The judges opposed to the marco temporal — the demarcation process aimed at stripping indigenous peoples in Brazil of their lands — now number 4. Those in favour: 2. On 20 September, voting resumes.
Three more Brazilian judges have cast their votes in the case centring on the right of the Xokleng indigenous people to live on their own lands.
The votes against the demarcation process now stand at 4, with 2 in favour.
The process will continue on 20 September 2023.
If it were a match, those opposing the marco temporal — that is, those against the thesis that seeks to strip Brazil's indigenous peoples of the land they live on — would currently be winning four votes to two. Setting metaphors aside, the news can be summed up in a few lines: in Brazil, over the past few days, three more judges of the Brazilian Supreme Court cast their votes in the historic marco temporal case, putting the judges who side with indigenous peoples' rights "in the lead."
What the marco temporal is and who has voted so far
What does the marco temporal theory consist of, and what has happened so far? For indigenous peoples and the associations defending their rights, the marco temporal is an attempt to strip indigenous peoples of their lands, based on the premise that indigenous peoples who were not physically living on their ancestral lands on 5 October 1988 — the day the Constitution was promulgated — would have no right to live there, as if they had "occupied" state-owned or privately owned land. In practice, the specific case assesses the application of the marco temporal thesis to the territorial rights of the Xokleng, but were it to be approved, it would obviously be legitimised more broadly.
The first vote on the marco temporal dates back to September 2021. On that occasion, Judge Edson Fachin ruled against the law, while Kassio Nunes Marques, appointed by then Brazilian president Jair Bolsonaro, voted in favour. We have to wait until 7 June 2023 to see a new vote: this time it came from Alexandre de Moraes, who ruled against the marco temporal legal thesis.
Then came 31 August, when Judge André Mendonça, also appointed by the former far-right president, intervened in favour of the demarcation process. His vote was followed by that of Judge Cristiano Zanin — appointed instead by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva — who declared himself opposed and stated that indigenous peoples who were not on their lands at the time the Constitution was signed may have suffered forced relocations, violence and threats. On the same date, Judge Luís Roberto Barroso also voted against and rejected the idea of providing compensation to those who had unlawfully occupied indigenous lands.
📣AGGIORNAMENTO #Brasile: Nei giorni scorsi altri 3 giudici della Corte Suprema brasiliana hanno espresso il loro voto nello storico processo sul Marco Temporal portando in vantaggio i giudizi a favore dei diritti indigeni. 1/6 ⬇️
To recap, then, the votes stand at 4 to 2: four judges have voted against the demarcation process and in favour of indigenous rights, while two have voted in favour of the marco temporal, and therefore against native peoples.
Voting resumes on 20 September
Eleven judges are due to rule on the case, and six have voted so far. Five remain, who will vote in the following order: Rosa Weber, Luiz Fux, Dias Toffoli, Carmen Lúcia and Gilmar Mendes. The next vote will be on 20 September, but there is no precise timetable: the Court sits only on Wednesdays and Thursdays, and each judge can potentially request more time to decide. In that case, the session would be suspended. It is therefore still too early to say when the case on the demarcation of indigenous territories will reach its conclusion. A suspension, moreover, would not necessarily be bad news, given that Barroso, who opposes the marco temporal, will become the new President of the Supreme Court from October.
In the meantime, however, the bill PL490 (which has now become PL2903), which promotes the marco temporal thesis, continues its passage through Parliament. According to Survival, the NGO that defends indigenous peoples' rights worldwide, the approval of PL490 would pave the way for the reduction or cancellation of any indigenous territory in Brazil, which could then be replaced by mines, oil wells or other industrial projects. But if the Supreme Court were to reject the thesis in court in the meantime, the marco temporal thesis would also be defeated in Parliament and PL490 would not be legitimate.
The fate of thousands of indigenous people therefore continues to hang in the balance.
Brazil, three judges vote against the marco temporal to protect indigenous rights
Environment — di Maurizio Bongioanni
The judges opposed to the marco temporal — the demarcation process aimed at stripping indigenous peoples in Brazil of their lands — now number 4. Those in favour: 2. On 20 September, voting resumes.