Ecuadorians said no to oil. What will the government do?

Ecuadorians said no to oil. What will the government do?

Environment · ·

Through a referendum, Ecuador said no to oil extraction in the Amazon. But the Minister of Energy has stated that he does not intend to honour the result. With the October run-off approaching, what should we expect?

Half-deserted streets, a three-day ban on alcohol consumption, and the deployment of around 100,000 police officers called upon to guarantee citizens' safety following an escalation of violence that, on 9 August, culminated in the murder of presidential candidate Fernando Villavicencio. This was the climate in which on 20 August the Ecuadorian people went to the polls with an enormous responsibility: to elect a new president and vote on the future of Yasuní National Park, one of the most biodiverse places on earth.

¡Hoy hicimos historia!

Esta consulta, nacida desde la ciudadanía, demuestra el mayor consenso nacional en Ecuador. Es la primera vez que un país decide defender la vida y dejar el petróleo bajo tierra.

¡Es una victoria histórica para Ecuador y para el planeta!

#SÍalYasuní

It goes to a run-off: what to expect from the October vote

While the popular referendum on Yasuní recorded a clear victory for the environment – with 59 per cent of voters firmly opposed to seeing one of the most biodiverse places on earth collapse under the weight of drilling rigs – the same cannot be said of the presidential race, which will see two candidates face each other in the 15 October run-off: Luisa González, of the left-wing party Revolución Ciudadana, and Daniel Noboa, of the alliance Acción democrática nacional.

"The results presented by the National Electoral Council (Cne), which give González 33.1 per cent of the vote and Daniel Noboa 23.66 per cent, illustrate a partially expected scenario," comments Maria José Hernandez, of the Chamber of Industry and Production of Quito, a politics enthusiast and deep connoisseur of the country's socio-economic fabric.

"The so-called correismo – the political current linked to former president Rafael Correa, in office from 2006 to 2017 and currently sentenced in absentia to eight years in prison for corruption – has historically always maintained a share of around 33 per cent of the vote throughout its entire institutional trajectory. Now we need to see who will manage to win the people's trust and, given the situation the country finds itself in, it is clear that the hot-button issues on which the challengers will play for victory in October will be essential matters such as security, and Ecuador's productive and financial sector."

Gli ecuadoriani hanno detto di no al petrolio. Cosa farà il governo?
Moncayo's handprint, with the glove soaked in oil from the still-open pits in the Amazon, in Sucumbíos © Valeria Barbi

And indeed, at a time when local street gangs, together with Colombian and Mexican drug cartels, have unleashed a wave of violence unprecedented in the country's recent history, pushing the homicide rate to record levels – figures point to a rise of +500 per cent between 2016 and 2022 – the winner will in all likelihood be the candidate who manages to earn the trust of a people sadly accustomed to corruption and electoral fraud.

Carlos knows this well; he owns a graphic design studio in the city centre of the capital: "Every time I think about the right to vote – which here in Ecuador is a genuine obligation, with failure to comply punishable by a fairly hefty fine and the suspension of access to certain public services – I ask myself how I can still believe in it, after at the last elections they even managed to cut the power at polling stations during the count."

A scenario that sounds like science fiction but which, unfortunately, here as in many other parts of the world is a well-known reality. This year, for example, the electronic voting system used by Ecuadorians living abroad was targeted by several cyber attacks originating from China, India and Bangladesh, while the official website of the National Electoral Council appeared to be down throughout Sunday. Incidents that, fortunately, do not appear to have jeopardised the correct counting of votes.

The real protagonists of the contest are the environment and development

Also clearly on the agenda for the candidates, and for the future government, is the environmental question, which goes beyond the referendum on oil extraction in the Amazon and mining concessions in the Andean region of Chocó, and is inextricably bound up with the development model the country will follow in the years ahead.

"Certainly," Hernandez continues, "the outcome of the popular referendum is a sign of how important the protection and conservation of the environment is for the new generations (let us remember that the percentage of young voters in Ecuador is around 40 per cent). It also shows that Ecuadorians understand progress and development as something that goes beyond infrastructure and the accumulation of money. Now we can only hope that the decision will be respected by whichever president is elected in October, and that what happened during Rafael Correa's presidential term is not repeated, thus setting in motion the long-awaited transformation of the country's productive matrix."

