The torture case at San Gimignano prison
Rights — di Luigi Mastrodonato
Terrifying violence against an inmate is alleged to have taken place at Rezza prison. Five officers are now to stand trial for torture.

Terrifying violence against an inmate is alleged to have taken place at Rezza prison. Five officers are now to stand trial for torture.
"Infami, pezzi di merda, vi facciamo vedere chi comanda a San Gimignano!" According to the prosecution, as they beat a Tunisian inmate, prison officers at Ranza prison allegedly addressed the other prisoners watching the scene from behind bars in these terms. It was 11 October 2018, and the accounts that emerged from the facility about what is alleged to have happened that cursed afternoon are chilling. In 2021, five prison officers, along with three inspectors and two assistants, are to face trial on charges of torture. It is the first time in Italy that this offence has been brought against public officials, following its introduction into Italian law in 2017.
At 3:20 pm on 11 October 2018, there is a great deal of movement in one wing of Ranza prison. A large group of officers, accompanied by several inspectors, must transfer a 31-year-old Tunisian inmate to another cell. The reason is that he has caused damage to the cell he was in; the individual has psychiatric problems and is described by his fellow inmates as someone who has never harmed others, only himself. According to the account of one of the inmates who witnesses the scene, the situation immediately gets out of hand for no apparent reason.
"They made us witness a real beating," he writes in a letter, "the inmate was being moved from one end of the wing to the other with kicks and punches — I mean, it's not as if they tried perhaps with a small use of force or a few shoves, given that the inmate was in a very poor state both psychologically and physically; he must weigh around 45 kilograms." Many shout at the officers and threaten to report them. They claim to have received violence in response. In the months that follow, associations for prisoners' rights gather evidence and testimonies about what took place during those hours, including through access to CCTV footage, intercepts and medical reports from some of the inmates. The prosecution thus constructs a terrifying picture, made up of physical and psychological violence, insults and humiliation.

The Tunisian inmate is alleged to have been taken by surprise as he was heading to the showers and thrown to the ground with shoves and punches. They allegedly made him get up to walk, only to slam him back down repeatedly on the floor. The inmate is also said to have been pinned face down while some officers pressed their knee against his neck — a position that became grimly notorious in Minneapolis with George Floyd. He was then allegedly dragged along the corridor, having been stripped, periodically grabbed by the throat and struck with punches and slaps, all the way to the entrance of the new cell, where the violence against him is said to have continued and where he was subsequently left naked, without a mattress and without blankets until the following day. Throughout all of this, the officers allegedly directed racist insults at him and threats at the other inmates: "Why don't you go back to your own country," "Don't move or I'll strangle you," "I'll kill you," right up to "We'll show you who's in charge at San Gimignano."
The investigation coordinated by public prosecutor (pm) Valentina Magnini concluded that the inmate had been subjected to "inhuman and degrading treatment". For this reason, five prison officers were committed to trial by preliminary hearing judge (gup) Roberta Malavasi on charges of aggravated bodily harm, ideological falsehood, aggravated threats, abuse of power and torture. Meanwhile, a prison doctor who had opted for a fast-track trial was sentenced to four months for failing to examine the inmate when, in pain and bearing signs of violence, he was in the new cell.
For a long time Italy had no law on torture, despite having ratified the 1984 United Nations Convention against this type of offence. In 2017 came the turning point, with a law described by many as inadequate but which at least filled a gap that had long been conspicuous. The provisions that have now been in force for three years prescribe sentences of between four and ten years in prison for those responsible for torture, rising to a maximum of 12 if the offence is committed by a public official or a person entrusted with a public service.
The first definitive conviction for this type of offence came in 2019 in Varese; others have been handed down in recent months. Until now, however, no member of the security forces had ever even been investigated for committing violations of the criminal code of this kind. The committal to trial in the San Gimignano case therefore opens an important chapter from this point of view.
"No grounds to proceed, excessive use of coercive means. These are recurring formulas when it comes to conduct carried out by police forces; Italian history is littered with similar episodes. In prisons it is difficult to bring them to light — other inmates are not always willing to testify to what goes on, and abuse often occurs away from the eyes of others," emphasises Sandra Berardi, president of Yairaiha, an association for prisoners' rights that directly followed the case of the alleged abuses at San Gimignano. A case that is, in its own way, fortunate, because it took place in the solitary confinement wing, which was equipped with cameras that made it possible to gather the material. "San Gimignano is no more troubled than other places; the complaint only came to light because of the specific circumstances of that period and that place," Berardi points out. "These are situations that are usually endured in silence out of fear of reprisals — it is not easy for an inmate to report an abuse, to manage to prove it and to come through unscathed."
The 2017 torture law changed the picture, because it provided a new legal instrument with which to prosecute degrading treatment carried out in places of detention. For too many years Italy witnessed conduct on the part of the security forces that at best resulted in derisory sentences and at worst in nothing at all, precisely because of the absence of an adequate legislative framework. One case above all others stands out: the events of the Genoa G8, with the brutal violence at the Diaz school and at Bolzaneto barracks, which even prompted the European Court of Human Rights to take a stance: "It was torture," the verdict.
But there have been many other episodes of torture and suspicious situations over the years, from the most publicly known cases, such as those of Stefano Cucchi and Federico Aldrovandi, to many others that have remained more hidden. For instance, the deaths of 14 inmates during the prison riots last March, officially attributed to methadone overdose, but on which no clarity has ever been established. And then the repression in several penitentiary institutions, such as that of Foggia, where witness accounts describe inmates being beaten with batons, kicks and punches, forcibly transferred to other facilities in the middle of the night in their underwear, and placed in solitary confinement for months without being provided clothing or their own personal belongings. And then complaints that disappeared, letters that were never sent, and so on, in an endless list of murky behaviour.
"Violence has always been there and continues to exist. The situation has not changed with the introduction of the new law, which is somewhat incomplete and leaves wide margins for a particular modus operandi. The ruling on the San Gimignano case could be important and set a precedent, but we have to get there first," concludes Berardi. "The regulations need to be accompanied by other changes — for example, the issue of identification numbers for law enforcement officers should be introduced, as well as the widespread installation of cameras linked to the ombudsmen's office."
The torture trial against public officials in San Gimignano was brought about largely thanks to the availability of footage — something that cannot be taken for granted in the Italian prison landscape. Installing cameras elsewhere too, in all wings, could mark a significant turning point in the protection of inmates' rights, complementing a torture law that cannot work on its own.