A step forward in the Senate towards the protection of animals and the environment in the Constitution

A step forward in the Senate towards the protection of animals and the environment in the Constitution

Environment · ·

After a lengthy debate, the Senate's Constitutional Affairs committee voted in favour of some constitutional amendments that environmentalists had long been waiting for.

At Wednesday 19 May's sitting, the Senate's Constitutional Affairs committee gave the green light to a number of amendments introducing the protection of animals and the environment into the Italian Constitution. It is a significant step forward, reached after a lengthy debate that was not without its difficulties.

How the Italian Constitution could change

Specifically, two articles of the Constitution are proposed for amendment. Article 9 forms part of the fundamental principles and currently reads as follows: "The Republic promotes the development of culture and of scientific and technical research. It protects the landscape and the historical and artistic heritage of the Nation." A new paragraph is to be added to this text: "It protects the environment, biodiversity and ecosystems, also in the interest of future generations. State law regulates the means and forms of protection of animals."

Tutela dell'#ambiente, degli #ecosistemi, della #biodiversità. Il @SenatoStampa ne ha approvato l'inserimento nella Costituzione, un grande passo avanti per il Paese, #ISPRA farà la propria parte

Article 41 on the freedom of private economic initiative is also involved. The latter, the Constitution establishes, "may not be carried out in conflict with social utility or in such a way as to cause harm to security, freedom, or human dignity" and, under this new amendment, "to health or the environment." The third paragraph is also supplemented: "The law sets the appropriate programmes and controls so that public and private economic activity may be directed and coordinated for social and environmental purposes."

senato italia, parlamento, elezioni politiche 2018
A view of the Italian Senate, in Rome. Also known as Palazzo Madama © Franco Origlia/Getty Images

The difficult path of this constitutional amendment

Now that this first agreement among political forces has been reached, the bill will be put to the full chamber for the two approvals required from both the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate within the space of one year. The process will still be a long one, in other words, but having laid this first brick is already a result that was far from a foregone conclusion. "Since the Constitution came into force in 1948, this is the first time that the fundamental principles have been touched, and only three other times has the first part of the Charter been amended," recalled the chair of the Constitutional Affairs committee, Dario Parrini. Until now, it had been chiefly Lega that had stood in the way, pursuing an obstructionist campaign that materialised in 246,000 amendments (later withdrawn).

Environmentalists' satisfaction

According to the Lega anti vivisezione (Lav), this is a "decisive vote that will take our country a great step forward" and represents "the premise for an epoch-making change that will have to translate into concrete action on the part of the State, producers and citizens."

Emendamento #svilupposostenibile in #Costituzione. Stefanini: Una vittoria dell'ASviS.È stata intrapresa la strada giusta. Si deve portare a compimento l'iter legislativo di una vera svolta politica e culturale verso una trasformazione ecologica e solidale bit.ly/3f6HyUp

It is also a "historic" result according to Enrico Giovannini, spokesperson for the Alleanza italiana per lo sviluppo sostenibile (Asvis) and Minister of Infrastructure and Transport in the government led by Mario Draghi. "The inclusion in the Constitution of a reference to sustainable development and to future generations would be a truly extraordinary result on the cultural and political level."