Cultivated meat, why there is talk of the government withdrawing the bill on synthetic food

Cultivated meat, why there is talk of the government withdrawing the bill on synthetic food

Food · ·

In recent days there has been talk of a possible withdrawal of the bill on synthetic food by the government, but Minister Lollobrigida has denied it. In recent days there has been talk of a possible withdrawal of the bill on synthetic food by the government, but Minister Lollobrigida has denied it.

Is the Italian government making a U-turn on the bill on so-called synthetic food? According to some reports, Agriculture Minister Francesco Lollobrigida is said to be ready to withdraw the legislative proposal that imposes a ban on producing and selling laboratory-made foods — first and foremost cultivated meat — in our country. This choice is said to be driven by fears that the bill could be rejected by the European Union.

cibo sintetico
The bill on synthetic foods presented on 28 March at the Council of Ministers is the first measure of this kind at an international level © Getty Images

The clue pointing to a withdrawal of the synthetic food bill

The news stemmed from Italy's withdrawal of the Tris notification for this bill: this is a procedure by which member states must notify the European Commission of legislative proposals relating to products, which are then assessed in light of European Union legislation. EU law could reject the bill for one main reason: were Efsa, the European Food Safety Authority, to give the green light to synthetic food — currently not authorised within the EU — the Italian measure could not ban its sale under the principle of the free movement of goods between member states.

Minister Lollobrigida denies it: "We're pressing ahead"

For his part, on social media, Minister Lollobrigida denied any intention to withdraw the bill, which the Chamber of Deputies will shortly be called upon to debate. Lollobrigida also stated that the withdrawal of the Tris notification is merely a formality that has been carried out on other occasions. "Not only am I not withdrawing the bill," the minister concluded, "but I am more convinced than ever that we must act on the requests of municipalities, regions (all of them) and the millions of Italian citizens who have explicitly asked us to protect our health and our economy. On this battle for civilisation, as with all the commitments made by the government, we are pressing ahead. Without taking a single step back."

The progress of the bill

The bill on synthetic food had been presented to the Council of Ministers last 28 March by Lollobrigida himself as "the first measure of this kind at an international level, aimed at protecting health, our production, our environment and a way of life that connects food production in the relationship between people, work, the land and farming". The news had made headlines around the world and reignited the debate on cultivated meat, between those who consider it "part of the solution" and those who see it as a "false solution". In July the bill received first approval from the Senate; now, the rumour of a possible reversal — even if denied — is giving hope to animal rights organisations and supporters of the cause.