The story of Stefano Cucchi's death in Ilaria's second life
Rights — di Maurizio Bongioanni
Stefano Cucchi died in 2009. In the same year as the final verdict, his sister Ilaria entered Parliament for the first time.

Stefano Cucchi died in 2009. In the same year as the final verdict, his sister Ilaria entered Parliament for the first time.
Ilaria Cucchi was elected as a senator of the Republic in the general elections of 25 September 2022. A woman who was forced to expose herself, becoming a public figure, against her will, because of the tragic death of her brother Stefano. We retrace her story to understand how Stefano Cucchi died, and how it came to be established that he had been beaten to death by the carabinieri who held him in a cell that night. We do so now that his legacy has entered parliament through Ilaria's election. A legacy that tells us just how possible it is to protect the truth and obtain justice, in spite of everything and everyone.
"We can draw a line under the murder of Stefano," said Ilaria Cucchi immediately after the verdict. "We can say that he was beaten to death, that justice has been served against those who took him away from us." The carabinieri Alessio Di Bernardo and Raffaele D'Alessandro were convicted on 4 April 2022 of unintentional homicide and sentenced to twelve years in prison. But the beating of Stefano Cucchi was only the "primary cause" — as the Court of Cassation writes in its reasoning — of a series of "subsequent factors", among which were also the "negligent omissions of the medical staff".

The path towards Stefano Cucchi's death begins on the night of 15 October 2009, when Stefano, who was 31 years old at the time, is stopped by the carabinieri while in possession of 20 grams of hashish and three doses of cocaine. Taken to the barracks, Cucchi is first placed under arrest and then accompanies the carabinieri to his home for a general search. During that time, Stefano meets his parents, with whom he lives. Stefano's mother does not know that this would be the last time she would see her son alive.
During the search nothing of relevance is found and the young man is taken to the barracks. While awaiting the validation hearing for his arrest, Stefano is held in a secure cell. It is night-time and the young man tells the officer on duty that he is not feeling well; the emergency services are therefore called, but Stefano refuses to be examined. The following morning, Stefano appears in court struggling to walk and speak and showing obvious bruising around his eyes. The young man exchanges a few words with his father, who has come to the hearing, but does not say what has happened to him.
The judge validates the arrest of Cucchi and schedules the first hearing of the trial for the following 13 November. Despite his state of health, Stefano is taken to Regina Coeli prison, where his health deteriorates further. On the night of 16 October he is taken to the accident and emergency department of the Fatebenefratelli hospital, where he is diagnosed with injuries and bruising to his legs and face with a fractured jaw, to his abdomen with haematuria, and to his chest (with a fracture of the third lumbar vertebra and the coccyx). Stefano Cucchi refuses admission and is therefore taken back to prison.
His condition deteriorates further and he is transferred to the detainees' ward of the Sandro Pertini hospital, where he dies at dawn on 22 October. At the time of his death he weighs just 37 kilograms. His relatives, who are repeatedly prevented from learning about the prisoner's physical condition, are informed of Stefano's death only when a court officer goes to their home to serve the decree by which the public prosecutor authorised the autopsy on Stefano's body.
This is where the first investigations begin. The prison staff immediately distance themselves from the accusations, denying that they committed any violence against the prisoner and claiming that the death could be linked to drug abuse, anorexia and drug dependency. To counter the false claims surrounding Stefano's death, his family publish online photographs taken at the mortuary, which show on his body the marks of the bruising and his evident state of malnutrition. For Ilaria, his sister, and their parents there is no doubt: Stefano was beaten.
In April 2010, the Rome public prosecutor's office sends thirteen defendants to trial: three prison police officers (for assault and abuse of authority) and ten doctors and nurses from the Pertini hospital, charged with aiding and abetting, abandonment of a person unable to care for themselves, abuse of office and ideological forgery. According to the prosecution, those on duty at the Pertini simply took note of the young man's refusal, which was motivated by his wish to speak with his own lawyer. Among the other omissions, there was the failure to urgently transfer the patient to a more suitable ward when his health had by then become critical.
On 13 December 2012, the first-instance trial opens. The court-appointed experts establish that the young man's death was indeed caused by the lack of medical care and the absence of food and fluids, but that as regards the injuries found, these could have been caused by a beating or by an accidental fall. The experts stress that there are no elements pointing more towards one scenario than the other.

On 5 June 2013 the Rome Assize Court convicts five hospital doctors at first instance to one year and four months, the head physician to two years in prison for involuntary manslaughter, and another doctor to eight months for ideological forgery, while acquitting six people: three nurses and the three prison police officers, who — according to the judges — did not contribute to Cucchi's death. The sentences are suspended for all, and the reading of the verdict provokes outrage from Stefano's family. On 31 October 2014, the Court of Appeal acquits all the defendants, including the doctors.
Stefano's sister, Ilaria, who has been active since the very beginning of the affair, does not give up and announces an appeal to the Court of Cassation, despite the legal complaint received from the police union, which maintains that Ilaria's statements amount to "insinuations" against the security forces. On 15 December 2015, the Court of Cassation orders the partial annulment of the appeal verdict, ordering a new trial for five of the six doctors (and once again excluding the police officers' liability): in the court's view, Cucchi's pathological conditions would have required greater attention and further investigation on the part of the medical staff.
This brings us to the second appeal, heard on 18 July 2016, which however once again acquitted the five doctors on the grounds that "the offence does not exist". But it did not end there: on 19 April 2017, the Court of Cassation ordered the annulment of that verdict too, and on 23 March 2018 yet another appeal hearing opened. The conclusion of the first line of investigation, which had focused on the responsibility of medical staff, came on 14 November 2019 with the acquittal of all defendants (in practice, the charge against the chief physician was time-barred).

