Armenia's irreparable wounds. What the 44-day war meant for civilians

Armenia's irreparable wounds. What the 44-day war meant for civilians

Rights · ·

The war in Nagorno-Karabakh had “unspeakably painful” consequences for the Armenian people, and wiped out an entire generation of young men.

A Caucasian Vietnam. That is what the 44-day war was for Armenia. A military, political and humanitarian tragedy. After 44 days of bombardments that began on 27 September, claiming three thousand lives and displacing one hundred thousand people, the conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh, a territory disputed between Armenia and Azerbaijan in the southern Caucasus, came to an end on 9 November.

The news that the war was over — and lost — plunged the young Caucasian democracy into a nightmare from which there was no waking. The very night Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan declared the "unspeakably painful" terms he had accepted, clashes and unrest broke out on the streets of the capital Yerevan, and hundreds of protesters stormed parliament and the prime minister's residence.

The agreement — signed by Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia — provided for Armenian withdrawal from the seven disputed districts of Karabakh, the transfer of the historic city of Shushi to Azerbaijani control — the "Jerusalem of the Caucasus" and a historic symbol of national identity for Azerbaijanis — and the construction, in Azerbaijan's favour, of a connecting road through Armenian territory to the Nakhchivan enclave and Turkey.

Nagorno Karabakh
A father and his eldest son contemplate a photograph of the younger son and brother, killed during the fighting in the Nagorno-Karabakh war © Daniele Bellocchio

Even now, four months after the signing of the capitulation and the cessation of hostilities, political tension persists in Armenia. The population is divided between those who support the prime minister and his decision not to resign — seeking thereby to preserve the fragile democratic structures his government managed to put in place over two years — and those who accuse him of having betrayed the nation, of having lied about how the conflict was progressing, and of therefore being the principal person responsible for the defeat and the death of an entire generation of young Armenian men.

The tension reached its peak in recent weeks. After the army's general staff called for Prime Minister Pashinyan's resignation on 25 February, military aircraft flew over Yerevan, and soldiers and police, together with tens of thousands of protesters, took to the streets. While the government accused the army of plotting a coup, supporters of the government and of the opposition clashed and faced off in the streets. The fear was, and remains, that the situation could spiral out of control, plunging the country into a vortex of internal violence. The worst possible epilogue after the horrors of the October war.

The conflict's irreparable wounds

The irreparable wounds of the conflict can be seen today at Yerablur, Yerevan's military cemetery, where funerals for young men killed during the fighting have continued for more than ninety days. Everywhere there are headstones bearing engraved photographs of young men born 18, 19, 20 years ago, and mothers, fathers and siblings light incense and lay flowers at the monuments. A silence heavy with grief and resignation sweeps over the burial ground. Gone is the belligerent rhetoric and irredentist fervour that set the Armenian capital ablaze during the days of the conflict; all that remains are parents shattered by grief.

Among them are Karen and Lilith, the father and mother of Aren, who died aged 18 after forty days of combat. "My son was 18 years old. He loved life, as everyone does at that age. He went to school, he liked football and he played the guitar. But then war broke out on 27 September and they sent him to fight before he had even finished his military training. I do not accept the rhetoric of politicians who call my son a hero. I don't want him to be called a hero — I would have preferred he wasn't one, but that he was still alive." These are the words with which Karen, the boy's father, recalls his son and the days of October, speaking from the Yerevan home he lives in after leaving Nagorno-Karabakh. Both father and mother are undone by a grief that is hard to put into words, yet there is no hatred in what the parents say, nor any revanchism or desire for revenge. What there is instead is a profound longing for compassion and silence.

The one certainty is that war is a terrible thing.

Karen, Aren's father

Angela and Nikolay know this too. They have had no news of their son, Sasun, since October, when he went missing on the front line. Every morning the elderly couple wrap themselves in heavy coats, leave the hotel where they are living as displaced persons, and make their way to the presidential palace in Stepanakert to ask for news of their boy. A ritual of grief, carried out with composure and the perseverance of two parents who refuse to give in to resignation.

Angela and Nikolay walk slowly — the man leans on a crutch, his wife helps him along the icy pavements of the Karabakh capital after they have been received at the government building: "Every day I go and ask the president whether there is any news of my son, but no one can tell me anything. The last time we heard from him was October. We know he is probably dead, but at least we would like a grave where we could lay a flower."

Every conflict, alongside its dead, also has its wounded. At the military hospital in Yerevan, more than two hundred young men are admitted, and will spend the rest of their lives bearing the dramatic legacy of the fighting on their bodies. They are conscript soldiers who have suffered mutilations and permanent injuries. Some have lost limbs; others, due to shrapnel wounds and other injuries, can no longer walk, nor even perform the most basic actions such as gripping a utensil or getting up from a chair. We met Dr Lucine Poghosyan, the centre's director, after visiting the patients, seated in the hospital library.

They are all very young men who have only recently begun their adult lives. We must try to give them a familiar environment in which to rediscover an attachment to life.

Lucine Poghosyan

The tragedy has infected every aspect of life in Armenia. A cry of anguish over what happened in the Caucasian region has also risen from the world of culture. Hasmik Papian, one of the most important sopranos in the world, whom we met inside the Yerevan Opera House, her voice still hoarse and her eyes swollen from weeping, described the days of the war to us. "I returned to Armenia a few days before the conflict began. I was here when it all started. What happened in Nagorno-Karabakh, in Artsakh, as we Armenians call that region, was something that had never been seen before."

We lost a land, we lost a generation, but beyond the pain for human lives — which is obvious — what is most grave is that we lost hope.

Hasmik Papian, soprano

Armenia is a wounded land

Nagorno-Karabakh is now a land of disenchantment, wounded and militarised. The borders and main entry routes are controlled by Russian peacekeeping troops; the flags of Artsakh have been lowered, replaced by those of Moscow and Baku, with the crescent moon flying imperiously from the ramparts of the old city of Shushi. Stepanakert, the capital of Karabakh, appears imprisoned and melancholy.

The markets have reopened, many buildings have already been rebuilt thanks to Russian investment, children have returned to school, the fighting is now a painful memory in Artsakh — but not its legacy: "War, once you have lived through it, will never leave you. War is with you, that pain is inside you and it will never go away." The words are those of Susanna Movsesyan, a young woman of 29, as she looks out today over her city from above.

We had met during the days of the bombardment of Nagorno-Karabakh's capital. In October, as the conflict raged, Susanna had gone back to live in the shelter where her mother had taken her in 1991, when the war began and she was just three months old. A freezing basement where only a small electric heater provided a little warmth, and where time seemed to have crystallised into an eternal present of fear and waiting.

The sirens never stopped announcing an imminent attack from the sky, the roar of explosions made the window frames and door hinges of the shelter tremble, and Susanna, as she read a letter sent to her by her little niece who had taken refuge in Armenia, recounted: "The war has destroyed all my dreams. I believed that after the war of the 1990s, Stepanakert and Karabakh would blossom again and violence would never return here. Instead, this land, my land, has been swept up once more in a terrible conflict."

Now, the echo of explosions and the sound of sirens are a painful memory in Artsakh, and Susanna, who at just thirty years old has lived through three conflicts, looks at her city and adds: "I hate hate speech, I have nothing against the people of Azerbaijan, and my mother, who studied in Baku, has always spoken very highly of Azerbaijanis. Hatred serves no purpose — even in wartime, it is nothing but poison, for anyone in the world. I just want to be able to live in peace in my homeland."