For the first time in thirty years, some towns between Turin and Lyon have been left without water. The cause is believed to lie in the TAV construction works.
The potential collapse of the Ottone Rosai middle school in Florence could have cost the lives of the pupils and teachers going about their work. A disaster that might have marked the beginning of 2013, but which fortunately did not come to pass. As a result of the draining of aquifers and ground instability caused by construction of the high-speed Florence–Bologna railway tunnel (TAV), the school's walls had cracked dangerously, yet the structure did not give way. This line is now under investigation not only for the draining of watercourses, springs and aqueducts, but also for fraud and corruption. According to the Court of Auditors, the works caused public financial damage of 13.5 million euros. The same hydrogeological instability risks being repeated in the Val di Susa as a result of the works connected to the Turin–Lyon railway. Indeed, while the Bologna–Florence works caused 81 torrents, 37 springs, 30 wells and 5 aqueducts to disappear (a total of 100 kilometres of watercourses), data collected in the Val di Susa suggests that the impact on the water table will be no less devastating.
The TAV tunnel at Chiomonte is boring through a rock massif rich in water / GIUSEPPE CACACE/AFP/Getty Images
Water supply for one million people already lost
The consequences can be foreseen by looking at previous works in the valley, such as the doubling of the Turin–Modane railway line, which caused 24 springs to disappear; the motorway tunnels between Exilles and the Val Cenischia, which caused another 16 springs to vanish; and the works on the Pont Ventoux power station, which accounted for another ten or so. These are all tunnel works that have pierced the same massif through which the Turin–Lyon tunnel is now being excavated. This is highlighted by Massimo Zucchetti, a professor at the Politecnico di Torino who has been studying the impact of the high-speed line in the valley for years.
The loss of pressure caused by tunnel excavation leads to equally substantial water losses, and the project's own promoters have estimated that just the two tunnels on the international section (the base tunnel and the Bussoleno tunnel) would drain the water table by a total of between 60 and 125 million cubic metres of water per year, comparable to the supply needed by a city of around one million inhabitants, such as Turin. The analysis was provided by the International Consulting Group, the body commissioned by the European Commission's Directorate-General for Transport and Energy, which noted that the drainage of groundwater is "far from negligible". The drying up of springs and streams upstream of the excavations could even occur. In addition to causing acknowledged damage to the water needs of towns and villages, there would be serious consequences for agriculture, river flows and hydroelectric power generation. Despite these considerations, the analysis limits itself to recommending that "precautionary methods be developed, where appropriate".
Some hamlets in Chiomonte were left without water for the first time in thirty years / GIUSEPPE CACACE/AFP/Getty Images)
Chiomonte without water
Meanwhile in Chiomonte, where tunnel excavation works are under way, the first water tankers arrived in 2015 due to a shortage of drinking water in the town. The news came from local councillors Giorgio Guglielmo, Giuseppe Jonas and Remo Sibille. "The tankers had been preceded by the delivery of 25–30 litre water containers for the most urgent needs of the population. The situation deteriorated from 25 October 2015 to the point of all public fountains being shut off and consumption being rationed."
The Chiomonte municipal website publishes all reports containing data on the monitored water tables and, although reading that data does not reveal significant reductions in flow that would justify alarm, the actual situation – according to Guglielmo – is different: "Back in 2010 we had already presented, during a public meeting attended by no stakeholders, data on all the springs that had seen a reduction in the water table following the construction of the Turin–Bardonecchia motorway tunnels and the Point Ventoux power station. One of those springs, called Rigaud, was never monitored by the company responsible for the works because the municipality never reported it, for reasons unknown. We can only know the data for the Rigaud spring because that water table was monitored by the company (Iren) that was building the Pont Ventoux power station at the time."
The amount of water present in the rock is slowing down the TAV works and risks pushing up costs / PHILIPPE DESMAZES/AFP/Getty Images
The first time in thirty years
The data for the Rigaud spring was requested directly from the municipality of Chiomonte, but it only goes up to 2006. "So we requested it directly from Iren," Guglielmo stated. The data shows that from 1 June 1995 to 6 October 2015 (over 20 years of measurements) the reading never fell below 1 litre per second (indeed, for 2014 the figure was 3.21 litres per second). From October 2015 the situation deteriorated sharply, with the flow dropping to 0.4 litres per second (the last reading is from December 2015). For this reason, public fountains were reduced to a minimum or shut off entirely. "We cannot directly link this phenomenon to the excavation of the exploratory tunnel," Guglielmo continues. "But based on previous excavations, we have been left with some well-founded doubts."
Furthermore, a resolution by the Cipe (Interministerial Committee for Economic Planning) ordered the drawing up of a plan to manage a potential emergency, but so far nothing has been done. "They keep telling us there is no problem," Guglielmo concludes. "They say the cause should be sought elsewhere: from the works already carried out in the valley to drought. But these justifications seem superficial to us. We would like all springs to be monitored and included in intervention programmes." Only then will we have a clearer picture of what lies ahead.
TAV, the Turin–Lyon line will leave the Val di Susa without water
Mobility — di Maurizio Bongioanni
For the first time in thirty years, some towns between Turin and Lyon have been left without water. The cause is believed to lie in the TAV construction works.