10 secular opinions puzzled by or opposed to gay marriage and adoption

10 secular opinions puzzled by or opposed to gay marriage and adoption

Rights · ·

One of the most useful tools for forming an opinion on gay marriage is comparing the positions developed by scholars, commentators, prominent figures and intellectually influential voices.

Given that, of late, the discussion has taken on the tones of a crusade and ideological partisanship, descending into muddled insults and entrenching itself in an irreconcilable clash, we have attempted to gather testimonies expressed somewhat earlier in time, when today's factionalism had not yet bloodshot anyone's eyes and clouded their vision.

Here, preference has been given to secular testimonies and those of intellectuals not currently enlisted in one camp or the other. Not because they lack substance or are unworthy of note, but because the arguments of Massimo Gandolfini, Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco, Paolo Hutter and Paola Concia are already abundantly well known, reported and replicated across every media outlet.

But let's also read: 10 secular opinions in favour of gay marriage and adoption

Carlo Nordio, 2016

"First. For thousands of years, across all latitudes and all civilisations, the educational office has been entrusted (wherever possible) to a father and a mother. Second. Our Constitution, in Article 29, defines the family as a natural society founded on marriage, and in Article 30 regulates paternity and its determination (incidentally: do you really believe that Togliatti and Terracini, not to mention De Gasperi and Saragat, could have remotely contemplated adoption by gay people?). Third. In the secular-Enlightenment cultural tradition, every form of education other than that provided by the traditional family has always been viewed with suspicion and sarcasm, even when it came from philosophers such as Plato, Campanella and Rousseau. Very well. If these three propositions are true — and I believe it would be difficult to contest them — is it worth igniting a kind of war of religion over a subject that ought to be treated with ethical and, above all, logical rigour? Not only out of due regard for the expectations of would-be parents, but also out of reverent care for the interests of those who, whether unborn or already children, cannot today make their voice heard."

(From: "Adozioni gay e famiglia, perché servono rigore etico e logico", Il Mattino, 19 January 2016)

Sergio Romano, 2014

"Words are not empty boxes. They contain the meaning they have acquired over time and pass it on to future generations. Marriage, in particular, is the word with which a large part of humanity describes the union between a man and a woman, blessed by God or certified by the State. Using it for different unions is a theft of tradition that does not even serve the interests of homosexuals. They are asking for a new right, and they should want a new word to be adopted for the exercise of that right. Is this a legitimate desire? The modern State does not issue diplomas of sexual morality; it must not decide whether homosexuality is an abominable vice or, more simply, a variant of human sexuality. If the phenomenon is socially significant, the State must acknowledge it and regulate its consequences, among which, in particular, those of a patrimonial nature. But it will only be able to do so if it has first decided when and how a sexual relationship becomes a union. What is needed, in other words, is a rule."

(From: Lettere al Corriere, Corriere della Sera, 19 October 2014)

Silvia Vegetti Finzi, 2013

"The Oedipus complex, which Freud defines as the 'cornerstone of the unconscious', is the triangle connecting father, mother and child. Within its coordinates unfold the unconscious erotic and aggressive relations, animated by the omnipotence of the Pleasure Principle — 'I want everything at once' — that engage its three vertices. For every newborn, the first object of love is the mother, but this is a possession barred by the incest prohibition, the unwritten law of every society. This impossibility is structuring in that it confronts everyone with their own insufficiency (one desires only what one does not have) and with the correlate impossibility of filling the original lack.

The child who wants the mother all to himself automatically triggers a rivalry towards the father, whom he also loves and by whom he wishes to be loved. The contest, which unfolds in the imaginary, comes to an end for two reasons: out of fear of castration — the threat of losing the symbol of the self — and through the objective recognition of the father's insurmountable superiority. Unable to compete with the father, the child identifies with him and chooses as his love object not the mother herself, but the woman who will one day take her place.

Through this play of roles, the child renounces infantile omnipotence, takes the place that belongs to him in the geometry of the family, assumes a masculine identity and orients himself towards loving, in due course, a female partner. I shall leave aside here the path of girls, far too complex to reduce to mere symmetry. But even the masculine path is sufficient to show how sexual identity asserts itself not in the abstract, but through a 'situating' of roles and functions that engages both the psyche and the body of its actors.

If, as Merleau-Ponty maintains, 'we do not have a body but are our body', it is not irrelevant that it be male or female, and that the child of a homosexual couple cannot, in defining him- or herself, confront the problem of sexual difference. Psychoanalysis is not a moral system and issues neither commandments nor anathemas, but, inasmuch as it adopts a logic that is not individual but relational, it seems to me particularly suited to give voice to those who, not yet having been born, will only be able to enjoy the rights we choose to grant them."

