In Montana, a court delivered (climate) justice by listening to young people

In Montana, a court delivered (climate) justice by listening to young people

Environment · ·

A Montana judge ruled in favour of the 16 young people aged between 5 and 22 who had sued the state over its support for fossil fuels.

Montana's young people mean business. On Monday, a judge of the District Court of Lewis and Clark County, in the American state, ruled in favour of the 16 environmentalists who, some months ago, had taken Montana to court, accusing its leaders of violating their constitutional right to a clean and healthy environment. The activists are critical of the work of Republican Governor Greg Gianforte. Just two days ago, their fight was vindicated by the first, historic, ruling of condemnation in a climate justice trial that is already, in and of itself, a unique case in United States legal history.

BREAKING! In historic first, Judge Kathy Seeley ruled wholly in favor of the 16 youth plaintiffs in Held v. State of Montana, declaring that the state of Montana violated the youth’s constitutional climate rights. Read press release: bit.ly/MTRuling-PR #YouthvGovMT

How the historic climate justice trial in Montana began

The trial had begun last June in a court in Helena, the capital of Montana. 16 young activists who are residents of the state, aged between 5 and 22, appeared before the judges. According to the formal complaint filed by the plaintiffs, supported by Our Children's Trust, a non-profit American law firm, the energy and environmental policies pursued by Montana undermine "the right to a clean and healthy environment", enshrined in the State Constitution. The specific request is to have declared unconstitutional a state law that prevents agencies from considering the effect of greenhouse gases when issuing permits for fossil fuel development.

During the two weeks of proceedings held in June, the plaintiffs, aged between 5 and 22, brought before the judge evidence of how rising emissions in Montana were causing harm both to the territory and to the health of those who live there. Grace Gibson-Snyder, 19, recounted the case of the wildfires that now regularly strike her hometown of Missoula. Fifteen-year-old athlete Mica Kantor described how smoke from the wildfires had worsened her respiratory problems, forcing her to use an inhaler. Among those called to testify was also Rikki Held, 21, who in 2020 sued the state, paving the way for the case Held vs. Montana to reach the courts — the first of its kind to come before a judge in a US state.

Rikki is one of the 16 youth plaintiffs in Held v. State of Montana who took their state government to court over climate change and WON! ✊🌎⚖️ Celebrate this historic win and share the big news by using our social media toolkit: bit.ly/MTRulingToolkit #HeldMakesHistory

The ruling in favour of the 16 plaintiffs

On Monday 14 August, young environmental activists achieved what experts described as a landmark legal victory: Judge Kathy Seeley ruled unconstitutional the policy used by Montana in evaluating permit applications for fossil fuels, on the grounds that it "does not allow for the assessment of the effects of greenhouse gas emissions." If it holds, the ruling could set an important legal precedent, although experts said the immediate impacts are limited and state authorities have pledged to seek to overturn the decision on appeal.

The ruling is nonetheless a first that will go down in United States legal history, marking the first time an American court has ruled against a government for violating a constitutional right on the basis of climate change: "It is still a state court, not a federal one, and the ruling is based on a state constitution and not on the United States Constitution, but it is still clearly an important and landmark victory for the climate plaintiffs," Harvard law professor Richard Lazarus told Associated Press.

In her ruling, Judge Seeley rejected the state's argument that Montana's emissions are insignificant, stating that they were "a substantial factor" in climate change. This is indeed what the facts confirm: Montana ranks fifth among US states for coal production, twelfth for oil production, and since 2011 has banned the consideration of climate issues when issuing new gas and oil permits. "Every additional tonne of greenhouse gas emissions aggravates the plaintiffs' injuries and risks causing irreversible climate damage," Seeley wrote.

A ruling is not enough to change Montana's environmental policies

As is often the case in such matters, it is important not to view the ruling as an unmistakable sign of imminent change: "The ruling provides nothing beyond emotional support for the many cases seeking to establish a public trust right, a human right, or a federal constitutional right" to a healthy environment, said James Huffman, dean emeritus of Lewis & Clark Law School in Portland.

Giustizia climatica
The 16 activists arrived at the courthouse surrounded by messages of support © Our Children's Trust

As already described, Montana is and remains a state strongly in favour of fossil fuels. It has been even more so since Greg Gianforte, governor since 2021, withdrew it from the US Climate Alliance – a coalition of states committed to cutting emissions – signing two laws to prevent the closure of coal-fired power plants. This means that only through a rethinking of the state's environmental policies will it be possible to give concrete follow-through to what the court has established. To date, in fact, very few American states such as Pennsylvania, Massachusetts and New York have constitutions with similar environmental protections. The road ahead for Montana's combative young people is still long, and will necessarily have to lead to a political solution.