Wild boar roam the streets of Rome. And politicians can think of nothing better than threatening to cull them. Meanwhile, wolves in Sweden are at serious risk
Wild boar have become an unwelcome presence across Italy, and Rome is not immune to their increasingly widespread invasion.
Political decisions weigh heavily on the situation and offer little sign of a way forward in how Italy manages it.
Meanwhile, Sweden is also seeking to reduce the number of wolves, in breach of EU directives on wild animals.
Wild boar have invaded Rome. Heedless of amendments and position statements from politicians and experts, in recent days even the magnificent Villa Pamphili was closed because a number of ungulates were roaming undisturbed among the trees and bushes. And as if that were not enough, shortly before, a man on a scooter had ended up in a coma following a close encounter with a wild boar. It is a red-alert situation that is sorely testing the nerves of the capital's residents, yet it could have been both foreseen and contained had adequate measures been taken in time. But the exponential increase in wild animals — wolves above all — appears to be worrying even the highly civilised Sweden, which is planning — provided it manages to obtain the necessary resolutions — to limit the number of these predators that, according to the Swedish authorities, have now become too numerous on national soil. What is happening? We asked experts to help us try to draw up some guidelines that might help us understand.
Recently the government introduced, through the budget law, an amendment authorising the containment of species deemed "dangerous" to agriculture, road traffic and public safety. This type of control is considered an activity that does not coincide with hunting practice and has therefore been deemed permissible even in urban and protected areas, with no particular restrictions, on the condition that these containment activities must always be carried out by persons holding a hunting licence and operating under the supervision of the carabinieri forestali. The measure is currently awaiting an opinion from the Ministry of the Environment and Energy Security, given also that a large part of the directives are, according to experts and animal welfare associations, to be considered unlawful.
"The measure is dreadful, both in its approach and in the unacceptable vision it embodies, which sees culling as the only solution to problems relating to wildlife — all without the slightest concern for evaluating different solutions that are ethically and scientifically sounder," explains Ermanno Giudici, writer and blogger.
"It must be said," he continues, "that the amendment in question diverts personnel — already in short supply — from the carabinieri forestali, who are burdened with this additional task, which can be read as a desire to reduce their operational capacity in combating crimes relating to the environment and biodiversity. However, claiming that this regulation has authorised an uncontrolled urban wild west, culminating in the episode of a hunter who fired from a window at a wild boar and hit a car instead, is a falsehood that neither politicians nor the media should be riding. All this does is create misinformation and helps spread the erroneous news that anyone can carry out culls, without any rules."
Unfortunately, the root of the wild boar problem in urban areas lies above all in the increasingly evident degradation of metropolitan areas overrun by waste of every kind and bins that are not emptied regularly. All of this drives wild animals — wild boar and foxes above all — to gradually encroach on the territory in search of food that is easy and accessible to the group.
On this point, the position of animal welfare associations is unequivocal, as a press release from Oipa, theOrganizzazione internazionale protezione animale, makes clear: "Hunting and selection policies are not the solution to the problem of wild boar proliferation — they are its cause. This is attested to by ethologists, zoologists and naturalists. The presence of wild boar in cities is due above all to improper waste collection. Furthermore, further upstream still, there is the restocking policy of past years. It is worth knowing that the ungulates populating Italy today, larger and more prolific than the native ones, were introduced from Eastern European countries for the use and benefit of hunters, who are now being called upon to solve a problem they themselves created."
And with regard to the wild boar invasion at Villa Pamphili, Alessandro Piacenza, wildlife officer at the animal welfare association, adds that alongside a metropolitan cleanliness policy and proper waste collection, what is also needed is the correct use of deterrents — from chemical sterilisation to targeted capture — already under study by the Ministry of Health. Oipa also calls for captured wild boar to be sent to dedicated facilities rather than culled, thereby respecting Article 9 of the Constitution, which also protects animals.
One might be tempted to say: live by nature, die by nature. The phenomenon of wild animals becoming increasingly bold towards human beings has many causes and many facets. All of them, however, are rooted in humanity's inability to understand nature and relate to it. The decimation of wild boar, wolves and bears also triggers a complex natural phenomenon. Females, if deprived of the alpha male, tend to mate with the remaining individuals, subverting and accelerating the natural rhythm of their breeding cycles, with the sole purpose of producing new individuals to repopulate the group. The phenomenon therefore has the paradoxical and uncontrollable effect of increasing the number of wild animals.
The recent Swedish position, which provides for the culling of 75 wolves from an estimated population of 460 individuals, has sparked considerable controversy. And the standoff with the European Union already looks set to be long and complicated. The population of these predators, in Sweden and neighbouring Norway, had been almost wiped out around 1970, as demonstrated by a study carried out by Ntnu, the Norwegian University of Science and Technology, and the University of Copenhagen. Ermanno Giudici points out: "The wolves currently present in the territory turn out to have come from neighbouring Finland, from where they arrived to occupy the ecological niches left vacant as a result of humans progressively moving to metropolitan areas.
Attacks on the apex predator, however, are not coming only from Northern Europe, but also from Switzerland, which recently made an unsuccessful attempt to have the wolf's status under the Bern Convention changed from "strictly protected" to "protected". This would have allowed the Swiss Confederation to implement further pack-thinning measures in a country where conflicts between predators and livestock farmers are fairly frequent."
But while the scientific community continues to sound the alarm, urging the need to implement every possible action for the conservation of biodiversity — the only way to keep the environment in balance — politics, in Sweden as in Italy, seems more interested in following the views of certain electoral groups rather than those of science. And it tries to keep up its constant policy of trying to please all sides at once.
Essentially the same view is held by biologist Mauro Belardi, an expert in environmental sustainability and president of the Eliante cooperative: "Sweden is an EU member, so any derogation from the ban on culling must comply with Article 16 of the Habitats Directive, which states that killings must be justified and limited, can only be requested if the species is in a favourable conservation status, and that alternative solutions must first have been attempted, etc. It should also be noted that wolf density in Sweden is very low compared to the European average. This is the source of the controversy, as the Swedish measure clearly does not comply with the directive."
Will European politicians take note, or will they prefer to appease those sections of the electorate — livestock farmers, hunters, agricultural workers — who are able to sustain political activity? It is not easy to give an answer given the current state of affairs. The coming months and years will be crucial in trying to understand whether human activity can coexist in harmony with the laws of nature, or whether, once again, we will witness the bullying and attempted annihilation of the weakest. In this case, animals.
When animals are held hostage by politics: the case of wild boar and wolves
Environment — di Brunella Paciello
Wild boar roam the streets of Rome. And politicians can think of nothing better than threatening to cull them. Meanwhile, wolves in Sweden are at serious risk