Australia, a court orders the government to protect young people from the climate crisis

Australia, a court orders the government to protect young people from the climate crisis

Environment · ·

According to the Australian court, the government “has an obligation” to take concrete action so as to avoid future harm to younger generations.

Update 16 March 2022 – The ruling that in 2021 had established that Australian Environment Minister Sussan Ley had a duty to protect young people from the climate crisis has been overturned on appeal.

The three judges who upheld Ley's appeal declared that judicial proceedings are not the appropriate means for determining matters of public policy, and that protecting citizens from personal harm caused by the effects of climate change is not the minister's responsibility under Australian environmental laws.

The eight activists who had brought the case the previous year, including 17-year-old Anjali Sharma, said they were extremely disappointed and angry at the court's decision. The young students, supported in their legal action by a nun named Brigid Arthur, made it known that their fight for climate justice would not stop. "The world is watching us."


It is a landmark ruling that has been handed down by an Australian federal court, which recognised that Environment Minister Sussan Ley has a duty to think about the future of younger generations and protect them from the climate crisis. The decision came following an injunction request by eight young students and an eighty-year-old nun to prevent Ley from approving Whitehaven Coal's proposal to expand the Vickery coal mine in the northern region of New South Wales.

Sussan Ley
Australian Environment Minister Sussan Ley © Tracey Nearmy/Getty Images

The Australian court's ruling

If approved, the expansion of the Vickery coal mine would contribute to worsening climate change, endangering the future of new generations. According to projections, it could lead to an increase of approximately 100 million tonnes of CO2 released into the atmosphere, with serious consequences for global warming, which in turn would have a devastating impact on young people.

This is a huge win for the whole climate movement. A big congratulations to the brave Australian teenagers who have achieved this. Of course the action needed is still nowhere in sight, but these court cases are symbolic breaking points that could have huge snowball effects.

During the hearing, the court referred to estimates suggesting that one million young Australians could be hospitalised due to heat stress, that the Great Barrier Reef and much of Australia's eucalyptus forests might no longer exist by the time they reach adulthood, to say nothing of the economic consequences. A dramatic scenario described as "reasonably foreseeable." Despite the request to block the expansion of the coal mine being rejected, Judge Mordecai Bromberg ruled that the minister has a "duty of care", that is, an obligation of diligence not to act in a way that causes future harm to younger generations. According to David Barnden, the students' lawyer, the judge's conclusions are "a world-first win."

Coal mine
A coal mine © Ian Waldie/Getty Images

Judge Mordecai Bromberg's statement

In Judge Mordecai Bromberg's statement, the scenario that looms if climate change is not halted appears to be dramatic. "The physical environment will become increasingly hostile, far more extreme. As for human experience — the quality of life, the opportunity to enjoy the treasures of nature, the ability to grow and to prosper — all will be substantially diminished. Lives will be shorter, ailments will be far more common and it will be harder to be and to remain healthy. None of this will be the fault of Nature itself. It will largely be inflicted by the inaction of the current generation of adults, in what may fairly be described as the greatest intergenerational injustice ever inflicted by one generation of human beings on another." Bromberg pulls no punches, despite the court having in effect rejected the injunction to prevent the expansion of the mine. Meanwhile, a spokesperson for Minister Ley has indicated that the government is assessing the ruling and reserves the right to make further comments "in due course."