- Greenpeace Italia, ReCommon and 12 citizens have brought a civil case against Eni and its shareholders, the Ministry of Economy and Finance and Cassa depositi e prestiti.
- The oil giant is accused of having contributed to the ongoing climate emergency and of having tried to conceal the responsibilities of fossil fuels.
- The promoters of the legal action have appealed to the Court of Cassation to establish whether the ordinary Italian courts have jurisdiction to rule on these matters.
The civil case against Eni must go ahead. This is why the NGOs Greenpeace Italia and ReCommon, together with 12 Italian citizens, have decided to appeal to the United Civil Sections of the Supreme Court of Cassation, asking it to declare that the ordinary Italian courts have jurisdiction over what they have chosen to rename "La giusta causa".
Why Greenpeace and ReCommon took Eni to court
It has been about a year since, in May 2023, the NGOs Greenpeace Italia and ReCommon, together with 12 citizens living in areas of Italy that are particularly vulnerable to the climate crisis, launched what they chose to call "La giusta causa". They took Eni to court before the Civil Tribunal of Rome, along with the Ministry of Economy and Finance and Cassa depositi e prestiti (Cdp) in their capacity as shareholders.
There are two main charges levelled at the energy giant. The first is that of contributing to the ongoing climate emergency, by helping to release into the atmosphere a volume of greenhouse gases greater than that of Italy as a whole. The second is that of having known for more than fifty years about the harmful consequences of fossil fuel use, while having tried to conceal them through lobbying and greenwashing strategies. The claimants are therefore asking the court to order Eni to cut its own emissions by 45 per cent by 2030, following the trajectory set by the scientific community to keep global warming within 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial levels.
The legal proceedings and the appeal to the Court of Cassation
The first hearing was held in mid-February, but another is scheduled for 13 September, at which the judge will have to rule on the preliminary objections raised by Eni, the Mef and Cdp. These parties have in fact raised the objection of an "absolute lack of jurisdiction": they argue, that is, that no court has the competence to rule on the matter. If this argument were accepted, it would be a major obstacle to any further climate litigation. This comes just a few months after the landmark ruling in which the European Court of Human Rights (Echr) sided with the Senior Women for Climate, finding Switzerland guilty of having acted insufficiently on climate, in violation of their human rights.
"The appeal to the Court of Cassation stems from the need to establish, at the highest judicial level, whether in our country it is legally possible to protect the human rights endangered by the climate emergency caused by human activities," Greenpeace Italia and ReCommon stated in a press release. Pointing the finger at Eni which, in their view, "does not appear to have any intention of addressing the substance of the charges we have brought against it within 'La giusta causa' regarding its past, present and future impact on the planet's climate".