Where things stand on the TAV construction progress between Turin and Lyon

Where things stand on the TAV construction progress between Turin and Lyon

Rights · ·

Despite having sided with the No TAV movement, the Italian government has not abandoned the project, but has proposed a “low-cost TAV”. According to environmental associations, however, the substance has not changed.

In September of last year, the technical observatory on the high-speed rail line that is meant to connect Turin to Lyon, established by the Italian government, sided with the No TAV movement active in Val di Susa. The document states that "there is no doubt that many forecasts made almost ten years ago, in absolute good faith, including those based on official European Union projections, have been contradicted by the facts".

And by "facts" is meant the "severe economic crisis" that would have altered the economic landscape and, consequently, the list of priorities. The current scenario is "very different from the one in which the decisions were taken at the time, and no sensible person acting in good faith can be surprised by this".

And while the fact is glossed over that those assessments, for years, caused clashes, ongoing trials, the deployment of law enforcement, injuries, misinformation and an irreparable rift between part of the Val di Susa community and the Italian state, the government is not abandoning the idea of building, but has instead opted for a scaled-back project.

View taken on June 4, 2013 shows the inside of the Maddalena survey gallery in Chiomonte, northeastern Italy. The Maddalena survey gallery is the fourth tunnel that, together with the three access tunnels already excavated in France, will provide access to the future base tunnel of the new Turin-Lyon railway link.   AFP PHOTO/PHILIPPE DESMAZES        (Photo credit should read PHILIPPE DESMAZES/AFP/Getty Images)
Works inside the exploratory tunnel in Val di Susa © PHILIPPE DESMAZES/AFP/Getty Images

A "low-cost" version of the TAV

After years of published studies, demonstrations and unheeded interventions by opponents of this project, the government has admitted that the Turin–Lyon high-speed train (TAV) is out of scale, and the blame is being shifted onto European forecasts that, however, never quantified traffic independently.

Rather than abandoning the idea — on which at least €1.2 billion has already been spent — the government is now pressing ahead with a proposal for a more modest version: a "low-cost" TAV. A scaled-back project that should cost less, at least in appearance. But one must be wary of such proclamations, according to the environmental association Pro natura Piemonte: "the project in its 'low-cost' version is not in the least more modest than the previous one," clarifies president Mario Cavargna. "The full projects remain approved exactly as they were; it is simply a matter of dividing the construction into phases — in other words, spreading out the financial requirements needed for each year."

Una manifestazione contro la linea alta velocità tav Torino - Lione - Foto di Stefano Guidi/Corbis via Getty Images
Una manifestazione contro la linea alta velocità tav Torino – Lione – Foto di Stefano Guidi/Corbis via Getty Images

The costs of the TAV in detail

But how much has the TAV cost so far? On 20 March, the Interministerial Committee for Economic Planning (Cipe) approved the project to put the Italian section of the cross-border stretch of the Turin–Lyon rail line into construction. With this Cipe resolution, all the approvals for the Turin–Lyon line in Italy and France are concluded. The project now enters its implementation phase.

As regards costs, the Turin–Lyon base tunnel was, according to the 2015 resolution, set to cost €8.6 billion, divided between France and Italy at 42.1 per cent and 57.9 per cent respectively, net of EU co-financing, which covers 40 per cent of the total cost. With the latest resolution, Cipe recalculated the proportions of funding shared between Italy and France, without taking into account the European contribution.

"In practice this was also the case in 2015, but at the time it was made to appear as though Italy's commitment was limited to the 12 kilometres out of the tunnel's total 57," Cavargna explains further. "Whereas according to current calculations, without the European contribution, it is as if Italy has taken on responsibility for 80 per cent of the tunnel that lies on French territory, and must therefore pay, as maintained by Cipe, 57.9 per cent of €8.6 billion, updated to €9.6 billion due to the price index, bringing Italy's contribution from the €2.56 billion made available under the previous resolution to €5.5 billion — a benefit of €3 billion to the other party, namely France." To this, Italy must add a further €1.7 billion needed to upgrade the existing historic line.

“La Torino-Lione superata e dannosa: ripensiamoci” goo.gl/7rRRCB #notav

The rhetoric of European support

"The rhetoric that leaned on that decisive European contribution of 40 per cent — including the presentation of the bill to Parliament in December 2016 to launch construction — has turned out to be nothing but an illusion." And it is now impossible to hide behind contained costs, even if there is an attempt to spread the investment over a longer timeframe.

As early as 2007, economist Marco Ponti, an expert in the transport sector, estimated the total cost to Italy of the entire Turin–Lyon project at €17 billion: "We have updated that figure to €20 billion, with the hypothesis that it will double to €40 billion before completion," Cavargna adds.

The Cipe resolution of 20 March tells us that the first of those doublings has already taken place: were it not for the constant monitoring activity of local associations, it would be difficult to know the spending forecasts and how much the project will cost taxpayers. Yet such assessments continue to go consistently unheeded. This certainly does not help to maintain a climate of calm around a project so troubled and — understandably — so unwanted by the people who live in that territory.