In 2013, indeed, then-president Correa, disregarding the public's demands and completely ignoring a petition of no fewer than 700,000 signatures, had begun exploration and oil extraction in block 43, where there are currently still 230 wells in operation. An attitude that, according to Wilmer Lucitante, a member of the indigenous Cofán people, would be typical of the political thinking close to Correa, to which candidate Luisa González belongs. "Despite the undoubted effort to improve all social sectors, correismo completely ignored the possibility of consulting the people before embarking on strategic choices for the country. The right wing to which Noboa belongs, on the other hand, stands in continuity with the government of Guillermo Lasso – who dissolved parliament on 17 May and will remain in office until the run-off – centred on corporate interests that have brought the country to ruin."

Issues that are fundamental above all for indigenous peoples

With an estimated population of between 1,500 and 2,100 people spread across Colombia and Ecuador, where they live in the Sucumbíos region – in the north-east of the country – the Cofán have been fighting for years side by side with other indigenous peoples, to assert their right to a healthy environment and to ensure that what happened with Chevron-Texaco is never repeated – a company accused of having spilled more than 56,000 million units of toxic substances into the environment and of never having made safe the approximately 800 open oil pits still found across the northern Ecuadorian Amazon.

That is why, for Lucitante, whichever of the two governments comes to power poses a risk: "their policies are not in keeping with the cosmovision of the Kofan nation, nor with our approach towards the environment and indigenous cultures. We are the true defenders of nature, and for our communities there is no other path but to continue resisting and fighting against the intervention of governments in power and the neoliberal system."

A view shared by Abdón Yumbo, president of the Comunidad Milenio Cofán, a few kilometres from Lago Agrio, the setting of the Chevron-Texaco case now in its thirtieth year in court. "All governments keep thinking about the funds that can be derived from oil extraction, showing that they still have not understood how vitally important the environment is for indigenous peoples, for our survival and that of our traditions."

Gli ecuadoriani hanno detto di no al petrolio. Cosa farà il governo?
A "mechero": installations like this one burn natural gas at a temperature of around 400 degrees, as part of crude oil extraction. They were initially installed by the multinational Chevron-Texaco in the 1960s and have since multiplied, particularly in the Sucumbíos and Orellana areas © Valeria Barbi

Nor is there any sign of hope in politics from Andres Tapía, communications coordinator of Confeniae, the Confederation of Indigenous Nationalities of the Ecuadorian Amazon, who notes, for example, that "Luisa Gonzales, as well as the members of her party, have always had a very lukewarm attitude towards the Yasuní consultation, which makes us understand that we cannot expect much progress on environmental matters, and that tension with indigenous peoples will remain constant unless the mistakes of the past begin to be corrected."

"However," Tapía continues, "it should be emphasised that the overwhelming victory of the yes vote in the popular referendum is a sign that, for Ecuador, the environment is something worth protecting. Citizens have shown the world that popular will can prevail over political agendas and the million-dollar campaigns of the government, its allied media and the sectors that promote extractivism. Ecuador's vote is one full of dignity, and it fills us with pride."

"The preference of Ecuadorians, as also demonstrated by the referendum results, will go to whoever is able to put forward alternatives that benefit society and the environment. I am talking about the energy issue, but not only that. We must launch a new paradigm," explains Donald Moncayo, general coordinator of the Union of People Affected by Texaco's Oil Operations (Udapt – Unión de afectados y afectadas por las operaciones petroleras de Texaco).

What the government will do

In the aftermath of the first round of elections, Ecuador presents itself as a deeply divided, shaken and distrustful country, yet inhabited by a people equally proud and eager to get back on their feet. Caught in the grip of rampant drug trafficking on one side, and the interests of major oil companies on the other, the small South American country has before it the possibility of changing what, for many, might seem a future already written.

It remains to be seen whether it will be accompanied by the young candidate, scion of one of the country's wealthiest families, who despite the education he received in the halls of major American universities will need to prove that he truly knows his own people, or by the lawyer weighed down by a heavy political burden who has, on her side, a long tradition of social reforms that Ecuador still undeniably needs.

A challenge that is still entirely open, given that, just four days after the results of the popular referendum, Energy Minister Fernando Santos (from the incumbent government of President Lasso) declared that he does not currently intend to take the referendum results into consideration. Consequently, extraction operations will, at least for the time being, continue.

Nos pronunciamos ante las desafortunadas declaraciones del ministro de @RecNaturalesEC, sobre un posible desacato del mayor consenso nacional.

And if there is one thing I have learned during these months in South America, it is that nothing, here, can be taken for granted. And this applies to life as much as to politics.