TAV, pros and cons

TAV, pros and cons

Rights · ·

The railway line under construction in the Susa Valley is highly controversial. Here are some arguments for and against the TAV.

The logistical arguments for the TAV

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because without the Turin–Lyon high-speed rail line, Piedmont would be cut off from a European transport system that is increasingly moving towards high speed.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because Piedmont is already abundantly connected to Europe, above all through the Susa Valley. In this valley there are already two national roads, a motorway and a double-track passenger and freight railway line. There is even the so-called motorail service (the transport of lorries on special shuttle trains). These are all links with France via two natural mountain passes (Montgenèvre and Mont Cenis) and two artificial tunnels (the Fréjus rail tunnel and the Fréjus road tunnel).

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because the existing railway lines are at capacity.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because the current Turin–Modane railway line is used at only 38% of its capacity. The lorry shuttles depart every day depressingly empty (even though they are "rediscovered" and stormed whenever a fire breaks out in the Fréjus tunnel). The direct Turin–Lyon rail service has been discontinued due to lack of passengers. The flow of goods has not been growing for ten years.

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because the TAV will remove lorries from the Susa Valley.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because according to some studies only 1% of current road traffic will transfer to the railway. And the 10 to 15 years of construction work needed to build the Turin–Lyon line will bring 500 lorries a day (and night) onto the roads of the valley and the Turin outskirts, transporting excavated material from the tunnels to storage sites.

The environmental and landscape arguments for the TAV

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because the route of the high-speed line runs largely through tunnels. The landscape and environmental impact is minimal.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because the route includes a 23 km tunnel through the Musinè, a mountain containing asbestos. The boring machine that drills through the rock will release an incalculable quantity of invisible and lethal asbestos fibres into the air. The foehn wind could carry them as far as the centre of Turin. Breathing asbestos fibres causes a lung cancer (pleural mesothelioma). Asbestos has been an illegal material since 1977. Furthermore, the 53 km Italy–France tunnel bored through the Ambin Massif will encounter (in addition to water tables and springs that will be destroyed) rock containing uranium. Moreover, a tunnel route brings with it many smaller tunnels running transversally to the main one. These are called service tunnels, or "windows". There will be 12 of them, with as many construction sites, all close to inhabited centres. Furthermore, the boring of such long mountain stretches near densely populated centres could drain the water tables and water supplies, as happened with the TAV tunnels in the Mugello. And again: the road network will be thrown into chaos. Overpasses will be built at each construction site, with damage already evident on the Turin–Milan motorway for the TAV Turin–Novara section.

The economic arguments for the TAV

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because it is a major public works project and is good for the economy, also because it sets private capital in motion.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because the estimated cost of 20 billion euros is entirely borne by the community. All public money, but entrusted to private entities, in accordance with the general contractor model. The Italian State acts as guarantor. No private party will put in a single euro, especially after the experience of the Channel Tunnel, which bankrupted those who had bought its bonds. The enormous sums required for this project will be taken away from existing railway lines (already in a dire state), from hospitals, schools, public utility services and renewable energy. It is already projected that the new Turin–Lyon railway line will have very high operating costs and will run at a loss for decades. Moreover, despite the fact that most of the route runs through French territory, the Italian government has committed to shouldering the cost of two thirds of the international section (Borgone – St.-Jean-de-Maurienne).

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because the Turin–Lyon line will bring jobs to the people of Piedmont.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because, as has been the case for years with all infrastructure projects under way, the jobs would be precarious, carried out largely by non-EU labour. Furthermore, the contracting firms would bring their own technicians and workers from their own region. What would arrive instead for the municipalities of the Susa Valley and the Turin outskirts would be a serious problem: the mafia. Bid-rigging has already been identified during the geological survey phase, involving Piedmontese politicians.

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because the Turin–Lyon line is indispensable for the economic revival of Piedmont.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because by diverting resources away from innovation and the restructuring of deeply troubled industry (Fiat and others), the TAV could weigh down the Piedmontese economy.

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because public force can be called upon to open the construction sites, as it is a project of national interest. The 671 million euros allocated by the EU for the construction of the Turin–Lyon railway line had only one condition: that work begin by 30 June 2011, and so they have finally been unlocked.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because the use of public force to impose the start of works is a sign of the failure to consult local populations, as mandatorily required by EU Directive 2000/60. The militarisation of the territory is a curtailment of civil liberties, and it is precisely what Italians have just opposed with their no vote in the nuclear referendum of 12–13 June 2011.

The social arguments for the TAV

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because the people of the Susa Valley are selfish, do not think about Italy's interests and are unwilling to make sacrifices.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because the Susa Valley currently carries 35% of the total goods crossing the Alps. Around 4,500 lorries a day travel along the Fréjus Motorway, compared to 1,500 through Mont Blanc, in the Aosta Valley (where the number of lorries has been limited by law).

The TAV construction sites must be opened in the Susa Valley because those who oppose the Turin–Lyon line and high-speed rail have a prejudiced attitude and are against progress.

The TAV construction sites must not be opened in the Susa Valley because the TAV is an old and by now anachronistic project, one that assumes infinite growth in the volume of freight transport (which will become tomorrow's waste), prizes speed and quantity as its only values, and ignores the questions of "whether" and "why" something needs to be transported at all.