Trump wants to eliminate the right to be transgender, by denying the possibility of identifying as such

Trump wants to eliminate the right to be transgender, by denying the possibility of identifying as such

Environment · ·

The US Department of Health is working on a regulation that would in effect eliminate the possibility of identifying with the “trans” gender. A move that would affect 1.4 million American transgender people.

Donald Trump is attempting to deny the existence of transgender Americans. The US government is working on a new regulation that would in effect eliminate the possibility of identifying with the trans gender by changing the very definition of "gender" and making it coincide with that of "sex", reports the American daily New York Times. In short, gender would be reduced to a biological condition determined by the genitals one is born with.

Trump eliminazione riconoscimento transgender
The Trump administration is attempting to eliminate recognition of transgender people in a number of ways © Spencer Platt/Getty Images

From fluid gender to immutable gender

The current administration's efforts are entirely directed at rolling back the gains that transgender people had achieved under the administration of Barack Obama. Trump's predecessor had, in fact, relaxed federal rules on gender, and people who identified as transgender had seen greater protections recognised in the areas of education and healthcare: students, prisoners and homeless people were granted the right, for example, to choose which bathroom to use. Under Obama, gender was understood as an individual choice and no longer tied to one's sex at birth. Conservatives, especially evangelical Christians, had of course looked unfavourably upon such a development.

Now, however, the Department of Health has circulated a memorandum requiring the adoption of a definition of gender "on a clear, grounded in science, objective and workable biological basis". The department is even seeking to change the legal definition of sex by intervening directly in Title IX — the federal civil rights law that prohibits gender discrimination in programmes receiving financial assistance from the government. As well as arguing that the term sex has never been used to include gender identity — and that it was precisely this gap that allowed Obama to extend civil protections to transgender people — the department explains that the new definition will be based on sex, "male or female, immutable and determined by the genitals with which a person is born. The sex listed on the birth certificate, as originally issued, shall constitute definitive proof of a person's sex unless rebutted by reliable genetic evidence."

I can’t begin to express the rage I feel toward an administration that is trying to redefine me out of existence. Just another gift for his small minded base, terrified of the diversity that has always made America exceptional! #Vote nytimes.com/2018/10/21/us/…

The #WontBeErased campaign

The move was preceded by numerous attempts by Trump to limit the gains made by transgender people over the years. First by banning enlistment in the military, and then by effectively banning the word transgender from health documents, along with the words "foetus" and "diversity" (the sole exception being New York State, which in September introduced the possibility of writing "gender x" on birth certificates). But there is more: as far back as February 2017, Trump had already rescinded the very directive adopted by Obama that asked schools across the country to let transgender students decide which bathrooms to use.

The new definition would now apply to two laws currently under review by the White House. The first concerns sexual discrimination in schools and universities that receive federal financial assistance; the second applies to the health and human services sector, and covers health programmes and activities that receive federal funds or subsidies. In any case, the immediate effect would be to instantly erase 1.4 million Americans who have chosen to identify, surgically or otherwise, with a gender different from the one they were born into. "Transgender people are frightened," said Sarah Warbelow, legal director of the Human Rights Campaign, the human rights organisation that fights for the rights of LGBT people (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender). "The administration has turned its back on transgender people."

Read also: What it means to be LGBT in Indonesia, between violence and traditionalism

manifestazione amministrazione Trump revoca diritti transessuali
Thousands of people demonstrated against the Trump administration following the revocation of the Obama-era directive that allowed students to use school bathrooms based on their gender identity © Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Following the publication of the New York Times article, transgender people turned to social media to post their photos with the hashtag #WontBeErased and gathered to organise a protest in the hope of managing at least to contain the most extreme elements of the measure, such as Trump's demand for genetic testing to determine sex and thereby resolve all disputes around matters of gender. If all of this were to be put into practice, the requirement to produce a DNA test could become part of the educational experience in the lives of many people: an unprecedented step towards imposing a biological definition of gender.