The ECtHR sides with the Senior Women for Climate and condemns Switzerland's climate inaction

The ECtHR sides with the Senior Women for Climate and condemns Switzerland's climate inaction

Environment · ·

The European Court of Human Rights sides with the Senior Women for Climate: Switzerland's climate inaction violates their human rights.

The Senior Women for Climate are in the right. Switzerland has not acted decisively enough against global warming, and this constitutes a violation of their human rights — in particular of Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, on the right to respect for private and family life. This was established by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in a landmark ruling issued on 9 April, which also identifies a violation of Article 6 on access to justice.

What the European Court of Human Rights ruling says

The application had been brought by four women and a Swiss association — the Senior Women for Climate — comprising around 2,300 women over 65. The decision to represent this particular age group is supported by various scientific studies on the dangers that heatwaves pose to the health of elderly women.

While the four individual applicants do not meet the requirements for victim status under Article 34 of the European Convention on Human Rights, the association has the right to bring a claim against its own country on behalf of all those citizens who believe that climate change may threaten their human rights.

In particular, the Court argues, Article 8 of the Convention encompasses the right to be protected from the negative consequences that climate change entails for life, health, wellbeing and quality of life. Switzerland has failed in this duty to protect its citizens — specifically, it has fallen short both in quantifying its greenhouse gas emissions and in meeting its own emission-reduction targets, as well as in adopting laws and measures aimed at mitigating climate change.

Today is a herstoric day for the @KlimaSeniorin in their fight for climate justice: in courtrooms, in the streets, and in the hallways of power! You can continue to support them here: greenpeace.org/klimaseniorinn… greenpeace.org/klimaseniorinn…

The Senior Women for Climate's victory is a landmark precedent

"Today's ruling against Switzerland sets a historic precedent that applies to all European countries," explains Gerry Liston, lawyer at the Global Legal Action Network, the NGO handling the case. This decision, in fact, places an obligation on all European states to set science-based greenhouse gas emission reduction targets aligned with the goal of keeping global warming within 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. "This is an enormous victory for all generations," he concludes.

A victory that was far from guaranteed — and one that opens promising new chapters. "Had the Court not recognised the Convention's mandate for states to actively protect citizens from the repercussions of climate change, it could have placed a substantial barrier to future litigation, representing a step backwards in terms of the evolution of climate law," adds Catherine Higham of the Grantham Research Institute on Climate and the Environment.

"What happened today does not stop at Strasbourg," assures Louise Fournier, the legal adviser at Greenpeace International who supported the legal team of the Senior Women for Climate. "The stories of the KlimaSeniorinnen are also before the International Court of Justice, where hearings on the climate justice obligations of all governments will take place at the beginning of next year."

sentenza della Corte europea per i diritti dell'uomo
The ruling of the European Court of Human Rights is of historic significance © Shervine Nafissi / Greenpeace

No success for the other two climate justice cases

No such outcome, however, for the other two cases concerning climate justice on which the European Court of Human Rights also ruled on 9 April. The application brought by Damien Carême — former mayor of the municipality of Grande-Synthe — challenging the French state for failing to cut greenhouse gas emissions, thereby exposing him to potential climate disasters and compromising his right to life and respect for private life, was declared inadmissible. Having no longer a home in Grande-Synthe and no longer living in France after being elected to the European Parliament, the applicant does not hold victim status under Article 34 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

💬 Some words from Martim today in reaction to the verdict from the @ECHR_CEDH.

Also declared inadmissible was the largest climate legal action ever brought to date, initiated by six young Portuguese nationals against 32 European states. The applicants argued that policies to address global warming were inadequate, to such a degree as to violate their human rights. The Court, however, does not consider the criterion of extraterritorial jurisdiction over the other states to be satisfied. Nor can it rule on Portugal alone, because the young people had not approached a national court beforehand, despite having the opportunity to do so. The essential prerequisite for bringing a case before the ECtHR is to have already exhausted, "in the state in question, all remedies capable of redressing the situation complained of."