- European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen will propose withdrawing the draft pesticide regulation, which aimed to reduce their use by 50 per cent by 2030.
- It was one of the issues at the heart of farmers' protests, and for von der Leyen it had become "a polarising proposal".
- Environmental organisations up in arms: "it is a step backwards that helps neither farmers, nor health and the environment".
The protest movement of European farmers, who for days have been blocking roads and cities across half of Europe with their tractors and are preparing to arrive in Rome as well, has secured a first victory: the European Commission's halt to the SUR, the proposed pesticide regulation, which aimed to reduce the use of plant protection products by 50 per cent by 2030.
The polarisation created by pesticides
The Commission President, Ursula von der Leyen, in her closing speech at the European Parliament plenary in Strasbourg, announced that she will propose withdrawing the pesticide proposal, which "represents a valid objective for reducing the risks of chemical plant protection products," she recalled, but which "has become a symbol of polarisation". Indeed, the proposal had already reached a dead end: it was rejected by the European Parliament on 22 November last year and, by von der Leyen's own admission, "there is no longer any progress being made in the Council either. So we need to do something. That is why I will propose to the College to withdraw the proposal. But of course the issue remains. And to move forward, more dialogue and a different approach are needed."
At this point the Commission could put forward a new proposal "with far more mature content, developed in consultation with stakeholders." That is, with objectives that will certainly be lower than those in the current proposal.
The disappointment of environmental organisations
At the end of last year, a coalition of more than 90 civil society organisations called #CambiamoAgricoltura, coordinated by a working group comprising the leading Italian environmental, consumer and organic sector associations that are members of European organisations — including FederBio, ISDE Medici per l'Ambiente, Legambiente, Lipu, Slow Food Italia and WWF Italia — had called on European institutions to press ahead with the proposed regulation despite the European Parliament's rejection. The proposal aimed (or, at this point, had aimed) to halve the use and risk of pesticides in EU member states by 2030, as set out by the EU's own Farm to Fork strategy.
Today, following von der Leyen's announcement, the organisations went back on the offensive: according to Legambiente, for instance, the withdrawal of the legislative proposal on pesticides "is incomprehensible and represents a resounding step backwards on the major issue of agroecology and the future of agriculture. In doing so, neither farmers, nor the environment, nor citizens' health are being helped." For president Stefano Ciafani, "this is yet another instance of political manipulation ahead of the upcoming European elections," which will be held on 8–9 June. But the proposed regulation also marked recognition of the role of organic farming in reducing pesticides, "identifying it as a priority in national action plans."
The satisfaction of farmers and the government
On the other side, the Italian government expressed its satisfaction ("it is also an Italian victory – Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni assures – From the very start of its mandate, the Italian government has been working to chart a different path from the one taken so far and to combine agricultural production, respect for labour and environmental sustainability"), as did farmers, who welcomed the European Commission's decision as good news: for the national president of Cia-Agricoltori Italiani, Cristiano Fini, the EU regulation on plant protection products "would have decimated agricultural output, putting at risk not only the survival of businesses in the sector, but also the food security of European citizens." According to farmers, a sharp cut of 50 per cent in plant protection products by 2030 would indeed be unworkable without viable alternatives and with the ongoing climate crisis.
Indeed, von der Leyen herself in her address today acknowledged that "farmers are the first to feel the effects of climate change, droughts and floods have destroyed their harvests and threatened their livestock, and they deserve to be heard." Farmers are calling for a "more gradual, realistic and manageable" reduction policy "to reach the green targets, rebalancing agricultural production needs with environmental sustainability objectives," Cia observes. And that is probably what we should expect from the next proposed regulation.