A bear has killed a man, but we must not restart the war on nature

A bear has killed a man, but we must not restart the war on nature

Rights · ·

The tragic death of Andrea Papi, a runner killed by a bear in Trentino, has reopened the debate on coexistence between humans and large carnivores.

A bear has killed a man in Trentino, and this is a tragedy from every point of view. First and foremost for the victim, Andrea Papi, whose young life was cut short in a sudden and violent way, for his family and for the community of which he was part, shaken by grief and by a sense of vulnerability unknown until a few days ago. But also for the bear that killed him, against which a death sentence has been issued, and for the other bears and large carnivores in general, who were already poorly tolerated by a large section of the Italian population before this incident, and who will now have to face an intensified climate of hatred. This tragedy, however, while respecting the pain it has caused, must be analysed and contextualised, understood to some degree, as we try for a moment to set aside the horror that an event of this kind — the killing of a man by a large carnivore — can arouse.

Alpi trentine
Landscape of the Trentino Alps, home to a number of bear specimens © iStockphoto

What happened in Trentino

Andrea Papi, 26 years old from Caldes, in the province of Trento, was killed on the evening of 5 April by a bear he encountered on his way back from a training run through the woods of Monte Peller, which forms part of the Brenta Dolomites. From the outset, based on the marks found on the man's body, an attack by a bear was suspected. The attack was subsequently confirmed by the results of the autopsy, which identified a deep cut to the neck as the fatal wound. The president of the autonomous province of Trento, Maurizio Fugatti, immediately signed an order providing for the capture and culling of the bear following genetic identification. Genetic analyses, according to statements from the Trento public prosecutor's office, revealed that the animal that killed Papi was the bear known as Jj4, a 17-year-old female, daughter of Joze and Jurka and sister of Jj1, killed in Germany in 2006. The forestry carabinieri are now searching for the bear, whose radio collar is currently out of charge.

Woods can be dangerous

The sequence of events leading up to the attack is not yet clear, and some answers we will never have. It is, however, very likely that this was an accident, an exceptional and unfortunate event. Reconstructions suggest that the bear was behind a blind bend, and that the young man, running, suddenly appeared in front of it, startling the animal and triggering its reaction. The biology and ethology of the bear suggest that this was not a premeditated attack, not an ambush by the large animal. The primary cause of brown bear attacks on humans is not predation, but the bear's reaction to surprise. Inside a dense forest we can be invisible until the very last moment, particularly when moving into the wind, risking a sudden encounter with a bear around a corner. It is no coincidence that shops in Yellowstone sell hikers small bells that jingle with every step, to signal their presence to the bears. The death of the young runner reminds us, above all, that forests and mountains can be dangerous places over which we cannot exercise total control, and in which, simply put, zero risk does not exist. It is nonetheless necessary to seek coexistence, investing in information and in the preparedness of those who frequent certain areas, because it has by now been demonstrated that eliminating all predators is counterproductive.

The return of predators

We have no memory — our collective recollections usually go back only a few generations — by which to compare the current situation. We know only a tamed Europe, inevitably shaped by millennia of human activity. Yet the old continent has looked as it does today for only a very short time, an extremely brief interval in the history of life on Earth. For hundreds of thousands of years Europe was an enormous expanse of forests and grasslands, steppes and marshes, glaciers, rivers and lakes. It makes no sense to take as a benchmark a nature that has reached alarming peaks of depletion. Bears were present in the Alps, they lived there for a long time, until they were wiped out. Now science tells us clearly and unequivocally that large carnivores are needed, that they are fundamental to the balance of an ecosystem. We cannot treat nature as our own back garden and reshape it to human scale at any cost. Not least because we would be doing ourselves a disservice first of all: a degraded environment harms all species, including our own. It is precisely to reverse this destructive process that conservation projects have been established, and, for certain species, reintroduction projects.

Why the bear was reintroduced

Such is the case with the Life Ursus project, funded by the European Union and heavily criticised in recent days, which between the late 1990s and the early 2000s rebuilt a small bear population in the Italian Alps, starting from ten Slovenian individuals, in the very area where the last native bears in western Trentino had been hunted in the late 1990s. The brown bear had in fact been driven to extinction by unrestrained hunting across most of the Alps, wiped out within half a century or a little more, between the mid and late 1800s. The last cullings, around 1970, involved young dispersing males from western Trentino. There were no longer any bears in the Italian Alps. "The Life Ursus project, which brought about the rebirth of the bear in Trentino through the transfer of bears from Slovenia, was the last, carefully considered, strongly desired and scrupulously executed action in a long pursuit aimed at saving the brown bear of the Alps from extinction," wrote Matteo Zeni, a former forest ranger, in his book In nome dell'orso.

