The City of Turin votes against the construction of the project and asks that the funds earmarked for the Turin–Lyon TAV be redirected to sustainable mobility.
Turin says no to the high-speed rail project, the TAV — the long-debated line that would connect the Piedmontese capital with the French city of Lyon. The motion proposed by the Five Star Movement, which called for a halt to construction work on the line as well as the resignation of the leadership of Telt (the body responsible for delivering the project) and of government special commissioner Paolo Foietta, and the conversion of the funds towards sustainable mobility initiatives, was indeed approved by the city council with 23 votes in favour and 2 against. Criticism came from both inside and outside the council chamber: while industrialists staged a rally in support of a "yes" to the TAV, all centre-left councillors — including former mayor Piero Fassino — were expelled from the chamber following fierce protests.
The city of Turin, which had formally stated its opposition to the project back in 2016, is now asking the government to block any further steps towards its advancement, at least until the ongoing cost-benefit analysis has concluded and its results, expected at the end of the year, are available.
Spending forecasts built on figures that have since been disproved
A cost-benefit analysis is an evaluation technique used to forecast the effects of a project, assessing whether its implementation would result in a net benefit or a net cost to society. Economists regard it as a tool to support public decision-making, since by monetising the benefits and costs associated with a project it identifies the best option among several alternatives.
The analysis awaited at the end of the year on the Turin–Lyon TAV is the second to be carried out on the project. The first was produced in 2012 directly by the observatory for the Turin–Lyon rail link, a body established in 2006 by ministerial decree specifically to oversee the project's design process. Not exactly an "independent body", as one might say — on the contrary, an organisation whose stated aims include "examining, assessing and responding to the concerns expressed by the communities of the Susa Valley", as reported in a summary document. Several municipalities in the Val di Susa, however, chose to withdraw from the observatory, disagreeing with the fact that the construction of the project itself was never called into question. Among them was the municipality of Turin, then led by the Five Stars.
The 2012 analysis not only arrived after the design phase was already under way (six years after the observatory was established), but it also failed to keep pace with subsequent developments: when the decision was taken to scale back the original project — that is, to opt for a low-cost TAV — no revision of the cost-benefit analysis followed, and its traffic forecasts were moreover largely disproved by the government in 2017: "There is no doubt that many forecasts made almost ten years ago, in absolute good faith, including those based on official European Union projections, have been contradicted by events … The current situation is therefore very different from the one in which those decisions were taken at the time," the Council of Ministers put on record in black and white. In the meantime, however, on the basis of the "old" project, at least 1.2 billion euros had already been spent on the design phase of the project and the start of excavation works.
Where things stand with the TAV and the work completed so far
Following the design phase, the Cipe (Interministerial Committee for Economic Planning), by a resolution published on 24 January 2018, ordered the construction of two construction lots of the cross-border base tunnel. This is a contract worth 5.57 billion euros on the Italian side, issued in the absence of any actual funding being in place. Indeed, neither France nor Europe has yet committed all the necessary funds, despite the agreement between Italy and France of 2012 explicitly stipulating that construction on the base tunnel cannot begin without all the funding for the entire project being secured. France has not only failed to include the projected expenditure for the cross-border base tunnel in its budget but, as stated in the motion tabled in Turin's city council, "has deferred until after 2038 any decision regarding the works on the section falling within its jurisdiction to be built on its territory (for example, the three tunnels at Belledonne, Glandon and Chartreuse)".
Approvato odg che impegna Sindaca e Giunta a chiedere a #Governo di “rendere pubblici e verificabili criteri, procedure e modalità di attuazione di una rigorosa Analisi Costi-Benefici da avviare su ipotesi nuova linea ferroviaria Torino-Lione” (#TAV):comune.torino.it/cittagora/in-e…
Furthermore, the construction lots, as explained in a complaint filed with the Court of Auditors by the Counter-observatory on the Turin–Lyon line, are not functional works, and therefore remain unusable until the entire project is complete. "There is no legal definition of what a construction lot is," explains the Counter-observatory in its complaint, "but in essence, given an overall public works project, it is a portion of the works that corresponds to the funding available at that point in time and is not in itself sufficient to complete the entire project. The lot as built serves no purpose in itself and cannot be used." The project therefore proceeds without any certainty that the works will ever be finished. And all of this, as already noted, on the basis of a cost-benefit analysis that has not been updated.
Penalties to pay? There's nothing in writing anywhere
Supporters of the "no" to the TAV consider the allocation of costs "disproportionate": as established by the 2012 agreement between Italy and France, the cross-border section is funded 57.9 per cent by Italy — on whose territory 12 kilometres out of a total of 57.5 lie, representing just 21 per cent of the route — and 42.1 per cent by France, on whose territory the remaining 45.5 kilometres run. This brings us to the point that project supporters keep pressing: the risk of having to pay penalties. Which, according to the Counter-observatory, is a myth. "There is no international agreement signed by Italy with France or Europe that provides for the payment of penalties in the event of a unilateral Italian withdrawal," reads the association's website. "The bilateral agreements between France and Italy contain no clause imposing on either party, in the event of withdrawal, any form of compensation for works carried out by the other party on its own territory … We stand ready to stand corrected if anyone can demonstrate otherwise."
Il bilanciamento del trasporto merci tra strada e ferrovia attraverso i valichi dovrà essere tra le priorità dei prossimi anni. [...] @Conftrasporto auspica una strategia uniforme d'intervento sui porti e sulla #ViadellaSeta che tuteli prima di tutto gli interessi nazionali.
On the pro-TAV side, Sergio Chiamparino, president of the Piedmont region, is calling for a referendum, while Paolo Foietta, the government commissioner for high-speed rail, speaks less of penalties and more of costs to be borne in the event of withdrawal: according to Foietta, the estimate would amount to over 2 billion euros, in addition to the risk of legal proceedings. The costs relate, again according to the commissioner, to the demobilisation of construction sites and equipment, the costs of making the works completed so far safe, and the repayment of EU funding already disbursed due to the failure to complete the remaining works. But the Counter-observatory has reiterated that, "in order to avoid any dispute with the European Union and with contractors", it is sufficient for "Telt not to launch tenders or enter into any commitment with anyone until such time as, in accordance with Article 16 of the Rome Agreement, the three financial backers of the Turin–Lyon project (the EU, France and Italy) have formally guaranteed, through statutory acts (laws of the state), all the funds necessary for the complete realisation of the project". Acts that have yet to materialise.
Turin says no to the TAV — what it means for the project and the funds allocated so far
Rights — di Maurizio Bongioanni
The City of Turin votes against the construction of the project and asks that the funds earmarked for the Turin–Lyon TAV be redirected to sustainable mobility.