Why bears in Italy, but not in Europe, are an endangered species

Why bears in Italy, but not in Europe, are an endangered species

Environment · ·

Bears in our country are an endangered species. The reasons? Laws that are not respected or little known, and an increasingly evident lack of environmental awareness.

Bears in our country are an established presence, but one that is often "inconvenient" — that is, a source of controversy and positions that are, more often than not, unsupported by genuine data or specific information. The media, social media and animal welfare associations also act as a sounding board for killings, birth restrictions, and announced cullings of individuals considered dangerous or aggressive. But where does the truth lie? And what will the future of this plantigrade hold in our country? Let us try to shed some light on the matter.

orsi
Bears in Italy are facing serious dangers © Pixabay

Are bears in Europe a danger to humans?

In general, the European situation for bears appears to be better than in Italy. The populations of the Dinaric Alps and the Balkans are in good health, despite the culling and removal of problematic individuals. The same can be said of the Finnish and Scandinavian populations. The positive figures from Spain stand out, as it represents a model similar to the Alps in terms of the history and origin of this plantigrade. "Naturally, the presence of bears causes accidents everywhere, mostly non-lethal, but the impact on public opinion is on average different from Italy. There is less media fallout and what happens remains confined to the necessary coexistence between humans and large predators, with wolves at the forefront. An exception is Romania, where despite a management system of culling and feeding areas that should have kept bears away from people and villages, even fatal accidents continue to be common, and the political conflict surrounding the issue is also growing. Romania is the most glaring example of how managing these plantigrades through culling and invasive control schemes does not achieve the desired results: bears continue to frequent people and villages, numbers increase due to artificial feeding, accidents do not decrease and conflict grows," the naturalists at Eliante, a cooperative working in the field of environmental sustainability, told us.

orsi
Bears are often kept in zoos and protected facilities © Pixabay

The situation of bears in Italy

And in Italy? Coexistence between bears and humans appears to be increasingly fraught and problematic. The past year was marked by negative events that attracted significant media attention, in particular the collision involving bear Juan Carrito and the shooting of bear Amarena. Mauro Belardi, biologist, explains: "The low number of animals of reproductive age makes the situation critical. It is expected that in the coming year genetic monitoring of the individuals present in the territory will be organised. In the Alps, the population still sees the females' range confined to western Trentino, with dispersing males venturing further afield."

On the conservation front, the most significant news is the presence for two years of several females with cubs in the province of Brescia. The approximately one hundred individuals and the high density in western Trentino is, on the other hand, the most pressing issue where bears are concerned. This is a problem that cannot be managed by the province of Trento alone at this point in time. "The growth of the bear population is in line with projections, but the distribution range is more limited. At the moment the Alpine population is in good demographic health, but political exploitation and, looking ahead, genetic impoverishment too, mean the species in the Alps must be considered to be in a conservation status that is certainly inadequate and not out of danger," the expert warns.

cucciolo orso
A young bear tries out its climbing skills © Pixabay

The Marsican brown bear

The Marsican brown bear (Ursus arctos marsicanus) is a subspecies of brown bear endemic to the central Apennines, long isolated geographically. These plantigrades differ from their relatives in their slightly smaller size. The name Marsican derives from Marsica, a south-western area of Abruzzo centred on Lake Fucino, which in antiquity was inhabited by the Marsi, an Italic people dating back to the first millennium BC. "The Marsican bear finds itself in a decidedly worrying situation. Numbers hover around 45 animals, the reproductive rate is limited, many bears have moved outside the Parco nazionale Lazio Abruzzo e Molise, venturing quite far afield — which also has positive aspects, but for the time being disperses the management of the species across many different bodies," the biologist points out.

The experts at Oipa (Organizzazione internazionale protezione animali) add: "While in Trentino bears are deemed too numerous and some administrators are pushing for culling, the Parco nazionale del Gran Sasso e Monti della Laga announces that it wishes to resort to "assisted reproduction" to increase the number of Marsican bears. We ask ourselves whether this will not then result in a density that creates problems of coexistence with local communities, with potential consequences for the plantigrades themselves. It is important to stress, however, that the project will need to be carried out with great care and that its priority must be to protect not only the species, but also individual specimens." This is undoubtedly a debatable piece of news and one worth examining more closely, given the nature of the bear and its status as a wild species that is difficult to manage.

grizzly
The American grizzly is one of the largest bears in existence © Pixabay

Are bears genuinely protected across the national territory?

Is the bear truly protected in our country? Or is the situation of the great plantigrade largely in the hands of political questions and party disputes? "At present, possible culls or removals are permitted by applying the derogations provided for in the Habitats Directive. In the Alps, the guidelines for these removals are set out in a dedicated paragraph and summarised in a table within the Pacobace (the Conservation Plan for the Brown Bear in the central-eastern Alps). The table, contrary to what is constantly being stated these days, is not a technical instrument, but rather a statement that was voted on (and occasionally amended) politically, while nonetheless having a clear technical basis. From an ethological standpoint, culling is justified by the reasonable probability that a bear may repeat dangerous or problematic behaviour. However, in the current table there is considerable technical confusion, since aggressive bears, bold bears and even nuisance bears are all lumped together as candidates for possible removal," explains Mauro Belardi.

A specific ongoing debate concerns the behaviour known as a mock charge, which is a strategy that bears all over the world employ with a certain frequency and which, if treated as synonymous with aggression, would certainly lead to drawing up a list of a great many animals deemed "eligible for culling," without any particular basis. Not to mention that it would, in effect, signal a desire not to have bears on the territory at all.

Scant — indeed very scant — knowledge of the species' ethological mechanisms, and a fundamental ignorance of the plantigrade's behaviour, lie at the root of all this, one might add. And disinformation, unfortunately, appears to pervade media outlets and animal welfare circles alike, which are often the source of alarmism and exaggerations with no real foundation.

orsi
Bears on our peninsula are coming under sustained attack, above all from the very institutions that should be protecting them © Pixabay

"Regarding the supposed resolution passed for the culling of eight bears in Trentino — Belardi continues — it should be clarified that Trentino has, in the past, issued others with a predominantly political purpose." In this case the only novelty is that Ispra has stated that the maximum number of annual removals that the Alpine population could sustain without compromising its favourable conservation status is, precisely, eight. Each removal will nonetheless have to comply with the same previously authorised procedures — that is, it must concern problematic bears, satisfy the Pacobace table and obtain a positive opinion from Ispra. The recent policy of the Province of Trentino that is by far more worrying, in my view, is not the removals policy, but the desire to prevent the population from expanding towards eastern Trentino, something that could increase problems of overcrowding, with no scientific or legal justification whatsoever. I repeat, however, that what I consider most serious is not the culling of dangerous individuals — which may be necessary — but the position held by part of the environmental and scientific worlds, who believe that culls are necessary to increase acceptance and reduce conflict. This is a claim entirely devoid of scientific evidence or supporting experience: a mere hope repeated like a mantra.

"Bear conservation is achieved by implementing and updating the so-called Conservation Plans. At present the Pacobace needs updating, but no one is dealing with it, the signatories besides Trentino are nowhere to be found, 90 per cent of what is written in it is unapplied, and all the attention — including that of the environmental world — is devoted solely to the small table authorising culls. And that is a major defeat, above all on a cultural level," Belardi concludes.

A defeat, one might add, that once again undermines the peaceful coexistence of human beings with nature and the creatures that inhabit it. A natural world that, until the affronts perpetrated by humankind, had preserved intact its own laws and modes of expression dating back hundreds and hundreds of years.