Nagorno-Karabakh: a ceasefire signed
Rights — di Daniele Bellocchio
The war in Nagorno-Karabakh comes to a halt after weeks of bombardment. But what has been reached between Armenia and Azerbaijan cannot be called a peace agreement.

The war in Nagorno-Karabakh comes to a halt after weeks of bombardment. But what has been reached between Armenia and Azerbaijan cannot be called a peace agreement.
After 43 days, the war in Nagorno-Karabakh is over. While the announcement of the end of hostilities was greeted with celebrations and processions in Baku, Azerbaijan, the streets of Yerevan, the Armenian capital, erupted in anger as the population stormed parliament and the residence of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan — the man who announced to the nation the capitulation of Armenia and the Nagorno-Karabakh forces via a post on Facebook. Azerbaijan regains control of the greater part of the disputed territory after thirty years.

What Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia signed is not a peace agreement. It is instead a ceasefire and an admission of defeat on Armenia's part. Prime Minister Pashinyan described the content of the agreement to end hostilities with these words: "Unspeakably painful for me and for our people." He explained that the decision was taken following the fall of Shushi and the inexorable advance of Baku's forces towards Stepanakert.
The terms of the agreement are stark, uncompromising, and feature several winners and one single great loser: Armenia. Reading what has been agreed, it emerges that the Armenians will have to withdraw from the seven disputed districts of Karabakh, and that the historic city of Shushi will also remain under Azerbaijani control. Azerbaijani displaced persons will return to the territories of Nagorno-Karabakh under the supervision of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (Unhcr), and two thousand Russian soldiers will be deployed in the Lachin corridor — the road connecting Armenia with Karabakh — for a five-year mandate, renewable for a further five years. But that is not all: Azerbaijan requested and obtained that a connecting road also be built, through Armenian territory, to the Nakhchivan enclave and to Turkey.
After more than 40 days during which bombardments by drones, artillery and air power followed one another incessantly and the death toll, according to some estimates, stands at more than five thousand, the bloodiest conflict in the Caucasus in the past thirty years has thus concluded not with a peace agreement but with yet another ceasefire. Turkey and Azerbaijan are exulting over the military victory, while Russia has succeeded in its aim of cornering the pro-European government that Moscow holds in disfavour. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan came to power through the "velvet revolution" of 2018 and deployed troops at one of the most strategic and important points in the region. Armenia's young democracy is trembling on its own foundations and is bracing itself to face an uncertain and extremely painful future.

The first tragedy to befall Armenia is the plight of the more than 140,000 displaced people who fled Karabakh. The entire civilian population of Nagorno-Karabakh has in fact abandoned their homes and found shelter in Yerevan and in Armenia's other main cities, but at present none of these people know whether or when they will have any chance of returning to their dwellings. In addition, the country is in the grip of a serious political crisis. A large part of the population and several sections of the military are accusing Pashinyan's government of betrayal; the news of the agreement was met with riots and unrest in the streets, and now the entire world is trying to understand what tomorrow holds for Armenia — a country that appears politically divided, physically wounded, and set ablaze by hatreds and sorrows that risk finding their outlet in violence.