Bird migration is suffering under climate change
Environment — di Brunella Paciello
Climate change is affecting bird migration, causing increasingly serious damage to the ecosystem. We asked the experts

Climate change is affecting bird migration, causing increasingly serious damage to the ecosystem. We asked the experts
Climate change is also causing significant phenomena when it comes to bird migration. This is demonstrated by a study coordinated by Andrea Romano, a researcher at the Department of Environmental Science and Policy at the University of Milan and recently published in Ecological Monographs. The research gathered more than 5,500 historical series of phenological data (temporal variations in activities such as migration and reproduction), spanning from 1811 to 2018, and relating to 684 bird species worldwide. The data were then reanalysed collectively to assess possible differences in temporal trends between species with different characteristics and between different geographical regions. The results are clear. It was confirmed that both spring migration towards nesting sites and bird reproduction are being brought forward by approximately 2–3 days per decade. Substantial differences are observed between species with different ecological and biological characteristics: birds that migrate over long distances (transcontinental migrants) have shown less marked advances compared with those that move only within a continent, while resident birds show the most pronounced changes. This difference may stem from the fact that resident species, and to a lesser extent those that move only short distances, are better able to track changes in the climate and environment of their breeding grounds — something that is difficult for long-range migrants, which are also constrained by the crossing of ecological barriers such as the Sahara or the Mediterranean.
The global-scale study highlights several patterns of phenological variation (that is, relating to changes in the timing of annual activities) over time that had previously only been hypothesised or verified at a local scale, showing that ecological and biological characteristics can strongly influence the way in which species are responding to the increasingly pervasive effects of climate change. These findings could also prove useful for identifying the species most susceptible to the future effects of global warming, with a view to potential protection and conservation measures.

To shed more light on the phenomenon of changing bird migrations caused by an erratic climate, we put some questions to Marco Gustin, head of species and research at Lipu (Lega italiana protezione uccelli). Here is what he explained to us.
Is it true that climate change is affecting bird migration?
Climate change is certainly affecting bird migration, both with regard to the Palearctic-African flyway and the four main American flyways (Atlantic, Mississippi, Central and Pacific). The impact of climate change is not limited to migratory species alone. It also involves resident species, particularly those tied to mountain grasslands. For example, the rock ptarmigan is threatened not only by the reduction of its habitat due to the upward shift of the tree line, but also by the physiological impossibility of adapting to an erratic climate that, had it remained stable, would have allowed it to survive thanks to a moult suited to each individual season (completely white in winter and mottled-reddish in summer), thus making it less well camouflaged and increasing predation. Added to this problem is the expansion of ski resorts, which brings about a significant reduction in habitat and an increased risk of collision with ski-lift cables.

But returning to migratory birds, a great deal of research carried out over the past twenty years now confirms that, as a result of climate change, the spring migration of birds towards their nesting sites is being brought forward by approximately 2–3 days per decade, dating back to the early 1800s.
Both resident species and so-called partial migrants (that is, those that move within the Palearctic region) tend to advance their breeding activities to a greater extent. By contrast, species that migrate over long distances (the so-called trans-Saharan migrants) have shown less marked advances, also because they are more constrained by the crossing of ecological barriers such as the Sahara or the Mediterranean. Furthermore, the direction and strength of favourable or adverse winds can have a significant impact on movements. Adaptation to changing wind patterns is greater when changes occur gradually, but despite this many migratory birds — though not all — are already adapting their survival strategies to current conditions.

Then there is the increase in drought and temperatures…
Indeed. As a result of rising average temperatures, it has been found that migratory birds often reach their breeding grounds either too early or too late, causing a mismatch between arrival at breeding sites and the availability of food in the form of insects. Moreover, many migratory species — especially long-range ones — find themselves short of nourishment during migration, depleting the fat reserves essential to their journey sooner than they should. In Europe, a quarter of the more than 500 bird species studied are already being negatively impacted by climate change, with a clear decline in abundance and geographical distribution. But things are set to worsen. According to a recent study, by 2050 the proportion of migratory bird species affected by the environmental changes caused by climate warming could rise to more than 80 per cent of the total. Since 1500, more than 150 bird species have gone extinct — an extinction rate far higher than the natural one. Today, one in eight bird species is threatened with global extinction, and the situation is deteriorating. Particularly alarming are the sharp declines in birds that were once common and widespread.
What are the consequences of this phenomenon at the ecosystem level?
Many, if not all, of the habitats and ecosystems on our planet are being altered by climate change, and these impacts will in all likelihood be compounded by other human-caused environmental degradation factors, such as deforestation and new infrastructure driven by growth in the human population, with synergistic effects. These changes, which occur every day, threaten the survival of many bird species, which are forced to modify their behaviour in order to adapt to new environmental conditions — with the consequence that the very survival of many species will be significantly reduced.
A bleak prospect, then, which once again underscores the urgency of taking concrete action on a changing climate and its consequences.