Why lab-grown meat is a false solution to the climate crisis
Food — di Manlio Masucci
Lab-grown meat is a green narrative that seems perfectly suited to consumers' demand for change. But it is a false solution. Here's why.

Lab-grown meat is a green narrative that seems perfectly suited to consumers' demand for change. But it is a false solution. Here's why.
Do you remember when, in recent months and years, so much was said about the impact of industrial agriculture on soil, groundwater, air and, finally, on climate change? Do you remember citizens' protests against the massive and senseless use of pesticides and synthetic chemical fertilisers responsible for today's environmental contamination? The argument was: "we are of the earth" — we must change our production paradigm before we bring the planet to collapse. Faced with the evidence of the damage done and with the positive trials of agroecological alternatives, faced with the voices and mobilisations coming from threatened and ailing territories, certain political initiatives had been met with renewed hope. Among these were the European Commission's strategies for biodiversity conservation, the goal of increasing the area under organic cultivation, and the gradual reduction of synthetic chemical pesticide use in agriculture.

Now, have you ever wondered what the hybrid seed, GMO and biotechnology industries — the agrotoxin industry — were doing while environmentalists, consumers and organic producers were trying to build new, shorter ecological supply chains, anti-waste models that could also revive local economies? The right answer is the one you're already thinking: the industry was calculating how catastrophically negative an impact such a scenario could have on its balance sheets and dividends.
How do you survive the ecologist tsunami? Defending the old production paradigm made no sense. Of course, millions of euros could still be spent on lobbying to get glyphosate reauthorised in Europe — but then what? New proposals and new solutions were needed. New ideas to keep positions of power, control and profit intact. The two main directions agritech has decided to pursue are essentially: the second generation of GMOs and artificial meat. Both solutions are perfect because they involve patents, market control and profits — and, above all, they fit the green narrative perfectly, in other words they lend themselves to unscrupulous greenwashing initiatives.
The Italian case caused a stir because the government chose to act on both issues ahead of Europe — ante litteram — perhaps to claim a kind of Italian primacy always useful for propaganda purposes. Haste, however, is a poor adviser, and so while the big drum of the precautionary principle and the protection of Italian produce was beating loudly, slamming the door in the face of lab-grown meat, the window was being opened to let in the other great threat to our food sovereignty: second-generation GMOs. A true logical, political and ideological paradox.

The hasty embrace of the lab-grown meat business will not save the planet — it will save the agritech industry, which was at risk of losing significant market share. At the heart of this market solution there is no ecological vision encompassing soil regeneration, the protection of water resources or communities' food sovereignty; there is simply a marketing equation: more and more consumers are troubled by the deplorable conditions of intensive livestock farming? No problem — just produce fake meat. Frankenstein food, as it was called in the case of GMOs.
Those who raise doubts about artificial meat often invoke the precautionary principle. In this case, precaution concerns paying particular attention to the production processes behind placing the product on the market — both health-related and nutritional. It is indeed important to bear in mind that attempting to reconstruct a food that exists in nature, with the ambition of simulating all its natural characteristics, is not a straightforward or risk-free undertaking, as a recent FAO report on the subject underlines.
Those who choose to trust the same investors and the same industrial conglomerates that for decades told us that pesticides were not harmful to the environment or human health are free to do so. Those who eat junk food — which fills supermarket shelves — will perhaps not ask too many questions about new types of technological foodstuffs, which will probably contain a long list of artificial additives in order to make them more palatable.

But beyond these considerations, one of the greatest risks posed by the lab-grown meat narrative is that it diverts attention from the real alternatives — those being developed right now, bottom-up from local communities, in a participatory, conscious way and with the enthusiasm of those who know they are truly doing the right thing and the beautiful thing. The lab-grown meat solution — a top-down solution imposed on us by industry — risks undermining precisely this, by appealing to those very citizens who are environmentally aware and increasingly critical of industrial food production. To achieve this, the industry has created a false dichotomy between cultured meat and intensive livestock farming. That is the choice the industry is offering us. The real world is something else entirely! And we are truly free to choose from a range of options — not only those the industry puts before us.
Agroecology, small-scale organic farming and livestock rearing, the role of farmers and shepherds as stewards of our landscapes and our land, the development of circular economies and short supply chains — these not only regenerate the land but also social and economic fabrics. By fostering the illusion that we can live outside nature's ecological processes, the artificial meat business will do nothing but increase multinational corporations' control over food and health, accelerate the collapse of local food economies and further erode food democracy. The real solution to the environmental and health crisis is based on an active path of planetary regeneration, working in concert with ecological processes through agroecological and regenerative practices.
The views expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect those of LifeGate.