Tanzania to build a dam in a Unesco world heritage nature reserve

Tanzania to build a dam in a Unesco world heritage nature reserve

Energy · ·

President Magufuli is immovable. The dam in Stiegler's Gorge will go ahead, despite warnings about the environmental damage it would cause to the Selous nature reserve, a Unesco world heritage site.

The Tanzania government has inaugurated construction of the Stiegler's Gorge dam, also known as the Rufiji hydroelectric project. It will be built on the Rufiji River, inside the Selous Game Reserve, a Unesco world heritage site since 1982 and one of Africa's most iconic natural areas, which has remained relatively undisturbed by human activity. According to the authorities, the hydroelectric structure will be 130 metres high and 700 metres wide, covering an area of 1,350 square kilometres, with a capacity to retain 34 billion cubic metres of water. The project, which is estimated to increase the country's electricity generating capacity (currently unreliable) by 2,115 megawatts, has been awarded to two Egyptian companies, El Sewedy Electric Co. and Arab Contractors, under a staggering contract worth 3.6 billion dollars.

Leggi anche: Cos'è l'Unesco e come funziona l'organizzazione che promuove la pace attraverso natura e cultura

However, several international experts have questioned its economic feasibility, arguing that the cost could reach as much as 9.8 billion dollars — more than double the current budget — making a return on investment in the short term unlikely, particularly given that the project's completion date, initially set for 2021, will probably be pushed back by at least six years.

L'inaugurazione della diga della gola di Stiegler in Tanzania
The inauguration of the Stiegler's Gorge dam in Tanzania, which will improve the country's electricity supply but put the ecosystem at risk © Egypt Independent

The environmental impact of the dam project in Tanzania

Environmentalists, who in recent years have cautiously begun to celebrate the decline of poaching in Tanzania, regard the dam's construction as a catastrophe and have repeatedly called for the project to be halted. In a letter to Tanzanian president John Magufuli, Unesco director-general Audrey Azoulay expressed her concerns about the threat the dam will pose. "We fear that the decision to proceed with the construction of the Stiegler dam will have a devastating and irreversible impact on the unique ecosystem of Selous, and that it will endanger the area's potential to contribute to sustainable development."

Leggi anche: Chi è Edward Loure, vincitore del premio Goldman e difensore delle terre della Tanzania

Audrey Azoulay, la direttrice generale dell'Unesco
Audrey Azoulay, Unesco director-general, has warned that the Selous reserve could lose its Unesco world heritage status © Christelle Alix/Unesco

An independent review commissioned by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (Iucn) highlights the inadequacy of the project's environmental impact assessment, which failed to address in any credible way the specific consequences for this area's outstanding universal value. Peter Shadie, director of the Iucn World Heritage Programme, argues that the construction of a large-scale hydroelectric structure inside a Unesco site is incompatible with its protected area status, and adds that the project would also involve extensive infrastructure development and the deforestation of around 1,000 square kilometres at the heart of the Selous reserve.

"The Stiegler's Gorge dam project is unacceptable. It would strike right at the heart of the Selous reserve, with catastrophic consequences for the nature and habitat of the area. The commitment to protecting world heritage sites for future generations must be collective — a commitment that neither Tanzania nor any other state can choose to ignore."

In response, the environmental group Green world warriors launched a petition calling on the Tanzanian government to immediately halt construction of the dam. "Environmentalists fear the ultimate destruction of a protected area already seriously compromised," where poaching has reduced the elephant population by 90 per cent since 1982, the organisation writes. "There is no doubt that Tanzania has a strong need for a better electricity grid, but this dam project is not the solution."

Il presidente della Tanzania John Magufuli
Tanzanian president John Magufuli says he will not listen to those who criticise the Stiegler's Gorge dam © Wikimedia

Magufuli rules with an iron fist

During the 41st session of the World Heritage Committee held in Poland in July 2017, a Tanzanian government delegation confirmed the country's firm decision to carry out the project, stressing that construction of the dam has been planned since the 1960s — that is, before the Selous reserve was granted world heritage status. President Magufuli, for his part, is immovable: "This is the beginning of economic liberation. In our country only ten per cent of the population is connected to the national electricity grid and this is unacceptable." And following the negative reaction from environmentalists, he played down the risks to the environment, arguing that the increase in energy production would mean local residents would no longer need to fell trees to produce charcoal. He also added that the dam will cover only three per cent of the Selous reserve, and that he will no longer listen to those who criticise the project "without knowing the facts."

Read also: Tanzania, ucciso Wayne Lotter, lottava per difendere gli elefanti

In recent years Magufuli has been accused of governing his country with an iron fist. Since coming to power in 2015, several independent newspapers have been closed and more than twenty opposition MPs have been arrested. Tundu Lissu, an opposition MP and one of the leading critical voices against Magufuli, was shot sixteen times in 2017 and his life is in danger for having challenged the government. Even publicly questioning the importance of this dam is risky, and the government has done everything to make that point clear. Kangi Lugola, the country's environment minister, issued a warning in parliament: "The government will proceed with the implementation of the project whether you like it or not, and those who resist will be imprisoned."

Abitanti della zona di Selous mentre pescano sul fiume Rufiji
Some residents of the Selous area fishing on the Rufiji river © Kris NM/Wikimedia

Poaching in the Selous reserve

Forty years ago, the Selous nature reserve was home to around 110,000 elephants — at the time it was estimated to be the largest concentration on the continent. In 1982, Unesco recognised the value of the reserve and its vast population of pachyderms, adding it to the world heritage list. Despite this, poaching in the area has since grown exponentially, causing a rapid decline in the reserve's wildlife. Among the worst-affected species are some extremely rare ones, including the black rhinoceros, the elephant, the African wild dog and the hippopotamus.

Leggi anche: La regina dell'avorio condannata a 15 anni di carcere per il traffico di elefanti, finalmente

Ippopotamo in Tanzania
As a result of the construction of the Stiegler's Gorge dam, the Selous plain will be flooded, leading to the loss of habitat for many animals, including hippos © Phil Hyde/Wikimedia

Stiegler's Gorge dam and deforestation

Furthermore, 17 local companies have won a tender to clear 1,500 square kilometres of land, felling around 2.6 million trees, for a value of 62 million dollars. An area twice the size of Berlin will be deforested and will disappear underwater as a result of the construction of the Stiegler's Gorge dam.

It is undeniable that Tanzania needs energy to grow its local industries, but the loss of part of the precious Selous nature reserve is a very high price to pay.

Tradotto da Elettra Tsikoudis