Climate: 6 young Portuguese people take 32 European countries to court over inaction

Climate: 6 young Portuguese people take 32 European countries to court over inaction

Environment · ·

On 27 September, 32 states will have to answer to the Strasbourg Court for their actions on climate. The ruling could represent a legal turning point.

Six young Portuguese people are about to appear before the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in an attempt to compel 32 European countries to accelerate their climate commitments and reduce their CO2 emissions, in line with the provisions of the Paris Agreement. The hearing will take place on 27 September: this is the largest climate legal action ever undertaken to date.

The six protagonists are between 11 and 24 years old and say they were driven to act after witnessing the fires that devastated the Leiria region, in the Portuguese province of Beira, in 2017: on that occasion, the flames caused the deaths of 66 people, destroying more than 20,000 hectares of forest.

processo all'inazione climatica
The European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg will rule on a case of climate inaction © Mustafa Yalcin/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

On climate, European states are violating human rights

In the summer of 2023, the hottest on record, fires devastated Portugal, Greece, Spain, Croatia and Italy. The young people who brought the case will highlight to the Strasbourg Court's judges that European states' policies for addressing global warming are inadequate, but above all that they violate human rights.

Should the judges rule in favour of the request brought by the young Portuguese people regarding European governments' climate inaction, it would represent a historic milestone not only for the applicants but also for international jurisprudence. Indeed, the Court's ruling would constitute a precedent with a direct impact on all Council of Europe member countries.

It is the very first case related to climate brought before the ECHR and is the largest of the three climate change trials currently under way.

"We cannot stand by and watch"

"Never before have so many countries together had to defend themselves before a court, anywhere in the world," said Gearóid Ó Cuinn of the Global Legal Action Network (Glan), the lawyers' association supporting the young people. André dos Santos Oliveira, the spokesperson for this campaign, is 15 years old and at the press conference launching the case declared: "European governments are failing and they are not protecting us. All of Europe is experiencing tremendous climate impacts: in Portugal this summer we have experienced ever worsening heatwaves. Which are limiting our ability to make free decisions about our own lives."

At the 27 September hearing, Glan's lawyers will need to bring evidence in support of the fact that the current policies adopted by the 32 countries named in the complaint are violating the rights of those they represent: in particular, the lawyers argue, governments' failure to act on climate is violating young people's right to health, making studying difficult and denying them the possibility of carrying out normal outdoor activities.

"In July, temperatures in Leiria exceeded 40 degrees," stressed Catarina Mota, 23, another of the participants in the case. "Is it so hard to understand that this is only the beginning of the end? Our experts say that at 3 degrees there will be even more extreme heatwaves, lasting a month or more. Governments around the world have the power to stop all of this but instead have chosen not to do their part. We cannot stand by and watch."

No causal link can be established, say the countries

Meanwhile, according to Glan's lawyers, the countries involved (all 27 European Union member states, plus Norway, Russia — which is no longer part of the ECHR following the invasion of Ukraine — Switzerland, the United Kingdom and Turkey) have already submitted their observations to the Court. In essence, the governments of these countries reject all accusations and deny that climate change constitutes a threat to human wellbeing.

Among them is Greece, which in 2023 suffered the worst fires in its history, and which wrote in black and white that "the effects of climate change recorded so far do not appear to directly affect human life or health." And that "no absolute causal relationship can be established between climate change and human health problems: there is great uncertainty about the final mortality balance: whether it is positive or negative."

Similarly, the Irish government rejected the argument, maintaining that no imminent or immediate risk to the lives of these young people can be established. Finally, the Portuguese government stated that the request consists only of "future fears, constituting mere hypotheses or general probabilities." It will now be up to the Strasbourg Court to determine whether that is indeed the case.