The civil lawsuit against Eni is just the tip of the iceberg

The civil lawsuit against Eni is just the tip of the iceberg

Energy · ·

The accusation is of having knowingly contributed to the climate crisis. Eni rejects the charges. The company is also criticised over new oil fields.

The multinational Eni will have to face a civil lawsuit in court filed by ReCommon, Greenpeace and 12 Italian citizens who have suffered the consequences of the climate crisis. The organisations that announced the legal action are asking that Eni be condemned for present and future damages, both material and non-material, linked to climate change "to which Eni is significantly contributing through its conduct over recent decades, despite being aware of this," the two associations write in a joint press release. The proceedings have been lodged with the court of Rome and have also been brought against the Ministry of Economy and Finance and Cassa depositi e prestiti, as shareholders of Eni capable of exercising "a dominant influence over the company".

eni-gp-recommon-conferenza-stampa
In the photo, from left, Simona Abbate and Felice Moramarco of Greenpeace Italia, Antonio Tricarico of ReCommon © Greenpeace/ReCommon

The demands of citizens and associations

The two associations and the other private parties in this lawsuit are not seeking quantification of damages but rather an establishment of liability on the part of the Italian energy giant for the damages caused by its oil and gas activities. The campaign #LaGiustaCausa – as the civil lawsuit has been named – calls for Eni to be ordered to limit the total annual aggregate volume of all greenhouse gas emissions (and in particular CO2) into the atmosphere, to such a degree that emissions are reduced by at least 45 per cent by the end of 2030 compared to 2020 levels, on a trajectory consistent with the scenarios drawn up by the international scientific community to keep the average global temperature rise within 1.5 degrees.

Should Eni fail to comply with this obligation, the claimants are seeking an order to pay the sum the judge deems equitable for any breach, non-compliance or delay in executing the ruling. Furthermore, Greenpeace, ReCommon and the individual claimants are asking the judge to order the ministry and Cdp to compel these bodies to adopt as soon as possible a policy defining the climate targets to be promoted within Eni, their monitoring, and guidance in this regard for the future participation of public institutions in the company.

What climate litigation is: the case of the Netherlands

As mentioned, this is the first civil lawsuit on climate against a private-law company in Italy. But it is not the only one in Europe and in the world. The legal action by ReCommon and Greenpeace is, in fact, part of what are known as climate litigation cases — that is, legal actions brought with the aim of compelling governments or companies to comply with specific standards on the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and the limitation of global warming.

At a global level, the total number of climate lawsuits has more than doubled since 2015, bringing the total to over two thousand, with a progressive multiplication of cases filed by citizens and non-governmental organisations demanding that the rights of people affected by the climate crisis be respected and placed at the forefront.

Emblematic in this regard is the case against Shell, brought in the Netherlands by a coalition of environmental organisations – Friends of the Earth, Greenpeace, ActionAid, Both Ends, Fossielvrij Nl, Jongeren Milieu Actief and Waddenvereniging – on behalf of 17,379 citizens. In that case, the court ordered the oil multinational to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 45 per cent by 2030, compared to 2019 levels, in order to align with the requirements imposed by the Paris Agreement on climate. The case against Eni is very similar in structure to the Dutch one against Shell, the lawyers handling the case on behalf of Greenpeace and ReCommon have stated.

manifestazione-eni-roma
A demonstration against Eni in Rome © Simona Granati/Corbis via Getty Images

Eni invested windfall profits in fossil fuels

Setting aside the lawsuit, it has been an intense period for Eni, which is coming under criticism outside the courtroom as well. On 10 May 2023, the Italian multinational held its shareholders' meeting. Ahead of the gathering, the organisation Oil Change International published a report entitled Big oil reality check 2023: Eni, which reveals that the energy strategy of the oil and gas company appears strongly misaligned with global efforts to curb the climate crisis.

As reported in the document, in 2022 Eni invested fifteen times more in industrial segments dominated by fossil fuels than in Plenitude, the subsidiary of the "six-legged dog" – as Eni is known by virtue of its logo – that integrates renewable energy production. Oil Change International also warns that Eni is about to greenlight new oil and gas extraction.

One of these projects concerns gas exploration in Australia's northern waters. It is called Verus and, if exploited, risks becoming one of the most CO2-intensive gas fields in the world. This is revealed in another report, this time produced by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (Ieefa) and released precisely ahead of the shareholders' meeting.

Eni is accused of seeking to explore new gas fields

The exploitation of the Australian field, intended for the production of LNG (liquefied natural gas), according to Ieefa, the American institute engaged in the energy transition, would not only undermine Australia's ambitions to reduce national greenhouse gas emissions by 43 per cent by 2030 compared to 2005 levels, but also Eni's own ambitions to eliminate CO2 by 2035 for all emissions generated by oil and gas extraction and production.

Furthermore, Ieefa raises another serious accusation: the institute states that retail (i.e. private) shareholders of the energy company embraced Eni's sustainability ambitions by subscribing in January to 2 billion euros in a bond issuance linked to the goal of climate neutrality. Those funds could now be used for the development of Verus and to produce millions of tonnes of CO2 per year — an activity difficult to regard as sustainable.

Eni rejects Ieefa's charges, maintaining that it is false to say the January bond issuance was linked to the financing of specific gas projects and that Eni's climate ambitions will be upheld, thanks to CO2 capture and storage technologies.

📢 Con @Greenpeace_ITA portiamo #ENI davanti al Tribunale di Roma perché vogliamo:
- che siano riconosciute le responsabilità di ENI per la crisi climatica
- che sia obbligata a modificare i suoi piani di investimento e decarbonizzazione in linea con gli Accordi di Parigi.
È

The role in Pakistan's energy crisis

This does not change the fact that Eni has planned to increase oil and gas extraction by 3-4 per cent per year until 2026. Again according to Oil Change International, in 2023 Eni could rank third among companies globally by volume of new oil and gas reserves approved for development, behind only QatarEnergy and Petrobras.

Furthermore, Eni must also answer accusations — again levelled by ReCommon, against which Eni has said it "reserves the right to evaluate appropriate legal action to protect its reputation with regard to the repeated defamatory actions carried out, starting from the role the association sought to carve out for itself in the Opl245 judicial case, which ended with the total groundlessness of the charges and reputational damage to the company and its people" — of being responsible for the energy crisis in Pakistan.

On this point, ReCommon has published an in-depth report to shed light on the role of the energy giant after it won the contract to supply liquefied natural gas to the Asian country. The Italian multinational is accused of having diverted elsewhere the gas destined for Pakistan (at least eight of the 20 agreed deliveries, that is, one third) in order to resell the fuel on other markets (in particular to Turkey), thereby obtaining maximum profit from each cargo and exploiting the rise in prices during last winter's energy crisis. A manoeuvre that would have earned Eni at least half a billion dollars but would have created a serious energy supply problem for Pakistan.

The government of Islamabad announced a dispute against Eni, but to date this has not yet materialised. The agreements, which provide for very low penalties in the event of supply interruptions and no additional sanctions whatsoever in the event of wilful or repeated non-compliance, bind Pakistan and Eni to a liquefied gas supply for a further 9 years. Meanwhile, continuous blackouts in Pakistan have forced numerous companies to close, leaving thousands of people without work. To contain the energy crisis, the country's energy minister announced the intention to quadruple coal use: a desperate move to reduce the price of electricity, which will have serious consequences for people's health and for the climate.