What Islamic finance is and why it has a positive social impact

What Islamic finance is and why it has a positive social impact

Environment · ·

Thanks to its ethical foundations, Islamic finance attracts those seeking fair financial products, proving itself an important tool for financing positive social impact.

Sharia is the Islamic canonical law founded on the teachings of the Quran and the Prophet Muhammad, a set of disciplines and principles that govern the behaviour of a Muslim towards others, including in matters of investment and financial instruments. Sharia explains in detail the Islamic concepts of money and capital, the relationship between risk and profit, and the social responsibilities of financial institutions and individuals.

What Islamic investments are

On the basis of this philosophy, Islamic finance has developed and used Sharia-compliant instruments and techniques for financial activities around the world. The fundamental concept of Islamic finance is that money has no intrinsic value, but is a simple means of exchange. The two most important elements of the Islamic financial world are banking services and the sukuk market (the Islamic equivalent of the bond market). Other services include leasing, the stock market, investment funds, insurance (takaful), reinsurance activities (retakaful) and microfinance.

Segments of Islamic finance

Source: State of the global Islamic economy report 2016/17
SegmentValue (billions of dollars)
Islamic banking sector assets1,451
Takaful/retakaful assets37.7
Sukuk outstanding342
Islamic funds net asset value66.4
Other106

The most important prohibitions in Islamic finance

A Muslim is not permitted to benefit from money lending. Furthermore, it is forbidden to pay or receive interest (riba), to be involved in financial activities that carry excessive uncertainty (gharar), and one may not invest in prohibited sectors (haram).

What riba is

Riba is a concept that in Islamic banking refers to the charging of interest, which is forbidden under Sharia law because it is considered a form of usury. Riba creates social injustice because those who grant loans with interest tend to profit from the weaker position of those who take them out. For a mortgage, for instance, an Islamic bank does not lend money to an individual so that they can buy a property, but purchases the property directly. The customer can buy it back from the bank (at a higher price) by paying in instalments (murabahah), or by making monthly payments that include the purchase and rental of the property until it becomes theirs (ijara). Similarly, those who hold sukuk (bonds) technically do not lend money to the issuer, but buy a nominal share of the assets on which the money has been spent. Moreover, they do not earn from interest, but from the profit generated by that asset or from the rental payments made by the issuer. At maturity, the issuer returns the principal to the investor by buying back the shares of the asset.

bank islam
An employee of Bank Islam in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia © Tengku Bahar/AFP/Getty Images

What gharar is

Gharar is an Arabic word associated with uncertainty, deception and risk. Gharar is forbidden because Islam prescribes strict rules against highly uncertain transactions (similar to gambling). This includes the prohibition of classic financial practices such as certain forms of insurance (such as the purchase of premiums to insure against something that may or may not happen); short selling (short selling), that is, the sale of a security that is not owned by the seller; speculation, meaning trading that is not aimed at obtaining the underlying product; and derivatives, a contract between two parties that derives its value or price from assets such as stocks, bonds or commodities.

The prohibition on "sin stocks"

Not far removed from the concept of responsible investment, Islamic investments exclude companies that are forbidden under Islamic law (haram) by not investing money in them. The so-called sin stocks include companies that profit from the sale of alcohol, pork-based products, pornography, gambling, military equipment or weapons.

A brief history of the spread of Islamic finance

Islamic finance began gaining popularity in the mid-1970s, in conjunction with and in response to the growth of oil wealth in Islamic states, which increased interest in and demand for Sharia-compliant products and practices. The Islamic financial market amounts to two trillion dollars in assets, based on 2015 figures reported by all Islamic finance institutions together with sukuk and Islamic funds (and is expected to reach 3.5 trillion by 2021), according to the State of the global Islamic economy report 2016/2017. Islamic finance has outperformed conventional finance, with a penetration rate increase of at least 15 per cent in the Middle East and Asia. Sukuk issuances increased twentyfold, reaching 120 billion dollars in 2013, with new issuances in Africa, the Far East and Europe.

Top Islamic financial markets

Source: State of the global Islamic economy report 2016/17
CountryAssets (billions of dollars)
Iran343.7
Saudi Arabia342.7
Malaysia230.3
United Arab Emirates134.2
Kuwait95.5
Qatar72.6
Bahrain69.2
Turkey44.5
Bangladesh23.1
Indonesia23

The positive social impact

According to Sharia, money is not equivalent to wealth, but is a means through which we can create a system of production and trade and generate a social impact in sectors such as culture, health, education and infrastructure. Islamic finance has proved to be an effective tool for financing development around the world, including in non-Muslim countries, as stated by the World Bank. Furthermore, given that Islamic investments place asset-backed finance and risk-sharing at the forefront, they offer alternative sources of funding for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and investments in public infrastructure. For example, Malaysia has used sukuk to build roads, airports and other large infrastructure projects, while the Islamic Development Bank (Idb) lent 150 million dollars through Islamic financial institutions for the new Lekki port in Nigeria. This factor is very important because the infrastructure needs of developing countries will continue to grow in the coming decades and, at present, cannot be met by public investment or traditional bank financing. The emphasis placed on tangible assets ensures that the industry supports only transactions that serve a real purpose, thus discouraging financial speculation.

Because of the ethical foundations of Islamic finance and the poor performance of conventional banks following the financial crisis, Islamic investments also attract non-Muslims seeking ethical investments or fair financial products. In 2013, for instance, the United Kingdom became the first Western country to issue sovereign sukuk.

The growth of Islamic finance

Since the onset of the 2008 financial crisis, Islamic finance has continued to expand at a rate of 17 per cent per year, helping to strengthen financial stability, as well as promoting the development of the financial sector and expanding financial inclusion. Of the 1.6 billion Muslims in the world (roughly a quarter of the global population), only 14 per cent use banks, with Islamic investments accounting for just 1 per cent of the world's financial assets. There is potential to expand Islamic finance, but it is held back by a lack of awareness of the options it offers. Even in those countries where Islamic finance has strong footholds, such as the Gulf states or South-East Asia, its activities rarely represent more than a third of the market.

islamic-finance-west.jpg
Source: Malaysia Islamic Financial Marketplace

The shadows of Islamic finance

Despite this, Islamic finance is in its early stages of development and still faces several challenges. At present, it is less profitable than the conventional banking system. A 2014 Ernst & Young report shows that shareholder returns are 20 per cent lower due to higher costs and operational inefficiencies. Islamic banks tend to be smaller, making it harder to achieve economies of scale. Furthermore, they are rather lacking in cross-selling (the ability to sell a customer additional products or services beyond what they had initially chosen), with an average of 2.1 products per customer, compared to 4.9 products per customer at conventional banks. Sukuk have not taken hold outside Malaysia due to the lack of stable regulatory frameworks and an economic environment that promotes them.

There is also less standardisation of available products due to differing interpretations by banks and jurisdictions of what is acceptable under Sharia law. For example, Goldman Sachs's attempt to enter the market failed because it was claimed that the proposed sukuk were not Sharia-compliant. Similarly, Indonesia was forced to scale back the issuance of a type of sukuk over similar claims.

sharia investment
An employee of Bank Negara Indonesia (Bni) in Jakarta, Indonesia © Adek Berry/AFP/Getty Images

This has led to calls for greater international standardisation, which in turn has led to the creation of the Islamic financial services board, which provides religious and decision-making guidance (playing a role similar to that of the Basel Committee for conventional banks).

Islamic banks have a strong desire to continue growing and to become more than a niche market, but they must compete with conventional banks to support the development of emerging economies and disadvantaged populations.