Violence against the LGBT community in Indonesia is on the rise. What the country must do to address the issue in the face of growing religious and political radicalism and a lack of laws and acceptance.
**Violence** against lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people is increasing across many regions of Indonesia. Religious traditionalism and political agendas are obstructing the social and cultural process that would allow people to form their own views on the role the LGBT community plays within society. Law enforcement is needed to prevent these people from falling victim to disrespectful behaviour and violence, so that the country can carry forward the debate on the subject in a civil manner.
Indonesia has recently witnessed a succession of acts of violence against the LGBT community. For example, in January in the Indonesian province of Aceh, where the sacred Islamic law of Sharia is in force, police targeted twelve people presumed to be transgender, or waria in Indonesian, with the support of the local population. During a raid on several beauty salons on 27 January, these individuals were forced to remove their shirts and have their hair cut in public, before being taken to prison and made to perform physical exercise and vocal drills to become more "macho".
Suara Kita, an organisation that campaigns for transgender rights, stated that only one of the twelve people was actually transgender. Three of them were regular customers of the beauty salon, while all the others worked there. After the incident, traumatised and fearing for their safety, they decided to flee to Medan and the surrounding area, in the province of North Sumatra.
Traditionally, the Indonesian people are accustomed to the concept of transgender or waria, a term used to describe men who dress and behave like women. Indeed, waria are present among the Bugis ethnic group, a people found in South Sulawesi, and in certain traditional dances. The country, however, regards it as a "condition" dictated by behaviour rather than an integral part of a person's identity, and sexual orientation is not usually discussed in public.
Fluid sexuality is instead accepted with empathy when it is linked to physical characteristics or biological aspects, such as in the case of children born with both genitals or with a prevalence of male or female hormones. Historically, waria have always been part of the family and the community, even though they have never held positions of importance. Singer and actress Dorce Gamalama is a trans woman whose fame can be compared to that of Oprah Winfrey in the United States, demonstrating a certain level of tolerance towards waria.
Until recently, attempts to change the identity of transgender people were limited to more moderate approaches, such as those adopted by religious leaders (not only Islamic ones), and the use of violence was not common — to such an extent that an Islamic boarding school for transgender people was even established in the city of Yogyakarta, offering training and education. Meanwhile, waria seek to advance the struggle for their own rights, such as obtaining gender status on national identity cards, and to change the perception that associates them exclusively with sex work.
In general, Indonesian society is less accustomed to homosexual and bisexual people than it is to transgender people, because they are considered harder to accept given that their identity is more directly linked to explicit sexual preferences.
Over the past twenty years, the LGBT community in Indonesia has grown and become increasingly open and visible. The presence of transgender people is no longer associated with a specific profession: being LGBT has become part of one's identity and a lifestyle that is leaning ever more towards Western customs, such as in clothing and the consumption of alcohol and cigarettes. Finally, speaking openly about one's sexual orientation in public is no longer considered as much of a taboo as it once was.
Despite this, public attitudes towards transgender people and the LGBT community in general have changed dramatically. Antipathy has turned into outright rejection or even phobia. A survey conducted by Saiful Mujani Research and Consulting in December 2017 showed that more than 87 per cent of respondents felt threatened by LGBT people, and more than 53 per cent do not accept the idea of having a person of this sexual orientation in their own family.
Religion is one of the main causes behind this lack of acceptance. Even though Indonesia is not a country based on religion, it has a strong influence on the rules of society. By law, Indonesia recognises five religions, but Islam is the most widespread. According to Islamic teachings, homosexuality is a sin, though the interpretation of this rule is divided between more radical and more moderate approaches. In the current social and political climate, it is the radical approach that is gaining the most ground.
Violence against LGBT people has worsened in tandem with growing religious conservatism, which has intensified in recent years particularly ahead of regional and national elections. The trump card for winning more votes has been the exploitation of religion-related issues, thereby making minorities easy targets. For example, the 212 Muslim Movement succeeded in impeaching the incumbent governor of the Indonesian capital, Basuki Tjahaja Purnama, also known as Ahok, ultimately securing his imprisonment for blasphemy against Islam. Of Chinese origin, Purnama was a popular figure and champion of the province's development, reducing bureaucratic delays and jailing corrupt officials. He has now been sentenced to several years in prison for blasphemy. As a consequence of all this, the candidates backed by the 212 movement won the elections.
In this context, local governments and law enforcement do not intervene in acts of violence against the LGBT community, turning a blind eye or, worse, personally taking part in the violence. The Indonesian Legal Aid Institute (Ylbhi) documented at least 66 cases of violence during 2017. A further example is the survey conducted in April 2016 by the Wahid Foundation, a think tank on democracy and Islamic culture, on the communities least accepted by society, which showed that LGBT people were ranked alongside "communists" and people of Chinese ethnicity.
To date, at national level there are no specific laws on LGBT rights. There is only a marriage law that permits marriages and divorces solely between people of the same religion, but none of the recognised religions allows unions between people of the same sex. In cases where charges against LGBT people fell within the penal code (Kuhp), they were placed in the category of harassment, governed by article 292 of the penal code — the same article used in cases of child harassment, for example. Riding the wave of a push for a general overhaul of the penal code, opponents of LGBT people have proposed expanding it to make homosexuality between adults illegal, with a penalty of up to nine years in prison.
This amendment has sparked a major debate among activists and communities, not least because its passage through parliament has been very slow and mired in political conflicts over vote-winning. Zulkifli Hasan, speaker of the People's Consultative Assembly (upper house, Mpr), stated that five of parliament's ten factions have accepted the revision, without specifying which ones. This revision has made very little progress in the People's Representative Council (lower house, Dpr), as absences during the sessions dedicated to debating the amendment have prevented a decision from being reached.
Some regional governments have created local laws on this issue. In the case of Aceh, for example, the chief of police, as a representative of the local government, has claimed the right to apply Sharia law, given that the province holds a special regional autonomy status known as Daerah Istimewa. This means that the central government has no power to intervene. Furthermore, this type of autonomy requires that regional and national laws do not conflict with one another.
Now that Indonesia is entering its most heated political phase ahead of the 2019 elections, the need for legal certainty on the LGBT issue is urgent. The government must act and play a more active role in preventing antipathy from turning into hate speech, physical violence, intimidation and expulsion from neighbourhoods, so as to avoid this minority finding itself increasingly at the centre of such clashes. The tyranny of the majority is unacceptable. The LGBT question in Indonesia is a sociocultural process that cannot be resolved in a hasty manner. By creating robust laws, the government would enable debate within a healthy democracy, in a safe and equal environment for all.
What it means to be LGBT in Indonesia, between violence and traditionalism
Rights — di Novrida Masli
Violence against the LGBT community in Indonesia is on the rise. What the country must do to address the issue in the face of growing religious and political radicalism and a lack of laws and acceptance.