A climate justice lawsuit that could make history has begun in Montana

A climate justice lawsuit that could make history has begun in Montana

Environment · ·

16 young activists are accusing the American state of Montana of having denied them “the right to a clean and healthful environment” guaranteed by the Constitution.

On Monday 12 June, in a court in Helena, the capital of Montana, a trial began that has already made history in the field of climate justice in the United States. It is in fact the first case in which the government of a federal state will have to answer for having denied its citizens the constitutionally guaranteed right to live in a healthy environment. A case that could add another piece to the past rulings that have established institutions' duty to protect citizens from the effects of climate change.

Montana youth are making climate history TODAY! Trial in Held v. State of Montana begins at 9:00am MT in Helena. Details about this first-of-its-kind climate trial can be found at: bit.ly/MTClimateTrial #YouthvGovMT

Sixteen young resident activists aged between 5 and 22, living in Montana, appeared before the judges to accuse the State of having endangered the health of its own citizens by supporting fossil fuels. The formal charge brought by the plaintiffs, backed by Our Children's Trust, a non-profit American law firm, is that the energy and environmental policies pursued by Montana in recent years conflict with "the right to a clean and healthful environment", enshrined in the State Constitution.

The stories behind the lawsuit against the American state

In the complaint filed, the young people explained how climate change has affected their lives. Grace Gibson-Snyder, 19, described the wildfires that regularly engulf her hometown of Missoula, while the water level in the surrounding rivers drops visibly. Rikki Held, 21, spoke about the water supply difficulties on the family ranch and the resulting economic and health consequences.

rikki held speaks about what it's like to work on her family's ranch during 110 degree heat and intense smoke from wildfires, like what she saw in the brutal summer of 2021

Tuesday was the turn of Mica Kantor, a 15-year-old athlete who, during his testimony, recounted how smoke from wildfires makes it difficult for him to compete, and that a doctor prescribed him an inhaler to help with his respiratory problems. According to Associated Press, Kantor told of how, at the age of 4, he dictated a letter to a local senator — because he was too young to write it himself — in which he expressed concern that, due to climate change, it was becoming increasingly difficult to run or go hiking with his family. Among the testimonies was also that of paediatrician Lori Byron, who reported on the effects of climate change on the physical and mental health of children, as well as on the growing number of cases of asthma and other respiratory problems.

Giustizia ambientale

Held v. Montana, a legal battle that began in 2020

The trial marks the arrival in court of the Held vs. Montana case, filed in March 2020. It comes on the back of a series of decisions made by Montana's Republican government that have opened the door to new oil, gas and coal projects. The plaintiffs' specific request is for a state law to be declared unconstitutional — a law that prevents agencies from considering the effect of greenhouse gases when issuing permits for fossil fuel development. The rule, the prosecution argues, conflicts with Article 3 of the Montana Constitution, according to which all persons have inalienable rights, including the right "to a clean and healthful environment", while Article 9 states that "the state and each person shall maintain and improve a clean and healthful environment in Montana for present and future generations", and the preamble makes clear that all provisions apply to future generations as well.

Young people in Montana are fighting for their future.

For the first time, a youth-led climate case will go to trial in the United States. #ClimateCrisis

As far back as 2011, the law firm that now supports the activists had brought the case to the attention of the Montana Supreme Court, without result. The lawyers therefore chose to build a legal action starting from the first degree of judgement, involving the local community, which better than anyone else could bring to the table the concrete problems arising from the State's fossil fuel policies. For now, both Governor Greg Gianforte and Attorney General Austin Knudsen, both Republicans, have rejected all charges and disputed every scientific basis that recognises fossil fuels as a cause of climate change.

For Montana's environmentalists and, more broadly, for the national opposition to fossil fuel exploitation, the trial could represent a genuine turning point, given that similar cases have already been dismissed in almost every other state. If the judge were to recognise fossil fuels as a cause of global warming, it would be a landmark ruling for climate justice. It remains to be seen how far the legal recognition of fossil fuel companies' responsibility for climate change can translate into a concrete step forward from a policy standpoint.