Where the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict comes from and why it is still being talked about

Where the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict comes from and why it is still being talked about

Rights · ·

The clashes in Nagorno-Karabakh over the past few days are the tip of the iceberg of a history of tension that has its roots in the nineteenth century.

Nagorno-Karabakh, the territory disputed between Azerbaijan and Armenia, is once again making headlines. This has happened over the past few days, after a number of clashes between the forces of Baku and Armenian troops resulted in around thirty deaths. What may appear to be a sudden escalation of violence is in reality the latest chapter of a war that has been going on for more than thirty years, with roots that stretch back even further. In Nagorno-Karabakh, no one can remember what peace looks like, paralysed as the region is in a perpetual state of tension that sometimes explodes and at other times simmers silently, waiting for a new spark.

In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
Life In The Nagorno-Karabakh State Conflict
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
Life In The Nagorno-Karabakh State Conflict
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
In Nagorno Karabakh la tranquillità è stata interrotta da nuovi scontri
Da dove viene il conflitto del Nagorno Karabakh e perché se ne parla ancora

It all begins in the 1980s — or even earlier

Even the name Nagorno-Karabakh contains contrasting influences. Nagorno means mountain and comes from Russian — the same Russia that today backs the Armenian cause in the region. Karabakh, on the other hand, is a word of Turkish origin meaning black garden, with Turkey today supporting Azerbaijan's actions and describing Armenia as the cause of instability in the Caucasus.

La mappa del Nagorno Karabakh
The map of Nagorno-Karabakh © Achemish/Wikimedia

In the nineteenth century, the region was under the rule of the Russian tsars. It was during this period that many Armenians left Anatolia to settle in the areas closest to what is now Azerbaijan, encouraged by the Russians who wanted to undermine Ottoman dominance in the area. It was thus that, as far back as two centuries ago, Azerbaijanis and Armenians found themselves in a kind of forced coexistence, which in practice did not give rise to major problems.

With the Bolshevik revolution, the Russians lost their influence over the territory and Nagorno-Karabakh became part of the Transcaucasian Democratic Federative Republic in 1918. During this period the first inter-ethnic clashes broke out, with the Armenian Christian-majority territory being claimed by both Armenia and Muslim Azerbaijan. Two years later, the newly formed Soviet Union retook control of the area, annexing it. Nagorno-Karabakh remained part of Azerbaijan's territory, with Joseph Stalin accustomed to including ethnic minorities within Soviet republics in order to prevent the formation of overly strong national identities. Armenia did not accept this arrangement willingly, and throughout the twentieth century discontent remained high, even if largely out of sight. It was at the end of the 1980s that tensions truly began to rise. Azerbaijani control over the region was no longer tolerated by the Armenians, who began to organise themselves to change the state of affairs. It was the prelude to a very difficult period for the region.

The bloody end of the twentieth century

In 1988, the Nagorno-Karabakh soviet petitioned the Soviet Union for recognition of Armenian control over the territory. The supreme soviet opposed this, and the move triggered widespread demonstrations by the Armenian majority in Azerbaijani territory, which in many cases descended into violence. It was during this period that the first genuine local secessionist movement was born: the Karabakh Committee.

With the fall of the Berlin Wall and the end of the Soviet Union (USSR), Nagorno-Karabakh came back under the control of Azerbaijan, which had in the meantime declared its independence from Moscow. In 1991 the Karabakh National Council declared the establishment of the Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh (NKR), following a referendum that was never recognised by the international community. It was at this point that violence finally erupted in full. The war went on for several years, with massacres carried out by both sides – among the most significant are those of Khojaly and Sumgait. The statistics speak of a total of 30,000 deaths, but the tragedy was also one of forced migration. There were over one million refugees: Muslim Azerbaijanis fleeing the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh and the other provinces seized by Armenian forces; Christian Armenians fleeing Azerbaijani-controlled territory, as victims of persecution and reprisals. By the end of the violence, the Armenian population had come to represent 95 per cent of Nagorno-Karabakh.

The illusory peace of 1994

On 12 May 1994 the two states put their weapons away. The Bishkek Agreement was the fruit of Russian mediation and, on the one hand, imposed an indefinite ceasefire and, on the other, made certain concessions to the Armenian cause at a territorial and political level. It was a temporary solution, which required further negotiations and settlements, entrusted to the Minsk Group, established in 1992 and comprising 11 states in addition to the two belligerents.

The role of the Minsk Group, of which Italy is also a member, has in recent years been to mediate between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the never-settled dispute concerning Nagorno-Karabakh. Both states, however, look unfavourably upon that international forum: the Azerbaijanis consider it too heavily weighted in favour of the Armenian cause, while Armenia contests the fact that no member of the government of the self-proclaimed Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh has ever been admitted to it. It is partly for this reason that, nearly thirty years after its establishment, the Minsk Group has never managed to bring the two belligerent states to a definitive peace agreement.

Why the clashes are continuing today

Shooting breaks out in Nagorno-Karabakh from time to time. The early 2000s saw the conclusion of several cooperation treaties between Armenia and Azerbaijan, with small portions of territory transferred to the control of one side or the other. But violations of the ceasefire have nonetheless been frequent, bearing witness to the fragility of the Bishkek Agreement.

In 2012 some clashes on the border resulted in casualties within both armies. In 2016 three days of fierce fighting ended with around a hundred deaths among Azerbaijani and Armenian soldiers, while in the years that followed there were numerous acts of force in Nagorno-Karabakh. The clashes of recent days are therefore nothing new, but rather the grim routine of a territory where tension seems to have been rising again for some time.

The initiative for the clashes appears to come from Azerbaijan, and this is no coincidence. As journalist Gwynne Dyer pointed out in the weekly Internazionale, Nagorno-Karabakh is indeed Azerbaijani territory, but it has been entirely under Armenian control for decades, meaning Armenia has little interest in launching itself into a war against a stronger and wealthier state (thanks above all to oil). Moreover, discontent towards the president-dictator Ilham Aliyev is growing in Baku. A war in Nagorno-Karabakh, aimed at reasserting control over it, could stoke the nationalism of his citizens and cast his presidency in a new light.