Enrico Giovannini, the sustainable conscience of the task force for Italy's recovery, has no doubts. What is needed is a rapid and irreversible transformation, now.
Now that the plan of initiatives for Italy's recovery over the next decade has been presented, let us hear from Enrico Giovannini himself — the sustainable conscience of the task force, the committee of experts led by Vittorio Colao — what we should truly expect for our future. What must we do as civil society? And above all, what should young people expect — the very people from whom we are stealing opportunities, stealing the future, leaving them nothing but rubble and debt?
Giovannini — former Minister of Labour and Social Policies, professor at the University of Tor Vergata and spokesperson for Asvis, the Italian Alliance for Sustainable Development — is in no doubt: we must act quickly to make the most of this opportunity and ensure that the transformation is "rapid and irreversible".
Before the restart we were at a crossroads — either go back to the way things were, or change with an eye to survival, with a sustainable outlook. What do you make of these first days of the restart? It is too soon to make an assessment. For instance, we would need to see how, over the coming weeks and months, certain short-term phenomena are managed — such as the handling of personal protective equipment: face masks, gloves, single-use plastics in restaurants, hotels and bars — because the risk, as some have already raised, is that we go backwards. We will see whether Italians, particularly in cities, turn to the private car out of fear of contagion, or whether instead, making use of the incentives the government has made available, there will be a shift towards bicycles — electric or pedal-assisted — and similar means of transport.
In the medium term, the question remains entirely open, although I am somewhat more optimistic than I was before the restart. This optimism stems from three aspects: the first is that the European Commission is holding a steady course, and this choice points in the direction of sustainable development — though the final word will ultimately rest with the member states within the European Council. On the other hand, I see that Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte has announced that the ecological transformation of our system is nonetheless one of the government's priorities. It will be necessary to see the concrete actions that follow, but the overall approach seems right to me. Finally, the new president of Confindustria, Carlo Bonomi, stated clearly in his first address that economic, social and environmental sustainability is a "must" for the Italian production system. I was very pleased that Confindustria published, a few days ago, the first sustainability report for the confederation as a whole. These are interesting signals that need to be strongly steered in the right direction by public opinion.
Staggered hours, smart working, digitalisation. Do you think a revolution in the world of work is on its way? And what will happen to those who cannot take advantage of agile working — who have no access to the internet, to mobile devices or digital tools? What we have all experienced is not agile or smart working — it is working from home. For it to become truly smart working, training and organisation are needed. Many companies are already leaning towards making extensive remote working a permanent arrangement. The case of teaching is different: here there is a distinction between universities and schools. The relational dimension carries enormous weight in schools, whereas the investment universities have made in remote lectures could also be used not only for student-facing teaching, but for a major programme of continuing adult education — something that is sorely lacking in Italy.
For schools, the priority is to understand as quickly as possible how to return to the classroom, even though the possibility of using distance learning can be trialled and integrated into the normal way of teaching. The issue is the availability of tools — not only for the less well-off, but adequate ones for everyone. Companies must invest here; public administrations must invest to overcome the emergency situation we have faced. But this is a great opportunity to transform the rhythms of working life, and it could be used as a springboard for rethinking cities. In this regard, the government's decision to lower to 100 employees the threshold above which a company must have a mobility manager — with whom local authorities can engage — seems important to me. In short: rethinking timetables, commuting and the balance between working life and personal life is an extraordinary opportunity that must be managed carefully. Because not everything we have lived through has been positive.
How long do you think it will take to make this leap, both in terms of mindset and in physical, practical terms? How long does it take to change a country like Italy? I believe companies will move very quickly — and it is no coincidence that they are already deciding what to do. So by the end of the year we will have a clearer picture of the situation. The National Institute of Statistics (Istat) is conducting an analysis on these issues, and it will be very interesting to see the results. On the other hand, we need local, regional and national administrations to keep pace, because without an adequate system — in terms of transport, for instance, or the management of other services, including social care services and nurseries — it is clear the system will not make the leap. We risk very negative reactions. The other consideration is the role of the social partners. As several trade union leaders have rightly pointed out, we also need to understand how to regulate smart working, because there are safety issues and costs that companies should rightly be made to bear. There are many challenges, but I see a spirit of collaboration that gives me grounds for hope.
As Asvis, you have proposed digitalising and modernising existing infrastructure, and you have called on the government to create a transformative resilience unit. What is it and what is its objective? I began making this proposal publicly on 6 March; then on 10 April the so-called Colao committee was set up, of which I am a member, with the precise aim of imagining what could be done in phase three, in the recovery phase (the committee's published work is available here, ed.). It seems important to me, however, that — precisely because Brussels is steering choices towards the objectives we were discussing earlier — every European country should prepare its own recovery plan within the Commission's framework, not only in order to make use of the funds, but because the key words seem very much right to me.
I speak of transformative resilience because, normally, resilience refers to the capacity of a material, an individual or a collective to return to its state before a shock — like squeezing a plastic bottle and then letting it spring back to its original shape. I speak of transformative resilience because we do not want to return to where we were before the crisis, since we were not doing well: Italy was growing slowly, unemployment was high — especially among young people and women — there were major inequalities, very high tax evasion, pollution, soil degradation… in short, we do not want to go back to where we were. This must therefore be a great opportunity to bounce forward, not backward. The risks are real, which is why, as Asvis, we are working very hard towards the Festival of Sustainable Development, which we have moved to September. The good news is that attention to these issues is very high, and that is why we have also launched futuranetwork.eu — a new website that, after the flood of interviews and articles from great thinkers in recent weeks about what the future will look like, will host contributions on what we want our future to be, because the future is in our hands and we must decide now what to do, starting from current events, from today's problems.
