The German government's proposal to trial free public transport in five cities is sparking a discussion between supporters and opponents, with some preferring the 'Vienna model' of one euro a day.
Free public transport for everyone: this could be the future of Germany, given the intention to trial a system of public transport with no direct cost to users in five cities.
The German government has decided to find solutions to combat air pollution caused by road traffic, in order to avoid infringement proceedings with hefty fines from the European Commission. In a letter to Environment Commissioner Karmenu Vella, government authorities — including the ministries of Environment and Transport — proposed seven solutions, among them transport regulation, so-called low-emission zones for heavy vehicles, the promotion of electric mobility, and free public transport in Germany.
The U-Bahn, Berlin's underground, could one day be used free of charge under the idea the German government presented to the European Commission to combat air pollution. (Photo by Carsten Koall/Getty Images)
This last proposal has sparked a major debate between supporters and opponents, but it has yet to take on a structured or funded form — something that has not gone down well with the institutional representatives of the municipalities concerned. So much so that Essen and Bonn (the other cities are Reutlingen, Mannheim and Herrenberg) announced they would refuse to participate without first knowing the details and the financial cover established at federal level.
Free public transport in Germany: the positions of supporters and opponents
Supporters point out that such a measure would encourage the use of public transport by broadening the pool of users. Some advocate making it free at least for students, young people and pensioners, so as to incentivise the use of trams, buses and underground lines as a definitive choice. This, according to those in favour of the trial, would be a way to reduce reliance on the private car as quickly as possible.
It should also be borne in mind that air pollution in cities, caused in large part by road traffic, is leading an increasing number of municipalities to restrict diesel vehicle traffic — a decision that, according to an announcement by Mayor Virginia Raggi, will also apply to Rome from 2024.
Those opposed to free public transport point out that an initiative of this kind extended across the whole of Germany would result in a loss of ticket revenue of up to twelve billion, as reported by the Association of German Transport Companies.
These figures would have to be recovered through general taxation or new levies. Not to mention the fact that at peak times lines such as underground routes are already at capacity. A free solution would also increase the number of users, creating the need for additional funding to maintain the previous quality standards.
Examples to follow for greater use of public transport (not just free)
As Berliner Zeitung reports, free use of buses and trains is already in practice for visitors attending football matches, theatres and opera houses: the entry ticket is also valid for public transport. In Belgium, Great Britain, Australia and Hawaii, free public transport schemes have been in place for years.
Tallinn, the capital of Estonia, also chose in 2013 to offer free buses and trams to city residents. This solution reportedly reduced road traffic by fifteen per cent in the early days, leading to an increase in resident registrations with a consequent rise in tax revenue for Tallinn.
Following the German proposal, Brussels has decided to invest in free public transport, which will be provided whenever fine particulate levels exceed the limits for two consecutive days.
Germany, too, has seen similar initiatives in recent years, as Bayerische Rundfunk reports. In Templin, between 1997 and 2002, buses were free: passenger numbers increased fivefold. It was subsequently decided to set the annual season ticket at forty-four euros.
Since February 2018, the municipality of Tübingen (between Herrenberg and Reutlingen) has allowed free travel within the city on Saturdays. Mayor Boris Palmer has also drawn up a plan for how to make public transport permanently free.
Then there is the example of Vienna, where an annual public transport season ticket costs 365 euros: for one euro a day, you can travel across the entire city.
Where would the money come from for free — or almost free — buses and underground services in Germany?
Is Vienna therefore a model for Germany? Yes, according to Berlin traffic expert Heinrich Strößenreuther, who has launched an online petition arguing that the federal government should adopt the Viennese model of one euro a day across the whole of Germany. To fund it, Strößenreuther proposes scrapping the tax deductions for diesel vehicles.
According to the environmental organisation Deutscher Naturschutzring, abolishing the mineral oil tax benefit for diesel would remove seven billion euros from state coffers every year.
The counter-proposal put forward by many has therefore been to work towards significantly reducing the cost of season tickets and single fares. The debate on how to improve urban air quality remains open, including the possibility of completing the free public transport trial — especially in light of the decision by the federal administrative court in Leipzig to allow German municipalities to ban diesel vehicles from their roads.
Free public transport: Germany opens an important debate
Mobility — di Emanuele Rigitano
The German government's proposal to trial free public transport in five cities is sparking a discussion between supporters and opponents, with some preferring the 'Vienna model' of one euro a day.