Halving pesticides: the European Parliament rejects the proposal
Food — di Carlotta Garancini
MEPs voted against the regulation proposed by the European Commission to halve pesticide use by 2030.

MEPs voted against the regulation proposed by the European Commission to halve pesticide use by 2030.
No to cutting pesticides. That was the vote of the European Parliament on 22 November, rejecting the Regulation on the sustainable use of plant protection products (Sur) proposed by the European Commission, which provided for the halving by 2030 (compared with the 2015–2017 period) of pesticide use in the European Union. There were 299 votes against, 207 in favour and 121 abstentions.

Only a few weeks ago, the European Parliament's Environment Committee had raised the ambitions of the text, approving a 65 per cent reduction in the most hazardous pesticides; now, however, MEPs not only voted against the text at first reading but also rejected any referral of it back to the Environment Committee, effectively burying the proposal. It will now be the European Council that determines, through its position, whether the proposal will be definitively rejected or returned to the European Parliament for a second reading.
Austrian MEP Sarah Wiener of the Greens Group, who led the negotiations on the text, spoke of a "black day for the environment and for farmers", while her German colleague Jutta Paulus, from the same party, stressed that "the right is endangering the health of farmers and biodiversity".
It was, in fact, the European People's Party (EPP) that was the main opponent of the proposal, together with the agricultural trade union Copa-Cogeca and some member states. For the conservatives, the Commission's environmental objectives were too restrictive, unrealistic and ideological, and failed to address the real problems of farmers. "Today the European Parliament rejected the extremist approach of the Greens and the Socialists to impose ever more bans that would reduce food production in Europe," the EPP stated in a press release, calling for alternatives to pesticides to be found before banning them and for food security to be guaranteed. Votes against also came from those who had initially supported the proposal, since the text, weakened by EPP amendments, had by now become incoherent and devoid of substance.
The WWF described the vote as a significant setback for the ambitions contained in the European Green Deal, heavily influenced by the private interests of part of the agro-industry. For the association, "the fundamental objectives of the Green Deal, the Farm to Fork and Biodiversity 2030 strategies are at risk" and now "the road of the ecological transition of agriculture is all uphill".

"Thousands of scientists and millions of citizens have called for a reduction in pesticides to protect health and the environment. By not responding to these calls, the European Parliament is sending a negative signal to voters about its ability to address major social issues," declared Martin Dermine, executive director of Pesticide Action Network Europe, "– It is clear that the agri-lobby has taken control of our House of Democracy".
For Pan Europe, those who claim to be defenders of farmers are in reality doing the opposite: beyond the health of citizens and ecosystems, measures against pesticides are also necessary for farmers themselves, who depend on healthy soils, biodiversity, clean water, pollination and natural pest control, and who are highly exposed to chemical substances.