Don't call it synthetic. Cultivated meat is part of the solution

Don't call it synthetic. Cultivated meat is part of the solution

Environment · ·

The Italian bill against cultivated meat is an anti-scientific, ideological choice that harms the Italian economy, the environment and animals.

On Wednesday 19 July, the Senate approved the bill presented by Agriculture Minister Francesco Lollobrigida banning the production and sale of cultivated meat, and this is one of the flagship measures of this Government in the agricultural and food sector.

Within the proposal, in addition to the ban that – in practice – prevents the production of and scientific research into cultivated meat in Italy, a specific article was inserted that also bans the use of terms such as "burger" and "cotoletta" for all entirely plant-based products. A heavily fortified proposal that the majority inserted (and approved, at least for now) under pressure from the two main trade associations representing livestock farmers and meat producers, in order to obstruct potential competitors.

What cultivated meat is

Carne coltivata
The technology behind the production of cultivated meat is the same used in regenerative medicine © Getty Images

But what exactly is the cultivated meat that so frightens associations such as Coldiretti, Confagricoltura and many others? Cultivated meat is obtained by taking cells from a live, healthy animal. This is a technique that has already been used for years in regenerative medicine, taking cells from a living muscle that are then made to proliferate – cultivated, hence the name – in a bioreactor that replicates the same conditions as the animal body (temperature, acidity, pH, etc.), and fed with a mixture of nutrients (glucose, vitamins, minerals). To put it plainly, these are the same bioreactors used in the production of yoghurt, beer and wine.

For quite some time, those who oppose (or are alarmed by) cultivated meat have often deliberately used the term "synthetic" to describe it. This is an incorrect and misleading term, since cultivated meat derives from a sample taken from already living animals and is, to all intents and purposes, real meat.

Given, then, that there is nothing synthetic about it, how much truth is there in the many criticisms levelled at cultivated meat regarding its alleged negative impacts in environmental and health terms?

Hamburger Carne coltivata
Lab-grown meat is meat in every respect, being produced from cells taken from live, healthy animals © Getty Images

The associations' positions

Coldiretti, as well as the Ministry of Agriculture through its current head Francesco Lollobrigida, has repeatedly promoted the news of the study that attributes to synthetic meat an ecological footprint four to 25 times greater than that of conventionally farmed meat. However, this figure is based on a piece of research – Environmental impacts of cultured meat – carried out by five researchers at the University of California and deposited as a pre-print on the online archive BioRxiv, that is, before being subjected to peer review. We are therefore not talking about a study that has been verified and published in a scientific journal, but for the time being only on an online portal. The authors themselves, moreover, specified in the text that these are very preliminary figures, calculated on small-scale facilities, with ingredients and machinery not optimised for large-scale production. For this reason the researchers themselves suggested investing in research specifically to improve the current technologies used to produce cultivated meat, in order to avoid replicating at large scale mechanisms with an excessive environmental impact.

Production

The production of cultivated meat is, yes, still energy-intensive today, but several studies have shown that producing cultivated meat in a laboratory using renewable energy would have a significantly lower carbon footprint than even traditionally produced "sustainably farmed" meat products. In any case, the energy-intensive aspect is just one of many. When talking about environmental impact, it is not only the energy consumed that matters, but also other factors, such as land use, deforestation and water consumption, all elements that are strongly associated with the production and consumption of conventional meat. To give a complete answer, therefore, it is not correct to take into account only one element of environmental impact, but to consider all factors: in this sense, it becomes clear that conventional livestock farming remains one of the main drivers of global warming and of a whole series of very serious environmental impacts on the planet.

carne coltivata
Cultivated meat is antibiotic-free and eliminates the risk of antibiotic resistance © Blue Nalu

As regards health, Italy has witnessed a true manipulation of scientific data from the FAO, the United Nations organisation for food and agriculture. Within the FAO–WHO report "Food safety aspects of cell-based food", the agency in fact identified certain health risks that are entirely comparable to those of conventional red meat. In its manifesto, Coldiretti used the FAO's 53 points to alarm potential consumers, implying that these are risks exclusive to cell-based food. The report, however, makes clear that the very same risks are found in conventional meat products and in common food processing. Not only that: unlike intensive livestock farming, where the widespread use of antibiotics for preventive purposes and the outbreak of deadly epidemics – such as avian flu in the case of poultry farms – are standard practice, cultivated meat is antibiotic-free and eliminates the risk of antibiotic resistance and the emergence and spread of diseases potentially transmissible to other animals and to humans.

There is, however, an indisputable and fundamental benefit that cultivated meat brings with it: the elimination of violence and cruelty towards animals that are still confined in farms today.

Italy's position

Coldiretti has repeatedly attempted to discredit this indisputable truth as well, arguing that cultivated meat is in fact not very respectful of animal welfare because it requires the use of animal foetal serum. Compared to the past, however, when producing this meat did indeed require the use of animal foetal serum as a cell culture medium, today completely cruelty-free plant-based alternatives have been developed. A single fragment of meat the size of a peppercorn would be sufficient to produce thousands of burgers, identical to those produced from real farmed animals.

NO AL CIBO SINTETICO

La diffusione del #cibosintetico è un problema gravissimo.
Contrasterò in ogni sede la produzione di cibo artificiale.
Finché saremo al governo, sulle tavole degli italiani non arriveranno alimenti creati in laboratorio.

As if that were not enough, the Government's proposal – which will soon reach the Chamber of Deputies for the final vote – is also strongly anti-economic: in the face of all these benefits for the environment, health and animals, Italy intends to prevent its own companies from investing in this country for this type of production, thus in practice leaving the market to foreign firms. Were it to be approved at European level, Italy would be unable to ban the marketing of cultivated meat produced abroad, thereby favouring foreign production. Rather than working towards a Made in Italy production, this law will therefore disadvantage and impoverish Italy's food economic sector.

carne coltivata di pesce
Cultivated meat production also includes fish and seafood © Wildtype

Cultivated meat abroad

And while Italy is still debating whether cultivated meat should or shouldn't be allowed, many companies abroad are already on the move. For some time now, in several countries such as the United States, Israel and Singapore, it has already been possible to taste cultivated meat. Moreover, in the last few weeks a number of important consumption approvals and authorisation requests have come through: on 21 June, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) approved for the first time the sale and consumption of cultivated meat produced by two companies, GOOD Meat and UPSIDE Foods, while on 21 July the Israeli cellular agriculture company Aleph Farms submitted to the FSA, the Food Standards Agency — the government body responsible for food safety and hygiene in England, Wales and Northern Ireland — a preliminary authorisation dossier for the market launch of cultivated beef steaks in the United Kingdom. A few days later (ed., 26 July), the same company then announced that it had submitted an approval request to the relevant authorities for the commercialisation of cultivated meat in Switzerland as well.

Cultivated meat, also known as lab-grown meat, has been cleared for sale in the United States cnn.it/46gg8Up

So, much to the chagrin of its detractors, cultivated meat is making headway and will be part of the future of food — a food that is more respectful of the environment and animals, and that in Italy too should be protected and encouraged. We hope that our Members of Parliament, when called upon to vote on this ill-conceived measure, will take into account the future of our planet, of animals and of our economy.

The opinions expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect those of LifeGate.