The UN calls for climate justice, before it becomes a verdict for everyone

The UN calls for climate justice, before it becomes a verdict for everyone

Environment · ·

A historic UN resolution has asked the International Court of Justice to rule on the environmental obligations of governments, especially the most polluting ones.

The General Assembly of the United Nations has passed a historic resolution on climate justice. At a session held yesterday, Wednesday 29 March, more than 130 states voted in favour of an initiative promoted by Vanuatu calling on the International Court of Justice to provide governments with its opinion on the climate obligations that countries around the world are required to uphold, with the aim of "protecting future generations". In plain terms, the climate resolution asks the UN's principal judicial body to provide guidance on the legal responsibility of states, particularly the most polluting ones, in an attempt to move even the most reluctant governments towards positions compatible with global climate goals.

#UNGA adopts resolution requesting advisory opinion of @CIJ_ICJ on countries' obligation to address the climate crisis. news.un.org/en/story/2023/… #ClimateAction

Vanuatu, the driving force behind the UN resolution

The main promoter of the resolution was Vanuatu, an island nation in the Pacific Ocean that risks disappearing due to rising sea levels and that has for years been at the forefront of denouncing the devastating effects of global warming: "We have witnessed a victory of epic proportions for climate justice," declared Ishmael Kalsakau, the country's Prime Minister. "Today's resolution is the beginning of a new era in multilateral climate cooperation, an era that focuses more on compliance with international law and that places human rights and intergenerational equity at the forefront of climate decision-making."

The resolution was also driven by many young activists from the Pacific islands themselves. Cynthia Houniuhi, president of Pacific students engaged in the fight against climate change, declared: "We are overjoyed that the world has listened to us. It is not our fault that we are witnessing devastating tropical cyclones, flooding, biodiversity loss and rising sea levels. We have contributed minimally to the global emissions that are drowning our land."

What the International Court of Justice will be able to rule on

Under the resolution, the Court will be required to assess whether failure to comply with climate agreements — such as those of the Paris Agreement of 2015 or those concluded at the end of COPs, the climate conferences — could entail legal consequences for countries that "violate" them. In particular, the judges' assessments will be based on the policies adopted by governments to contain global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels by the end of the century, while remaining well below the 2°C threshold that represents the point of no return. Alongside the global goal, the so-called NDCs will also be taken into consideration — an acronym standing for Nationally Determined Contributions — that is, the emissions reduction pledges made by governments around the world and repeatedly left unfulfilled.

As established by the United Nations Charter, the treaty that founded the organisation, the Court's opinion in such circumstances is not binding — it does not impose legal obligations on states — but it could constitute a powerful element of political and diplomatic pressure on countries least inclined to honour the outcomes of international agreements. An explanation to this effect came directly from the United Nations Secretary-General, António Guterres, who told delegates that the Court's opinion could help world leaders take the stronger, bolder climate action the world needs: "For some countries, climate threats are a death sentence. In reality, it is the initiative of these countries, joined by many others, together with the efforts of young people around the world, that unites us. And, together, you are making history," Guterres said.

Climate justice is both a moral imperative & a prerequisite for effective global #ClimateAction.

The climate crisis can only be overcome through cooperation – between peoples, cultures, nations, generations.

Let's work together to get the job done.

Italy is among the signatories, but the notable absentee is the United States

Our country is also among the more than 120 states that promoted the resolution. But dampening the enthusiasm surrounding a measure of such significance is the absence of the United States, which does not appear among the signatories of the initiative. This is a signal that must be read above all in the light of the Biden administration's recent decision to launch the Willow Project, a large-scale oil drilling project worth 7 billion dollars covering an area of more than 90 million hectares on the North Slope, in northern Alaska — the largest tract of untouched public land in the United States. In this sense, the resolution takes shape as an act of great symbolic impact, one that seeks to generate repercussions on the political conduct of countries that, like the United States, have until now maintained deeply ambiguous positions on climate, scaling back — or in practice repudiating — the commitments made at negotiating tables. And as is so often the case, those same countries are frequently among the greatest contributors to the environmental devastation that occurs every day before our eyes, drawing the line between the life and death of entire ecosystems and all the forms of life that inhabit them.