Victory for Brazil's indigenous peoples, the Supreme Court rejects the marco temporal

Victory for Brazil's indigenous peoples, the Supreme Court rejects the marco temporal

Environment · ·

Nine judges ruled against the marco temporal, the law that would have stripped indigenous peoples of their right to live on their lands.

It is a day of celebration for Brazil's indigenous peoples: the Brazilian Supreme Court has rejected the marco temporal thesis, affirming the integrity of indigenous rights and the protection of their territories. The bill had been strongly promoted by agribusiness companies seeking to seize large areas of indigenous land for the extraction of raw materials.

Nine judges ruled against the marco temporal and only two supported it. The final text of the ruling will now have to be awaited in order to understand and assess what arguments and implications may emerge from this vote.

The points of the ruling against the marco temporal

The application of the ruling will, in fact, have repercussions on all (or some) of the disputes that have arisen over recent years between Amazonian peoples and institutions. This means that the Court, upon publication of the ruling, will not only resolve the specific case that gave rise to it — namely the territorial dispute between the Xokleng indigenous people and the Santa Catarina environmental institute (Ima) — but will also define how the interpretation of the Constitution is to be applied going forward in all other cases.

For example, on the question of compensation: the Constitution provides for the payment of an indemnity for improvements made to an area when these are carried out by those occupying territory that is, in fact, indigenous. The judges must therefore discuss the possibility of recognising compensation for the value that such peoples have contributed to the land — value that has until now gone unrecognised and has indeed been obstructed.

bolsonaro genocidio
Thousands of indigenous people demonstrated against the violence of the Bolsonaro government © Buda Mendes/Getty Images

What is the marco temporal

According to the marco temporal, literally "time limit", indigenous peoples unable to prove that they were physically inhabiting their lands on 5 October 1988 (the day the Brazilian Constitution was promulgated) would have lost the right to have those lands demarcated (that is, officially mapped and protected).

Had the Court approved the proposal, the recognition of indigenous rights would have been set back by decades: hundreds of thousands of indigenous people could have been dispossessed of their lands, and uncontacted peoples would have faced the risk of extermination.

The first vote on the marco temporal by the Court's judges dates back to September 2021. At the time, one judge voted against and another in favour of the thesis. The other judges began to cast their votes first in June of this year, when another vote against arrived, and then, before the final ruling, further votes came at the end of August: one in favour and two against.

🎉Dopo anni di lotta, una vittoria storica per il mov indigeno brasiliano! La tesi del Marco Temporal, genocida&catastrofica, è stata oggi rigettata da @STF_oficial: una grande vittoria per i #popoliindigeni del #Brasile e i loro alleati in tutto il🌐
Info survival.it/notizie/13735/

Had it been approved, the law would have devastated dozens of peoples

"It is a historic victory, crucial for Brazil's indigenous peoples and a great defeat for the agribusiness lobby," declared Fiona Watson, director of the advocacy department at Survival, an NGO long committed to the defence of native peoples. "The marco temporal was a scheme designed to legalise the theft of millions of hectares of indigenous land. Had it been approved, dozens of peoples would have been devastated by it, including thousands of Guarani and the uncontacted Kawahiva."

"The marco temporal proposal was part of a full-scale assault on Brazil's indigenous peoples and the Amazon rainforest, strongly promoted by former president Bolsonaro and his allies. This is why it is so important that it has been rejected, not only for indigenous peoples but also for the global fight against climate change."

The indigenous movement and its allies, including Survival International, have fought for years for the marco temporal thesis to be abandoned. While awaiting the verdict, massive protests against the proposal took place in Brazil and around the world.

Emocionante!
Há anos o movimento indígena vem lutando para enterrar a aberração jurídica representada pela tese do Marco Temporal. Hoje o STF deu mais um importante passo para garantia dos direitos originários dos povos.
Via @tukuma_pataxo/ @ApibOficial

But the marco temporal is being discussed in Parliament

Is it all over, then? Not quite, given that the marco temporal proposal has also been advanced in recent years by a number of Brazilian parliamentarians. The thesis has in fact been included in the bill known as PL490, approved by the Chamber, before moving to the Senate for discussion (and changing name: it is now called PL2903).

In theory, the parliamentary process would be as follows: if a majority of senators voted in favour of the law, it would then pass to President Lula, who may approve it or exercise a total or partial veto. If he were to veto it, the bill would have to return to Congress, at which point a new phase would open in which deputies and senators would have to approve or reject the veto, reaching a final decision on the validity of the law.

This is the theoretical process. Even if the marco temporal were removed from the draft law, the latter would still represent a deeply flawed law steeped in anti-indigenous policies, since it would allow timber traffickers, agricultural entrepreneurs and other actors who have illegally invaded indigenous territories to remain there. In short, the struggle for indigenous rights is not yet over.