The offence of torture: Italy has its law, but doubts remain

The offence of torture: Italy has its law, but doubts remain

Rights · ·

In the days marking the anniversary of the Genoa G8, the question has resurfaced: under the new law, would the beatings at the Diaz school truly have been considered torture?

Sixteen years on, the dramatic events of the 2001 Genoa G8 have forcefully returned to public attention in recent days for multiple reasons. Right on the anniversary of Carlo Giuliani's death during the clashes of 20 July, several of those convicted for the beatings of protesters at the Diaz school were reinstated to the Police force, upon the expiry of the five-year ban from public office to which they had been sentenced as additional penalties: among them were senior officers and riot-squad unit commanders. All this while, in an interview with Repubblica, the current Police Chief Franco Gabrielli admitted: "That G8 was a catastrophe. At the Diaz and at Bolzaneto, there was torture." Unfortunately, the offence of torture was only officially incorporated into the Italian penal code a few days ago, following numerous rulings by the European Court of Human Rights relating precisely to the events of the G8. Even the new law, however, has raised some concerns among civil-liberties organisations.

Gabrielli rompe con un passato buio usando termine #tortura per fatti di Genova nel 2001. Ora codici identificativi …ili.blogautore.espresso.repubblica.it/2017/07/19/gab…

The new law passed by Italy

The new text provides for imprisonment of a minimum of 4 and a maximum of 12 years for anyone who, through serious violence or threats and with cruelty, "causes acute physical suffering or a verifiable psychological trauma to a person deprived of their personal liberty or entrusted to their custody, or who finds themselves in a condition of reduced ability to defend themselves." In the penultimate parliamentary reading in the Chamber, however, an amendment was inserted defining violence as torture "if the act is committed through multiple conducts or if it involves inhuman and degrading treatment of the person's dignity." Another significant amendment, introduced to protect the police forces, excludes from the law any suffering resulting solely from the lawful execution of measures that deprive or limit rights by the Police.

All the concerns about the amendments

The formula introduced by the first amendment has been deemed unacceptable by Associazione Antigone and Amnesty International for "the insistence with which it limits torture to only those behaviours repeated over time." This provision, for example, would have made it less than straightforward to classify the events at the Diaz and Bolzaneto as "torture," together with the requirement laid down by the law to prove that the violence suffered caused a "verifiable psychological trauma." The question at this point is: if this law had already existed in 2001, could it have been applied to the G8 beatings? Also weighing on assessments is the fact that the offence of torture, initially envisaged as a specific offence — that is, one attributable to public officials and those performing a public service — has instead become a common offence: even Senator Luigi Manconi, who had presented the original bill, said he was disappointed because this means "refusing to highlight inhuman or degrading treatment within a profoundly unequal power relationship, an illegitimate use of force, an abuse of authority." In short, a kind of downgrading of the law.