(From: Ai bambini servono entrambe le figure, Corriere della Sera-27esima ora, 2 January 2013)

Ernesto Galli della Loggia, 2012

"Bernheim (Gilles Bernheim, Chief Rabbi of France, author of the essay 'Matrimonio omosessuale, omoparentalità e adozione' — Ed.) begins with the decisive point, namely by contesting that the true stake of these issues is a problem of equality of rights. What is at stake, he writes, is instead 'the irreversible risk of a confusion of genealogies, statutes and identities, to the detriment of the general interest and to the advantage of an infinitesimal minority'.

In a manner that strikes me as defensible even from the standpoint of a non-believer, he dismantles one by one the arguments habitually used in favour of homosexual marriage: from the need for legal protection of the potential spouse, to the importance of loving one another ('one cannot recognise the right to marry for all those who love each other simply because they love each other': for instance, a woman who loves two men); to the affective reasons that would justify the adoption of a child by a homosexual couple.

'All the affection in the world is not enough to produce the basic psychic structures that respond to the child's need to know where he comes from. The child constructs himself only by differentiating himself, and this presupposes above all that he knows whom he resembles. He needs to know that he is the fruit of the love and union of a man, his father, and a woman, his mother, by virtue of the sexual difference of his parents.' Further: 'the father and the mother indicate to the child his genealogy. The child needs a clear and coherent genealogy in order to position himself as an individual. Always, and forever, what constitutes the human is a word in a sexed body and in a genealogy.' Bernheim not only tackles head-on the aim, dear to many homosexual activists, of replacing the sexed concept of 'parents' with the sexless and vacuous one of 'parenthood' and 'homo-parenthood', but maintains that one cannot in any way speak of a right to have a child: 'the suffering of an infertile couple is not a sufficient reason to obtain the right to adoption. The child,' he emphasises, 'is not an object but a subject of rights. To speak of a right to a child implies an unacceptable instrumentalisation.'"

(From: Quando le religioni sfidano il conformismo sui gay, Corriere della Sera, 30 December 2012)

Giuseppe Di Mauro, 2012

"Based on the available scientific literature, children appear better suited to a successful adult life when they spend their entire childhood with their married biological fathers and mothers, and especially when the parental union remains stable over a long period of time. The debate is highly complex and scientifically still open, and therefore greater caution and more awareness of the messages being conveyed to the many viewers would be desirable on the part of the media. Many studies on the subject exist, but their quality is often poor, particularly with regard to sampling method: a scientifically valid study must be conducted on a random sample and on a significant number of subjects. Instead, most research on this topic has been carried out on non-random, small-scale samples and is therefore not representative. The only study currently recognised as valid is that of University of Texas sociologist Mark Regnerus. Indeed, the paper, published in 2012, boasts a methodological framework that is unprecedented both quantitatively and qualitatively: not only is it based on the largest nationally representative random sample (12,000), but it is also the first to let the "children" (now grown) of homosexual parents speak directly, demonstrating that 12% think about suicide (compared with 5% of children of heterosexual couples), that they are more prone to infidelity (40% versus 13%), more often unemployed (28% versus 8%), more likely to resort to psychotherapy (19% versus 8%), and more frequently supported by social services compared with peers raised by married heterosexual couples. In 40% of cases they had contracted a sexually transmissible disease (versus 8%), and they are generally less healthy, poorer, more inclined to smoking and to criminal behaviour."

(*President of Sipps- Società italiana di pediatria preventiva e sociale, from: Famiglia: come cresceranno i figli delle coppie gay? Linkiesta, 2 June 2012)

Luisa Muraro, 2012

"'Better to have homosexual parents than none at all,' said the Mayor of Milan, according to the newspapers. Did he really say that? I ask myself this because those words contain two oversimplifications. Having parents is not always better than not having them. There are parents who are unworthy of their role. As for adoption, Pisapia knows very well that our law has become very cautious in granting it. Too cautious, some say, without knowing about the many children first adopted and then rejected. A rigorous assessment is needed — for instance: are professional politicians and artists suited to fatherhood? Second oversimplification. The mayor spoke of homosexual couples without specifying whether male or female. But that is an enormous difference. Female couples who want children can have them and already do so, with the tacit consent of the surrounding society. The problem arises for male couples, as they are naturally and obviously sterile. Here I am not taking a position for or against adoption. I am simply stating that, when faced with a problem, it is worth being clear about how things actually stand. Adoption is a problem for men, not for women. And behind the pressing male demand to be able to adopt, there may lie an ancient envy of female fertility. Am I wrong? I cannot rule it out, but in that case the man should openly say: why don't I want to ask a woman for the gift of becoming a father? Why do I want to be the mother myself? And let us not reduce the problem to a matter of rights. In this world, desires — including legitimate ones — do not automatically translate into rights."