As LifeGate, it will be in our interest to understand how to take part. Let me ask you a very concrete question: in your book L'utopia sostenibile, much of what is being discussed today was already written. The health crisis we are living through is merely a reflection, a consequence too, of a looming climate crisis that more or less demands similar solutions. What is needed now to put that agenda into action? There is a cartoon doing the rounds these days, and it is quite terrifying: it shows a tiny city about to be hit by the tsunami wave of the pandemic. Behind that wave there is an even bigger one — the recession. After the recession comes one bigger still: the climate crisis. Ursula von der Leyen stated in a speech that one day we will find a vaccine against the coronavirus, but there is no vaccine against global warming, so we must prepare for a great transformation of our systems.
Sooner or later we will find a vaccine for the #coronavirus. But there is no vaccine for climate change. Therefore Europe needs a recovery plan designed for the future. #EPlenary
I believe her words are a perfect summary of how this crisis has shown that capitalism and our societies have been built in a fragile way. The capitalism and globalisation of the past 40 years, oriented towards efficiency and cost reduction, have on one hand produced great results — we must not deny that, because billions of people have been lifted out of extreme poverty — but on the other they seem incapable of dealing with a world subject to repeated shocks, as I had already envisaged in my book. I believe this message has come through loud and clear in the minds of political, business and financial leaders.
A concrete example: the European Investment Bank (EIB), last September, decided to stop financing, from 2021 onwards, energy projects based on fossil fuels. Cassa depositi e prestiti (Cdp) had its statute amended by law with a clear reference to the 2030 agenda and sustainable development. At European level the EIB, and at national level the Cdp, are the engines on which the future development of our economy and our societies is set. Having put these guardrails in place before the crisis shows both that we must proceed in that direction and that it is possible to do so. We all have to push for a transformation in thinking that is still not there, above all among the advisers to politicians, who have instead been trained in the old paradigm. This is why civil society, which endures beyond the term of a minister or an adviser, must push for this transformation to be rapid and irreversible.
It seems to me, from your answer, that the various requests to weaken certain environmental laws will not be — or at least should not be — accepted by Italy and by Europe. What will happen to the green deal, but also to short-term decisions such as the plastic tax? The risks are real, and in the analysis we carried out of the various decrees we showed how the attitude has largely still been one of protecting rather than transforming. In this sense, new automatic responses have been absent because the old ones kicked in.
I will give three examples: the first is precisely the plastic tax, which has been postponed like many other levies, yet no one thought to immediately remove the tax burden from compostable products, which could prevent the risk of a new wave of plastic use to protect against the virus. So an attempt was made to shield businesses that feel penalised by an "unfair" tax, but no attempt was made to promote the use of alternative products. From what I have gathered, this was placed on the agenda but downgraded as a non-urgent item. If that is true, it would be a glaring mistake — one that can still be corrected in Parliament.
Second example: at this moment we are supporting all businesses with substantial financial resources, including those that evade or have evaded taxes in the past. Aid of this kind should clearly have been accompanied by a very strong "promise" of rigour in the future should those businesses be caught evading again. That was not done.
The third example is the aid going to so many medium and large businesses. This was an opportunity to require those businesses with more than 250 employees to report on their environmental and social impact, thereby correcting a very serious mistake made by the government led by Matteo Renzi in 2016 — against our advice — when it restricted this obligation to very few companies.
The well-known 19 billion euros spent every year by the state on subsidies harmful to the environment could be eliminated in one go, replacing them with a 10 billion reduction in the tax wedge. This would shift incentives towards businesses that create employment, removing them from energy-intensive ones. Then 5 billion for businesses for sustainable transformation, and 4 billion for an extraordinary investment in young people and women, who are the most penalised by this crisis. I believe that, given the situation, the support for such an important and bold decision would be far greater than anything we have experienced in the past. Courage is needed in some cases, because without courage and without radical change, we will not bounce back towards the future at the speed we need.
You have spoken of courage and of utopia, two qualities that characterise young people. I note with pleasure that now, with the health emergency, scientists have returned to centre stage and have regained their authority and their role as a guide for political decisions too. That was not the case with the climate crisis, even though it was young people who asked us to listen to those very same scientists who have been telling us for decades that we must change. What has been, and what will be, the role of young people? What do we want to say to them? What can we do now to ensure that the centrality we have restored to science — and therefore to young people as well — is not undermined? Because of the shortcomings of previous policies, we are today forced to respond to this crisis by taking on yet more debt, and Italy is already a heavily indebted country. This means shifting the burden onto younger generations and further reducing their opportunities for the future. I would therefore expect at the very least that leaders enact the policies young people are calling for, otherwise this generation would end up, as they would say in Naples, "cornuta e mazziata" — meaning not only are you not doing what I am asking, but then I am the one who has to pay for it too. That strikes me as truly excessive.
At this moment, certain things can be done that may seem far o
Rapid and irreversible: Enrico Giovannini on Italy's sustainable recovery
Rights — di Tommaso Perrone
Enrico Giovannini, the sustainable conscience of the task force for Italy's recovery, has no doubts. What is needed is a rapid and irreversible transformation, now.