24 organisations and 179 individuals have brought the state before the civil court of Rome to compel it to adopt more ambitious environmental policies.
On 5 June 24 organisations and 179 individuals (17 of whom are minors) brought the Italian state to court. The aim is to compel it to adopt more ambitious environmental policies and to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, the main cause of climate change, and to break free "from its inertia in tackling the climate emergency". They are not the first, and they will certainly not be the last, to sue institutions: just a few days ago came the landmark ruling of an Australian federal court, which recognised that the environment minister, Sussan Ley, has a duty to think about the future of younger generations and protect them from the climate crisis.
In recent years, many environmental organisations and groups of private citizens have called on institutions for concrete action to reduce the effects of climate change. In Italy, the legal case is part of a communications campaign called Giudizio universale, organised by the environmental association A Sud. The main requests made to the court are to declare the state "responsible for the situation of danger arising from its inertia in tackling the climate emergency" and to order it to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 92 per cent compared to 1990 levels by 2030.
Il giudizio universale sta arrivando? Salvare il pianeta non è una causa persa. Invertiamo il processo. Facciamo causa allo Stato! Costringiamolo a dare risposte concrete Vai su giudiziouniversale.eu unisciti a noi!
This figure is the result of climate policy analysis carried out by the independent organisations Climate Analytics and New Climate Institute. Using a tool called the Climate Action Tracker, the two organisations estimated how much each country would need to reduce its emissions in order to keep the rise in average global temperature below 1.5 degrees compared to pre-industrial levels — as set out in the 2015 Paris Agreement on climate. All of this taking into account each country's wealth and therefore providing an equitable solution for all countries in the world.
As mentioned, this is certainly not the first instance of legal action relating to climate change. There are currently more than a thousand cases under way. But there is one in particular that "set a precedent". That is the case of Germany, where at the end of April the Constitutional Court ordered the government to change its climate law, ruling in favour of a group of individuals who argued that the law violated their freedoms, as it was insufficiently ambitious and stringent. A case that, within the German jurisdiction, reached the highest level of judgement in three years.
In Italy, given the notoriously longer timescales of the justice system, the proceedings are unlikely to have major practical consequences, if only because they could conclude too late to change the emissions reduction targets for 2030. What we must hope, however, is that it may be an opportunity to bring the debate to the centre of public opinion and, even more importantly, of politics.
The Italian state will have to defend itself in court over climate inaction
Environment — di Cecilia Dardana
24 organisations and 179 individuals have brought the state before the civil court of Rome to compel it to adopt more ambitious environmental policies.