Crimes against animals, a horror with no end in sight
Environment — di Brunella Paciello
Crimes against animals are the perverse face of “animalism” and reveal all its contradictions. A book on the subject can help us understand.

Crimes against animals are the perverse face of “animalism” and reveal all its contradictions. A book on the subject can help us understand.
There are crimes and there are crimes. Those perpetrated against the most vulnerable, whether children or animals, carry with them a horror that seems truly to defy reason. And they demand reflection. An example? The author has lived for years alongside dogs. Life companions perhaps more attentive and present than a close relative or a dear friend. So much is done for them. Perhaps too much. The best doctors, innovative treatments, tailored food, entertainment and leisure time. Yet, set against these lucky, pampered animals, there remains a world riddled with abuses, unspeakable violence, a pervasive and in some respects little-known barbarism that strikes domestic animals, but also wild ones — and in the latter case the crime becomes more barbaric, more culpable, because it also leaves a deep mark on the nature and environment around us.

Cani, falchi, tigri e trafficanti is a 2020 book written by Ermanno Giudici, blogger and writer (Il patto tradito), and Paola D'Amico. I recommend it to everyone who wishes to explore the subject of crimes committed against animals, whether domestic or wild. Ermanno Giudici has been working on animals and their protection for forty years. President and former long-standing head of the zoophile guards of Enpa Milano, an organisation he has been involved with since 1976, he is the author of numerous articles on the subject of animal rights and of Il grido degli innocenti and Il patto tradito fra l'uomo e il cane. Alongside his work as a blogger and author, he also runs training courses for police officers on the same topics.
But let us return to the book and its themes. The world of animals is big business, the authors explain — or rather, all too often, dirty business. The trafficking of puppies, the breeding of animals for experimentation, the trade in exotic and dangerous animals, the slaughter of wildlife and protected species are genuine criminal phenomena involving a range of offences, from mistreatment to document fraud to environmental damage. Not to mention the global health risk, such as that experienced during the outbreaks of avian influenza and Covid-19, most likely triggered in the so-called wet markets, the live-animal markets where infected animals, farmed or wild, are sold after slaughter with no controls whatsoever.
"There have been no real changes in this regard, beyond a few attempts, sometimes rather half-hearted, such as the generic inclusion of their protection in the Constitution," Ermanno Giudici adds today, speaking specifically about crimes against animals. "Looking on as an attentive observer, the impression is that there are more announcements than actual changes, because Italian politics often makes promises and, in this field too, almost never keeps them. Not to mention the reform of the criminal justice process, which will cause a large share of proceedings for mistreatment and trafficking to lapse under the statute of limitations and, in any case, will almost never reach a final verdict. It is therefore difficult to claim that there have been any truly significant improvements in the way animals are regarded and protected."

The issue of crimes against animals is an open and concrete one that formed the focus of a recent conversation I had with Giudici on a topic that is often little known and poorly publicised. And to the initial problem are added further pieces that contribute to widening the picture. Recently, for example, right here on LifeGate, I wrote about a law "protecting" wild animals. Is it consistent with the path towards safeguarding the welfare and protection of these species?
"The law in question derives from a European regulation of 2016 introduced — prophetically — to counter the pandemics that could be caused by zoonoses transmitted by wild animals; animals that represent, especially in the most remote parts of the world, a reservoir of viruses that should be treated with great caution, with efforts made to limit contact. Despite the fact that the regulation, finally transposed into our legal system only in 2021, required implementing decrees to be issued by May of this year, we are, in reality, still very much at sea. There are too many interests behind the market for animals kept in Italian homes, and so compromise solutions are being sought that will save everything except the welfare of non-conventional or wild species, which quite simply should no longer be living in family homes and cages. For the sake of both civilisation and public health."
A far from encouraging response, which leaves the field open to new questions arising from the war scenarios that have recently emerged and from the entry into Europe of refugees and their pets, which are often carriers of diseases that seemed to have been eradicated here. Rabies, for example. "The countries of eastern Europe have always been a transit route for illegally trafficked wild animals, or for what is known as 'puppy trafficking' — the phenomenon that every year moves eight million dog and cat puppies along European roads, causing unspeakable suffering for various reasons ranging from transportation to breeding conditions.
The war could exacerbate this phenomenon even further — a phenomenon that, when not subject to the necessary health checks, can pose a risk to human health and to animal health as well. It is a risk that must not be underestimated but that, in times of economic crisis, could end up failing to receive the attention it deserves. This could mean further trafficking of species captured in the wild, with a worsening of the depletion of the planet's natural capital."

The picture, then, is not a particularly bright one, even if there are moments when a glimmer of hope seems to emerge — one that could lead to a more coherent vision of the environment and the natural world around us. And it is perhaps in the name of a new awareness of the ecosystem that Ermanno Giudici adds, in closing his contribution: "The remedy for all the ills afflicting animals runs along a double track: judicial and cultural. We need stricter laws, with effective penalties that act as a genuine deterrent to criminals, and a cultural shift among those who consider themselves animal lovers — who are often the first to trample on animals' rights without even realising it.
We know that all markets, including those entailing high levels of animal suffering, are driven by demand, and that is where we must intervene. We need to make people understand how respect — for laws and for living beings alike — is the essential first step towards a new culture, one in which love for animals is not translated into the satisfaction of our own needs, but into attention to their suffering. It is still a very long process, one on which associations too should work with greater commitment, without fear of losing consensus." A hope that, perhaps, in the years ahead will help us to invent a different world. A fairer and freer one for all who inhabit it, whether human or animal.