Germany is trying to introduce free public transport to combat pollution. Meanwhile, against Italy's record smog levels, number-plate alternation is no longer enough. Legambiente's editorial on the Mal'Aria 2018 report.
In the end, even Europe stepped in to say that air pollution levels in major cities are no longer sustainable and that, if the governments of member states already subject to infringement proceedings do not present structural remedies in the near future, hefty fines will rain down. A warning that also concerns our country where, according to Legambiente's Mal'Aria dossier, in 2017 as many as 39 cities, partly due to climatic conditions, were found to be in breach of the law for high concentrations of PM10.
Mal'Aria 2018, the ranking of cities with the most polluted air
The most critical situation is that of the Po Valley, with Turin holding the outright record for the most unbreathable air: the exceedances of the fine particulate matter threshold recorded by monitoring stations reached as many as 112. Next comes Cremona, in second place with 105 exceedances, Alessandria with 103, then Padua with 102, Pavia with 101, Asti with 98, Milan with 97 and Venice with 94 days over the limit. After the worst cities in the north, Frosinone comes in at a surprising ninth place with 93 exceedances. In Campania the worst air is breathed in Caserta, in Umbria in Terni, in Friuli Venezia Giulia in Pordenone and in the Marche in Pesaro.
Alongside PM10, in 2017 Legambiente also measured out-of-norm concentrations of tropospheric ozone (the ozone present in the lower layers of the atmosphere, in direct contact with the earth's surface, ed.): in this case, 44 cities recorded exceedances of the limit of 25 days in the calendar year. The worst were Catanzaro with 111 exceedances, Varese with 82, Bergamo with 80, Lecco and Monza with 78, Mantua with 77. Combining the two pollutants, the city with the highest number of days in breach of the law was Cremona.
Stopgap remedies are not the solution
It is a by-now chronic emergency that afflicts our urban centres and that, until today, has not been met with adequate choices to tackle and resolve it. And yet, considering only the worst cities, it affects the lives of more than 7 million inhabitants. For decades, smog has only been addressed when situations reach "red alert" level, with each city acting as it sees fit, but essentially through insignificant measures that have no impact over the medium and long term: from number-plate alternation, to sporadic car-free Sundays, to circulation restrictions for older vehicles.
But air pollution is no trivial matter. It causes serious damage to citizens' health, particularly that of children and elderly people. According to data from the European Environment Agency (EEA), premature deaths attributable to air pollution in our country amount to more than 60,000 a year, while the associated costs for the healthcare system were already estimated, in 2010, at between 47 and 142 billion euros. The number one enemy is undoubtedly traffic. We hold the European record for private car registrations, with 624 cars per thousand inhabitants, compared to 331 in London and 166 in Paris. We are also the country with the highest number of diesel cars in circulation (56 per cent compared to the European average of 45 per cent) and with one of the oldest car and lorry fleets, with an average age approaching twenty years. And yet 92 per cent of Italians today say they are worried about the quality of the air they breathe.
Letting our cities breathe again
The next parliament must address this issue once and for all, setting aside the protocols signed in recent years between the government, regions and municipalities that have remained essentially on paper. It is necessary to define a different way of planning interventions in urban areas, with investments in collective mobility through the modernisation of vehicles in circulation — starting with commuter transport — in the sustainable conversion of motorised transport and industry, in building regeneration, in heating with innovative systems and in urban green spaces. Alongside this, the public inspection system also needs to be strengthened, with the still-missing approval by the Ministry of the implementing decrees for the law on regional environmental protection agencies.
Meanwhile, the first bold move in response to the European Commission's call comes from Germany, where the possibility of trialling free local public transport in five cities severely afflicted by pollution is being evaluated. The government has assured that it will directly cover the lost revenue. An innovative idea that should not be dismissed, if only for Germany's well-known rationality in financial management: in a city that invests heavily in this direction, boosting the use of public transport and drastically limiting car traffic, the costs of the service could quite comfortably be included in general taxation. Of course, German public transport bears no comparison to that of Italy, which still needs to make many investments in renewing its vehicle fleet. On this front, as on others, the German model remains out of reach for us, as we continue to breathe in the most dramatic fashion the mal'aria made in Italy.
“Let's let our cities breathe again.” Legambiente's advice against smog, in the Mal'Aria 2018 report
Environment — di Stefano Ciafani
Germany is trying to introduce free public transport to combat pollution. Meanwhile, against Italy's record smog levels, number-plate alternation is no longer enough. Legambiente's editorial on the Mal'Aria 2018 report.