: as it has been formulated, "both Italian companies operating in the sector and foreign companies without a permanent establishment in Italy pay the web tax," "the provisions aimed at making the action of the tax authority more penetrating are eliminated," or those "aimed at countering genuinely avoidance-driven activities." In other words, the analysis underlines, the state asks companies to voluntarily declare that they have exceeded 3,000 digital transactions in the previous year, but does not equip itself with adequate means to expose lies and inaccuracies.

La #webtax italiana approvata definitivamente non centra l’obiettivo del riequilibrio fra il prelievo gratuito presso la nostra economia di risorse tassate solo all’estero. Dopo le modifiche della Camera si è trasformata in una misura per fare cassa.
lavoce.info/archives/50454…

Italians are in favour of the web tax

55 per cent of Italians believe it is right to tax profits generated in Italy by web giants; a further 27.6 per cent believe this task falls to the European Union or another supranational body; only 17.5 per cent declare themselves entirely opposed. This is what emerges from the report La cultura dell'innovazione, drawn up by Agi and Censis. It should be said that our fellow citizens, when faced with innovation and the digital world, have a positive but critical attitude. While 57 per cent of Italians state that the innovations of the past twenty years have brought many benefits, albeit with a few minor problems, it is also true that 42.1 per cent automatically associate the advance of automation and robotics with job losses. And there is still 15 per cent who turn their nose up at the prospect of buying, selling and booking goods and services online.