Climate justice, the European Court of Human Rights rules on three cases tomorrow

Climate justice, the European Court of Human Rights rules on three cases tomorrow

Environment · ·

The European Court of Human Rights rules on 9 April on three cases aimed at pushing governments to act for climate justice.

Whatever the outcome, Tuesday 9 April 2024 will be a day to remember for climate justice. The Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), in Strasbourg, will deliver three rulings at a public hearing on three cases that differ from one another in nature and origin, but all share the same objective: to compel governments to act more decisively against the climate crisis.

The three climate justice cases before the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR)

Senior Women for Climate Protection versus Switzerland

More than 2,300 women aged over 64 have come together in the association Senior Women for Climate Protection. Assisted by the non-governmental organisation Greenpeace, they have brought a case before the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) against the country in which they live, Switzerland, calling on it to correct its climate policy, "given that the current climate targets and measures are not sufficient to limit global warming to a safe level".

Why does an initiative of this kind originate specifically from elderly women? Because numerous scientific studies show that the risk of mortality and health problems for this particular segment of the population increases considerably during heatwaves, which are being made ever more frequent and intense by the climate crisis. These risks and harms, the legal action argues, are sufficient to engage the state's positive obligations to protect their right to life and well-being, as guaranteed by Articles 2 and 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

anziane per il clima
An elderly woman at a climate demonstration © Ana Fernandez/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images

The municipality of Grande-Synthe versus France

The second case begins in Grande-Synthe, a municipality of around 20,000 inhabitants in the Hauts-de-France region. The former mayor Damien Carême, now a Member of the European Parliament, contests that the French state has failed to adopt all the appropriate measures to stay within the maximum greenhouse gas levels it had itself set.

This inaction, the legal action argues, constitutes a violation of two articles of the Convention on Human Rights. Article 2 (right to life) would oblige states to do everything possible to protect the lives of people under their jurisdiction, including safeguarding them from environmental disasters. In the case of Article 8 (respect for private and family life), the violation concerns Carême personally. Because, the applicant argues, his own home risks being damaged by the flooding that will strike the area in the future — something that makes it impossible to make plans for the future.

Six young Portuguese people versus 32 European countries

Finally, there is the largest climate legal action ever undertaken. On one side, six young Portuguese people born between 1999 and 2012; on the other, no fewer than 32 European countries, accused of having adopted largely inadequate climate policies.

In addition to Articles 2 and 8 of the European Convention, this legal action also invokes Article 14 on the prohibition of discrimination. In particular, the young applicants cite heatwaves, wildfires and the toxic fumes emitted by them, arguing that these phenomena, exacerbated by global warming, are forcing them to change their daily habits (for example, spending more time indoors) and, ultimately, threatening their physical and mental well-being. The fact that the applicants are young is no coincidence, because new generations are destined to bear the worst consequences of climate change, despite having done almost nothing to trigger it.