G8 in Genoa, another ruling from Europe: what happened at Bolzaneto was also torture

G8 in Genoa, another ruling from Europe: what happened at Bolzaneto was also torture

Rights · ·

The European Court of Human Rights condemns Italy for failing to identify those responsible for the violence against protesters during the 2001 Genoa G8. And for the absence, at the time, of a specific offence of torture.

The protesters at the 2001 Genoa G8, arrested and taken to the Bolzaneto barracks, "were subjected beyond any doubt to ill-treatment, to a condition of extreme vulnerability, to physical, verbal and psychological abuse." In a word, according to the European Court of Human Rights, they were subjected to torture.

Once again Europe moves to condemn Italy for the abuse of protesters at the Genoa G8 by law enforcement, speaking plainly of torture — an offence that was only introduced into the Italian penal code a few months ago. It does so through a ruling concerning an application brought by 59 protesters. In the ruling, the Court underlines that precisely because of the absence of a torture offence in Italian law at the time of the events, virtually all the acts of violence had become time-barred by the time the cases were tried, and virtually none of the individuals deemed responsible received an adequate sentence.

La condanna della Corte Europea: a #Bolzaneto fu tortura. Qui il racconto di quei terribili giorni al #G8 di Genova >bit.ly/2z8ocKF

Prolonged and severe violence

In their application, the 59 protesters stated that they had been subjected to prolonged and severe violence (insults, use of tear gas, beatings, deprivation and destruction of personal belongings) by police officers and medical staff present at the Bolzaneto barracks, where those arrested were held from 20 July 2001, on the first day of the G8, until the 22nd, by which point the summit had already ended.

The Court responded by acknowledging that the inhuman and degrading treatment suffered was demonstrable, but also that "the difficulties in identifying the perpetrators of the violence and the fact that the Italian penal code does not provide for any offence of torture complicated the proceedings." The European Court of Human Rights ordered compensation for the 59 protesters ranging from €10,000 to €85,000.

Il corpo di Carlo Giuliani a terra dopo gli scontri del G8 a Genova - Foto di Sean Gallup/Getty Images
The body of Carlo Giuliani on the ground after the clashes at the Genoa G8 – Photo by Sean Gallup/Getty Images

A law that took 16 years to arrive

Only since last August has Italy equipped itself, after many long years of waiting and delays, with a law on the offence of torture, which provides for imprisonment of between a minimum of 4 and a maximum of 12 years for anyone who, through violence or serious threats and with cruelty, "causes acute physical suffering or a verifiable psychological trauma to a person deprived of their personal liberty or entrusted to their custody, or who finds themselves in a condition of reduced ability to defend themselves." The new law cannot, however, be applied to the offences committed at the Diaz school and at Bolzaneto, which now date back 16 years.