While the first line of investigation focused on the responsibility of medical staff and ended in acquittal, the Cucchi family had returned to explicitly requesting that investigators look into the responsibility of the police officers who had Stefano in their custody that night.
The insistence of sister Ilaria and their parents convinced the Rome public prosecutor's office, in September 2015, to reopen the investigation file for unintentional homicide against the prison police. Crucial was the testimony of one of the carabinieri, Riccardo Casamassima, who reported having received threats from colleagues in order to provide a false version of events during the appeal hearing. It emerged that, contrary to what had been reported in the official documents of the force during the previous trial, after the house search Cucchi had not been taken straight back to the carabinieri station but had first been brought to another barracks for identification purposes, and, for reasons never fully clarified, he was beaten there.
It was a shocking testimony, and the preliminary investigation closed on 17 January 2017, almost eight years after the events, with the committal for trial for unintentional homicide and abuse of authority against carabinieri officers Alessio Di Bernardo, Raffaele D'Alessandro and Francesco Tedesco, accused of having struck Cucchi with slaps, punches and kicks, causing him to fall and sustaining injuries that subsequently proved fatal, also as a result of the negligent conduct of the treating physicians.
Tedesco and Marshal Roberto Mandolini, who at the time was the commander of the Rome Appia station where the beating took place, also had to answer to the charge of ideological falsehood for the omission of the names of Di Bernardo and D'Alessandro from the arrest report. Tedesco and Mandolini, moreover, together with Lance Corporal Vincenzo Nicolardi, were also charged with slander for having made false statements during the previous trial. On 24 February 2017, Di Bernardo, D'Alessandro and Tedesco were precautionarily suspended indefinitely from their duties, and on 10 July of the same year the request to commit the suspects to trial was granted.
The hearing opened in October 2018 and the officers immediately traded accusations: Francesco Tedesco identified Di Bernardo and D'Alessandro as the sole perpetrators of the beating. The prosecutor, during this hearing, informed the court of what had in the meantime emerged from the investigations, in particular regarding attempts to cover up the truth. In June, in fact, Tedesco had filed a complaint with the Rome public prosecutor's office against persons unknown, in which he reported the disappearance of a service note he had written on 22 October 2009 and addressed to his superiors, in which he had set out the events of the night of 15 to 16 October. This fact opened a new investigation, aimed at shedding light on the cover-up attempts.
Meanwhile, on 14 November 2019, the Rome Assize Court found Di Bernardo and D'Alessandro guilty of unintentional homicide, sentencing them to 13 years' imprisonment and lifetime disqualification from public office. That sentence was upheld as final by the Supreme Court of Cassation on 4 April 2022, reducing the sentence to 12 years. Tedesco was acquitted by the Court of Cassation of the charge of unintentional homicide, but sentenced to 2 years and 6 months for falsification, the same offence for which Marshal Mandolini was also convicted. On 7 April 2022, the cover-up trial also reached a conclusion, with eight carabinieri (including a general, a colonel, a commander — an entire chain of command) sentenced to serve a combined total of 22 years in prison.
The story of Stefano Cucchi was exploited by a certain section of Italian politics, which initially defended the work of law enforcement tooth and nail. Among them was the then Minister of Justice Angelino Alfano, who maintained that Cucchi had died in prison from a fall. Then came the then Under-Secretary Carlo Giovanardi, who declared that Cucchi had died solely of anorexia and drug addiction, asserting that the young man was HIV-positive. Subsequently, Giovanardi repented of his false statements and apologised to the family. Former Interior Minister Matteo Salvini also weighed in, saying that "the case shows that drugs are harmful" — a remark the Lega leader made following the 2019 conviction of the carabinieri. For this statement, Ilaria Cucchi filed a complaint against Salvini.
More broadly, the Cucchi case demonstrated how the criminalisation of the victim is a constant feature in cases of police misconduct, where the responsibility falls on the very institution that should instead be protecting the victims. This is a category that generally includes drug addicts, migrants and homeless people, who are often perceived as "social deadweight". In the name of decency and urban safety, the lifestyles of the most marginalised are criminalised and suppressed, meaning that those who fall into this condition struggle to attract the attention needed to obtain justice.

We can say that the Cucchi case received widespread media attention thanks to his sister Ilaria. Through her activism, today there exists an association dedicated to her brother committed to giving a voice to other similar cases. And there are many: as many as 26 in 2009 alone, the year Stefano died. We are talking about people who died in prison without the cause ever being established, as in the case of the Tunisian Kayes Bohli, who died of asphyxiation during transfer to a barracks, or those cases in which families are still fighting to see their rights