In 2016, 22.5 million people fled their land due to extreme events caused by global warming. “We risk having 1.5 billion environmental refugees in the near future,” according to diplomat Grammenos Mastrojeni. Resilience is the answer.
Defence professionals call it "climate security." It refers to the comprehensive incorporation of climate change into geopolitical and national security strategies aimed at adapting to the new projected scenarios. In 2016, the US Department of Defense defined climate change as "a threat multiplier and a source of instability," with significant potential to exacerbate humanitarian crises, migration and military interventions, as well as eroding the stability of security infrastructure — from military bases to the effectiveness of policing operations. Much to the displeasure of climate denier Donald Trump.
Yet the most important issue relating to security concerns the possibility of sustainable development for all peoples. When the environmental conditions for economic growth, for agriculture and livestock farming cease to exist — when it becomes impossible to live a peaceful and secure life — human beings have, since the dawn of time, moved in order to adapt to new environmental conditions. But in a world of nation states, with more than seven billion people and ever-diminishing fertile land, mass migrations, both domestic and international, could soon turn into large-scale political instability, widespread social tensions, and even outright wars.
"The effects of these environmental migrations could be terrifying," says Grammenos Mastrojeni, coordinator for Environment and Development Cooperation at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and author of the book Effetto serra, effetto guerra. "We would be looking at a migration potential of nearly one and a half billion people, mainly coming from fragile ecosystems and fragile societies." Such as arid zones, mountain areas, island states and the most vulnerable coastal zones: all regions of the planet exposed to the dangerous effects of climate change. The worst-affected region? "It will be the two Himalayan slopes, where the melting of glaciers will trigger alternating periods of drought and extreme rainfall events."
Climate security requires both mitigation and adaptation policies
For environmental organisations such as Italian climate network, addressing migration means tackling decarbonisation policies in developed countries, first and foremost. "The science is clear: we need to focus on both mitigation and adaptation, with shared commitments from all developed and developing countries," says Francesca Mingrone, director of Italian climate network. "The ambition within the Paris Agreement must be raised if we are to avoid worsening migratory phenomena. Europe must eliminate subsidies to fossil fuels and promote an even more ambitious national energy strategy on renewables."
The number of environmental refugees is set to rise
For those who study migratory phenomena, it is becoming increasingly clear that water and soil are the primary environmental factors driving mobility and those most affected by climate change. This is underscored by non-governmental organisations such as Gvc, Oxfam, Save the children, and international institutions such as the World economic forum, which in its Global risk report 2016 listed water crises and soil erosion among the main drivers of migration. Overall, since 2009 one person per second has been forced to leave their land due to catastrophic weather events. In 2016 alone, there were 22.5 million environmental refugees, some of them displaced by water-related problems such as drought, flooding and sea-level rise.
By 2050, according to calculations by Professor Norman Myers of the University of Oxford, refugees linked to the effects of climate change could number more than 150 million. Currently, around 1.6 billion people — one in four — live in countries with low physical availability of water, and projections suggest this figure could double within two decades. The majority live in countries with limited financial capacity — as in the case of Ethiopia — to build the infrastructure needed to address water scarcity, and lacking either the political will to join bilateral and multilateral treaties and agreements, or adequate governance capacity.
Many environmental migrants, however, will share one characteristic: they will move internally, at a domestic level, primarily affecting the poorest segments of the population — smallholder farmers who lack the resources for long-distance displacement. In some particularly acute cases, these individuals will remain trapped in affected areas, with no means of moving except on foot, giving rise to prolonged emergency situations.
Work must be done to restore ecosystems
"Cooperation proposes a distinctly Italian philosophy, one that starts from the rediscovery of regenerative agriculture, of slow food and of the value of local territories," explains Mastrojeni. "Intervening on regeneration means starting from the weakest link in development. Where there is degradation of nature, there is degradation of productivity." This distinctly Italian framework is beginning to spread among NGOs and other international institutions, which see a major opportunity to address the root causes of population displacement. By working on ecosystem restoration, the cycles of carbon, water and nitrogen are reactivated, thereby regenerating soils — a key element, together with water, for restoring productivity. "Land management and the rediscovery of natural balances become an obligatory choice, one that must cut across every international cooperation project, with a view to a large-scale circular economy. By injecting this vision into all existing projects, significant impacts can be achieved at limited cost," Mastrojeni continues.
Recovering a hectare of degraded land comes at highly variable costs — from a few tens of dollars for semi-arid and semi-degraded land under the most favourable conditions, to tens of thousands of dollars required to restore, for example, complex coastal biomes. Nevertheless, the majority of the land where the degradation–instability nexus is materialising can be recovered at a cost of no more than 250 dollars per hectare, and these soils are mostly located in the areas of origin of the growing migratory waves reaching Europe, particularly in the Sahel. Their recovery transforms them into carbon sinks whose annual absorption tends to be equivalent to the emissions savings achievable through a renewable energy investment of 1,000–1,500 US dollars. Regenerating the planet is the only key to enabling a prosperous future for populations within their own territories.
This article first appeared in Oltremare, the magazine of the Italian Agency for Development Cooperation (Aics)
Climate security: how to regenerate the Earth starting from migration
Environment — di Emanuele Bompan
In 2016, 22.5 million people fled their land due to extreme events caused by global warming. “We risk having 1.5 billion environmental refugees in the near future,” according to diplomat Grammenos Mastrojeni. Resilience is the answer.