(From: Metro, 3 October 2012)

Francesco D'Agostino, 2012

"First point: heterosexual marriage is not an invention of the Church; it is a legal institution, aimed at guaranteeing the order of generations, to be found in all (I repeat: all) cultures and at all (I repeat: all) times. Corollary: in defending heterosexual marriage, the Church defends not a dogma of faith or a principle of its own doctrine, but a dimension of objective human good. Second point: one can certainly procreate, as Battista reminds us, outside of marriage (even Catholics know this!), but the function of marriage is precisely to impose a rigorous social order on procreation, as a guarantee for new generations… Third point: the rights that according to Battista should be granted to gay couples are far less striking than they may appear when described as "civil rights": not only are they easily activated through what legal science calls "voluntary law" (pension reversibility, succession to rental contracts, hospital assistance, inheritance rights), but they are already largely available as a result of extensive interpretations of existing laws made by the Cassazione. Corollary: the real stake, when debating gay marriage, is symbolic — it is neither legal nor social; its proponents would like the law to recognise affective situations whose 'private' authenticity no one wishes to deny, but which do not in and of themselves carry any 'public' relevance."

(*Honorary President of the Comitato Nazionale per la Bioetica – from: Matrimonio e omosessuali: i 'laici' argomenti dei cattolici, L'Avvenire, 15 May 2012)

Rupert Everett, 2012

"My mother would always have liked to see me married to a woman, perhaps with children, because I would have been a wonderful father. She thinks children need a father and a mother and I agree with her. I can't think of anything worse than being raised by two gay dads. Some people might disagree. Fine! It's just my opinion. I'm not speaking on behalf of the gay community. In fact, I don't feel part of any 'community'. The only community I belong to is humanity, and we already have far too many children on the planet, so it's good not to have any more."

(From: "I'd still like my son to marry a pretty girl and have kids", interview in the Sunday Times, 16 September 2012)

Beppe Severgnini, 2011 and 2012

"I stated upfront that same-sex couples must be protected and recognised by law. But what can I do? I am not in favour of adoption and, before that, of marriage, which is by definition the union of a man and a woman. Don't accept my argument? Try to follow me. Why, then, can marriage not be between three people? Or four? Or three men, two women and an avatar? If your answer were 'No, there have to be two!' that means even you have a definition of marriage, based on a category: number. For me there is another one: difference of sex. It is not only the Catholic religion that asks this; common sense, history and nature suggest it too (nature aims, relentlessly, at procreation and the preservation of the species). I would add: adoption by homosexual couples leaves me puzzled; very puzzled when it has public and worldly dimensions, as in the case of Elton John. A child needs a mum and a dad, different and complementary figures. It may happen that a child must grow up with only one or only the other. But disadvantaging them from the outset seems unjust to me. Only in the case of adolescents for whom adoption proves difficult am I prepared to reconsider my position. Does this make me a political troglodyte? I don't think so. Perhaps, in part, a conservative. I do indeed believe there is something worth conserving in tradition and in the social fabric of human beings. Much else, on the other hand, can and must change. And in Italy we don't do it, damn it."

(From: Italians, Corriere della Sera, 3 February 2011)

"Marriage still seems to me, by definition, the union of persons of different sexes. I have explained why, on a couple of occasions, adding: for people of the same sex there are other forms of union to be welcomed and legally protected. And I was showered with abuse. I confess, it upset me. I cannot understand why those who have long suffered intolerance should respond with intolerance when faced with an unwelcome opinion."

(From: Italians, Corriere della Sera, 11 September 2012)

Corrado Augias, 2003

"The discomfort I feel when confronted with public displays of homosexual affection is something I too believe stems in part from 'cultural' factors and from a lack of familiarity. I have a vivid memory of the sense of freedom I experienced as a student when I began travelling around Europe (Paris and London above all). Contributing to that feeling were couples of lovers lying entwined on the grass in Hyde Park or in the Parisian Buttes-Chaumont. Those were years in which, back home, official morality required police officers to go and fine courting couples sitting alone in their cars, even at night, even in isolated spots, even with steamed-up windows. We were provincial, public displays of affection were (officially) considered unseemly. Many people were obviously opposed to this; the attitude was criticised, and Scelba (the Interior Minister) was called a voyeur by proxy. Over time, at least for heterosexual couples, everything changed. And yet I continue to think that for same-sex couples there are difficulties beyond the cultural ones. Perhaps an explanation lies in the fact that a man and a woman making love in a meadow embody, even without knowing it, the brazen force of a species demanding to be perpetuated. In a same-sex couple, I believe what causes unease is the idea of sterility, which turns kisses and caresses into a display that is an end in itself."

(From Letters to Corrado Augias, La Repubblica, 1 November 2003)