Pesticides on our plates: the proportion of contaminated food is rising
Food — di Carlotta Garancini
According to the Legambiente dossier, of more than 4,000 food samples analysed, 44.1 per cent were found to be contaminated with pesticides.

According to the Legambiente dossier, of more than 4,000 food samples analysed, 44.1 per cent were found to be contaminated with pesticides.
The proportion of foods contaminated with pesticides reaching Italian tables is rising: according to the latest "Stop Pesticidi nel piatto" report produced by Legambiente in collaboration with Alce Nero, traces of one or more plant protection products were found in 44.1 per cent of the food samples analysed. Only 54.8 per cent of the total samples showed no pesticide residues, whereas the same survey last year had reached 63 per cent.

In 2021, the dossier analysed 4,313 samples of foods of plant and animal origin, including products derived from beekeeping of both Italian and foreign origin. Traces of one or more plant protection products were found in 44.1 per cent of samples – specifically, 14.3 per cent of samples contained a single residue and 29.8 per cent contained multiple residues – albeit within legal limits. Irregular samples, that is, those with active substances above permitted thresholds, accounted for 1 per cent, a slight decrease compared with the previous year. As many as 90 active substances were detected: the most prevalent pesticides were Acetamiprid, Boscalid, Fludioxonil, Azoxystrobin, Tebuconazole and Fluopyram.
Fruit is confirmed, as in previous dossiers, as the most affected category: more than 70.3 per cent of samples contain one or more residues. With regard to vegetables, the picture is better: 65.5 per cent of samples analysed showed no residues. Among the most striking cases in the analyses were a sample of grapes with 14 residues, one of pears with 12 residues, and one of peppers with 10 residues. Among processed foods, wine and processed wholegrains showed the highest percentages of permitted residues, with approximately 61.8 per cent and 77.7 per cent of samples found to be contaminated, respectively.
"From the analysis of the data collected," declared Angelo Gentili, Legambiente's agriculture coordinator, "the need to pursue the path of agroecology with even greater determination clearly emerges, putting into practice, in a resolute and unwavering manner, what has been established by the European Farm to Fork and Biodiversity 2030 directives." With regard to organic produce, 91.1 per cent of samples were found to be compliant and free of residues. No samples with multi-residue traces were found either. As for samples with a single residue, the percentage stands at around 5.4 per cent, a figure likely linked to the so-called drift effect caused by neighbouring conventional crops.

Legambiente therefore highlighted the importance of following up on the recent approval of the organic farming law through the allocation of resources and by increasing organically farmed areas; it also emphasised the urgency of approving, at national level, the new National Action Plan for the sustainable use of plant protection products (Pan) and, at European level, the regulation on the use of plant protection products (Sur) presented on 22 June last year by the European Commission. The latter sets legally binding pesticide reduction targets for member states, which are currently at risk due to the repeated requests for postponements from certain countries, including Italy.
On the subject of renewals and derogations in pesticide use, on the occasion of the recent extension for glyphosate, an in-depth investigation by Foodwatch International revealed that 30 per cent of pesticides currently authorised in the European Union (135 out of 455) are extended without a new risk assessment. "Glyphosate is just the tip of the iceberg: one in three pesticides currently approved in the EU has been approved by extension, without a new and definitive risk assessment by the European Food Safety Authority (Efsa). This is absolutely irresponsible and unacceptable," said Lars Neumeister of Foodwatch International. "The EU's pesticide authorisation system has so many flaws that reform is urgently needed." One example concerns deltamethrin, a neurotoxic insecticide that paralyses insects: even though it is classified as moderately toxic by the World Health Organization and as a "candidate for substitution" in the EU due to its potentially harmful effects, its use has been continuously extended since 2013.

Foodwatch is therefore calling for all pesticides whose approvals have been extended without Efsa having carried out a new risk assessment to be immediately withdrawn, and for the European Union to define a coherent and effective pesticide exit strategy for a pesticide-free EU agriculture by 2035.