Killing 8 bears a year through to 2026: the decision of the Province of Trento

Killing 8 bears a year through to 2026: the decision of the Province of Trento

Environment · ·

The Province of Trento will be allowed to cull up to 8 bears a year: animal welfare associations are ready to appeal in every judicial forum.

Brace yourselves for more M90-style cases. The Province of Trento will be allowed to cull up to 8 bears a year in 2024 and 2025, in order to "contain the growth trend of the bear population in Trentino", which according to the latest estimate set out in the Rapporto grandi carnivori 2022 exceeds 100 individuals (including cubs). From 2026 onwards, the maximum number of bears to be culled will be redefined together with Ispra, on the basis of updated demographic data.

Up to 8 bears a year, of which only 4 adults

The Provincial Council, in the late evening of Monday 4 March, definitively approved the bill that had been passed in January, on the proposal of forestry councillor Roberto Failoni, and which confirms the power of the President of the Province of Trento to order the culling of individual problem specimens (up to a maximum of 8 bears a year) as a measure of permanent removal from the natural environment. Exactly as was done by President Maurizio Fugatti only last 6 February with M90, the bear that was habituated to humans (but never aggressive towards them) and was culled for having followed a young couple for a few hundred metres. Not only that: the law provides that among these 8 bears a year there must be no more than two adult females and no more than two adult males, meaning the remaining 4 will evidently be young specimens.

Proteste degli #animalisti e #Trento contro la legge "ammazza orsi", che, se varata, consentirebbe alla Provincia di uccidere fino a 8 orsi in 3 anni. Quando un'attivista è stata portata fuori dal palazzo, ci sono stati attimi di tensione e scontri fra manifestanti e #polizia.

While the Provincial Council was approving the text yesterday, a live protest by several animal welfare and environmental associations was taking place outside — associations that had already risen up when, at the time of M90's culling, they had not even been given time to lodge an appeal with the TAR.

The outrage of animal welfare associations

According to Councillor Failoni, "this is an important change of pace" that puts a brake on "the surge in the population of plantigrades, guaranteeing people's safety, while also improving working conditions for farmers and those who work in forest environments". For WWF, however, the decision by the Autonomous Province of Trento, which gives the green light to the killing of 8 bears a year, "is demagogic and is based on assumptions that the majority of scientific studies and international experience contradict: culling is not the right path to mitigating conflict and promoting coexistence. Once again, the authority instead chooses the path of the easy shortcut to tackle in the worst possible way the issue of coexistence between humans and large carnivores." According to animal welfare associations, "those who today are approving the culling of 8 problem bears a year have done far too little in recent years in the field of prevention and communication. What has been lacking is adequate information and awareness work directed at resident populations, along with concrete action in the field of conflict prevention and the emergence of problem behaviour in bears."

Approvata la legge per abbattere fini a 8 orsi l’anno. OIPA: «La Provincia di Trento maglia nera in tutela della biodiversità e primo premio in mancata prevenzione. Daremo battaglia» 👉oipa.org/italia/orsi-tr…

Oipa, the international animal protection organisation, also reiterates that the bear is protected by national and EU provisions and announces it will fight back: first by launching an EU Pilot procedure, a cooperation mechanism between the European Commission and member states that allows verification of whether Union law is being respected and correctly applied, and by challenging before the Trento Administrative Court of Justice any orders and decrees issued by President Fugatti should he identify individual specimens for culling — with the option of subsequently appealing to the Constitutional Court.