How dangerous are bears

The attack that claimed Andrea Papi's life is the first fatal bear mauling in Italy. According to the scientific paper Brown bear attacks on humans: a worldwide perspective, published in Nature in 2019, between 2000 and 2015 there were 664 bear attacks worldwide; of these, 95 were fatal, including 19 in Europe (eleven in Romania, two each in Sweden and Ukraine, one each in Greece, Bulgaria, Poland and Finland), 24 in North America and 52 in the eastern region (Russia, Iran and Turkey). A fatal attack by a bear is therefore a rare occurrence, even in countries such as Sweden and Romania that are home to thousands of bears, compared to the hundred living in Trentino — yet it receives enormous media and emotional coverage. Perhaps because, as David Quammen suggests (yes, the same writer who warned us about pandemics in Spillover) in his book Monster of God, the brown bear, like other large carnivores, reminds us of an aspect of the human condition we have forgotten, or rather concealed through the extermination of predators: that we too can be prey, and that we cannot exclude ourselves from the food chain. "Six billion human beings now weigh upon this planet," writes Quammen, "and the alpha predators face extinction. Already they are being pushed to the margins, reduced in number, deprived of their living space, confined to inadequate refuges, and here and there exterminated. This tendency foreshadows the definitive separation from Homo sapiens, and the end of our ancient relationship with them. Throughout our entire history as a species — for tens and hundreds of millennia, for almost two million years — we have tolerated the dangerous, problematic presence of the great predators, finding roles for them in our emotional universe. But today our numbers, our power, our solipsism have brought us to a point where tolerance is unnecessary and dangers of this kind are unacceptable."

mamma orso e cuccioli
The aim of rewilding is to restore ecological interactions and dynamics © iStockphoto

(Re)learning to live with the wild

In other parts of the world, what emerges from the relationship between traditional human communities and large predators — in many cases belonging to species far more dangerous than those we might encounter here — is a form of respect, which sometimes even becomes veneration, with roots stretching back to antiquity, yet grounded in an awareness of the risk inherent in sharing a natural environment. What we have lost, through the extinction or decimation of certain species, is the habit of coexisting, of knowing the other, of interacting enough to develop a degree of mutual wariness. In Italy, with the exception of certain areas such as Abruzzo, we are no longer accustomed to sharing the landscape with large, potentially dangerous animals. And yet large animals are returning, partly thanks to rewilding projects that are gaining traction across Europe. "Rewilding, unlike conservation, has no fixed goal: it is not driven by human managers but by natural processes. The main purpose of rewilding is to restore ecological interactions and dynamics to the greatest possible extent. In other words, the ecological principle behind rewilding is the restoration of what ecologists call trophic diversity," explains George Monbiot in the book Feral. The effects that certain species have on the entire ecosystem they inhabit are remarkable. Predators and large herbivores have, in some cases, altered the nature of the soil, the chemistry of the oceans and the composition of the atmosphere. These discoveries have required a rethinking of an older conservation model, and it has become increasingly important to reintroduce large predators and other vanished species in order to try to restore those delicate ecological mechanisms on which our own wellbeing also depends.

Another path towards coexistence

The bear that killed Papi, Jj4, known as Gaia, will be killed. The hope is that this action will be considered and deemed necessary, not mere revenge — because in that case it would be difficult to conceal the irrationality of seeking vengeance on a wild animal, perpetrated by a species that prides itself on rationality above all else. Killing the bear that killed Papi, should it truly prove to be a dangerous and aggressive animal, would be understandable in the absence of alternatives, but non-lethal solutions should be preferred. Otherwise it would amount to, in the words of Baptiste Morizot, "reacting through fear, re-establishing a world order and avenging the violation of a taboo." "The two options offered by Western culture for interpreting the encounter with the bear (facing the beast or welcoming the friend)," writes Baptiste Morizot in the book Tracks and Traces — "both refer back to a distorted conception of our relations with the living world: on the one hand, the despotic myth that holds that nature must be defeated in order to civilise it; on the other, an Arcadian ecology that dreams of a nature free from hostility. But wild animals are not our friends, as the contemporary illusion would have it — one that elevates our domestic animals to the model of all animality; nor are they beasts to be overcome in order to fulfil our destiny as civilisers. We must seek another path, other models for thinking about our relations with them, such as their alterity." All of us — but particularly those who share their territory with large carnivores — are today being asked to partly revise our habits and our relationship with natural spaces, and to find a form of courage that enables us to confront an alterity without concluding that, because it is dangerous, it constitutes an absolute enemy.