How is biodiversity faring in Italy: the voices of experts and organisations

How is biodiversity faring in Italy: the voices of experts and organisations

Environment · ·

Biodiversity is taking heavy blows due to the climate and the mismanagement of wildlife and its habitat. But there is good news too.

It has been stated, and forcefully, recently by Wwf. Biodiversity and wild animals are now dangerously close to collapse. And this is happening across the world, in Europe and, all the more so, in our country. What gives a glimmer of hope, however, is the fact that, as far as Italy is concerned, there can be no single answer, because some sectors and groups of animals are in an extremely critical condition while others are, fortunately, recovering. In summary, populations of mammals, birds, amphibians, reptiles and fish have declined on our planet by an average of 69 per cent since 1970, while in South America and the Caribbean the depletion of wildlife has reached astronomical levels: 94 per cent. "This is a double emergency: climate change and biodiversity loss threaten the wellbeing of current and future generations," Wwf director general Marco Lambertini declared on this subject.

delfini
Ecosystem biodiversity is being put to a severe test © Pixabay

Biodiversity: the expert speaks

We put a series of questions to biologist Mauro Belardi, environmental sustainability expert and president of the Eliante cooperative, to gain a clearer picture of the state of biodiversity in our country.

How is biodiversity faring in Italy?
There can be no single answer to this question, because some sectors and animal groups are in an extremely critical condition while others are recovering. On the verge of collapse, for example, are all aquatic organisms, since water ecosystems and wetlands are in a disastrous ecological state. The biodiversity of aquatic invertebrates is one per cent of what could be found 30 years ago. Fish are in very poor shape, given that 90 per cent of species are now non-native allochthonous species, often invasive and harmful. Our rivers have in fact become almost entirely artificial watercourses, interrupted by dams and subject to the continuous introduction of alien organisms. Even mountain streams are now being drained dry by water extraction for energy. Our marshlands are suffering from the presence of non-native plants and an unnatural water regime. The biomass and diversity of insects and other invertebrates has collapsed due to the overuse of pesticides. Only twenty years ago it was normal to have to clean insects off the car windscreen after a long journey; now it never happens.

polarwolf
Large predators, such as the wolf, are also threatened by climate change © Pixabay

Are there any signs of recovery among certain wild species?
Certainly, but here too distinctions must be made. Many species of large mammals are showing signs of recovery — ungulates, for example, and the large predators for which ungulates are the main prey. These animals have benefited from the partial abandonment of mountain areas, the recovery of forest cover and stricter conservation policies. But not everything that glitters is gold. While the red deer today is in a far better demographic situation than it was a few decades ago, the most precious native subspecies in Italy is found only in the Bosco della Mesola and numbers just a few individuals. The Sardinian specimens are not in good health either. It is true that Italy is overrun with wild boar, but these are populations that originated from hunting introductions, derived from subspecies of Eastern Europe, sometimes crossbred with domestic pigs: the original Italian subspecies has essentially disappeared.

biodiversità orso
The lives of large predators — the wolf and bear above all — are now under threat as they venture too close to inhabited areas © Pixabay

And predators? The wolf in particular?
In this case too, the favourable situation of predators is only partial. The wolf has certainly reached stable population levels by now, but the social conflict it generates is high and a reduction in its protection status is likely. The bear cannot be said to be out of danger. The lynx is still very rare in Italy. Meanwhile, what appears to be expanding unchecked is the golden jackal. And we are also witnessing a slow return of the otter and the beaver. Italian birds are a group that illustrates this ambiguous situation well. While on the one hand some iconic species for the environmentalists of the past, such as the golden eagle and the bearded vulture, appear to be out of danger, the situation for small passerines is dramatic, particularly insectivorous ones, due to intensive agriculture and the use of chemicals. The same is true of species suffering from climate change, such as the rock ptarmigan, for example. Of particular concern overall is the state of migratory birds, for which the increasingly poor conditions of their African wintering grounds are compounded by the increasingly critical conditions here, where stopover areas are disappearing along with their reproductive habitats in general.

scimmie
The genetic heritage of wildlife is deteriorating rapidly © Pixabay

When the remedy is worse than the disease

Meanwhile, trials of contraceptive methods to contain the numbers of wild animal populations are under way. This is announced by the Organizzazione internazionale protezione animali (Oipa) following the publication in the Gazzetta Ufficiale of the Ministry of Health decree authorising trials in our country. For the problems of "overpopulation" of wild boar, coypu, squirrels and other specimens of wild species in Italy, it will be possible to trial the immuno-contraceptive vaccine GonaCon, developed in the United States where it is registered as a contraceptive for horses (Equus caballus), wild donkeys (Equus africanus) and white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus).

"This is a drug that is not yet authorised either in Italy or in any other European Union member state, and we are waiting to learn which projects will be approved and submitted by the Istituto zooprofilattico sperimentale del Lazio e della Toscana and the Istituto zooprofilattico del Mezzogiorno. We hope it will be an experiment that takes animal welfare into account and proves useful in avoiding the resolution of the overpopulation problem through hunting or euthanasia, as has been done until now," comments Massimo Comparotto, president of Oipa, on this matter. In short, in trying to patch one hole, an even bigger one could open up.

orso
The bear has often been demonised and subjected to harassment © Pixabay

Good news from Lombardy

Not all the news concerning the condition of wildlife in our country is dire, nor are all the prospects bleak. We paid a visit to Lombardy to meet Gianluca Comazzi, president of Fiba (Federazione italiana benessere animale) and councillor at the municipality of Milan: "Wildlife in Lombardy is certainly very rich and diverse. Recently, Ersaf – the regional body for agricultural and forestry services – confirmed the return of the lynx to Lombard territory, in the woodlands of Alto Garda and near the border with Trentino. In my view, the general trend is positive: the presence of large animals is a growing phenomenon, and the wolf has also been spotted again in our territory. It is a great heritage that we absolutely cannot afford to lose. The region has an obligation to protect it, including through its nature parks. We have 24 of them, and all harbour a great wealth of biodiversity that must be defended and understood. They are beautiful places that form the green lung of our magnificent land."

A note of hope, then, that counterbalances the far-from-positive news on biodiversity. The return of large predators should indeed be welcomed with satisfaction, and not treated as something to be curbed and demonised. A clear signal to those who hold the power to make decisions at a political level.