Pesticides. “The reduction in use in the EU is measured with misleading indicators”

Pesticides. “The reduction in use in the EU is measured with misleading indicators”

Food · ·

The denunciation by environmental NGOs and the organic movement, who are calling for new tools to achieve the halving of pesticides.

The European Union wants to halve the use of pesticides by 2030, but the measurement of progress towards this goal is said to be based on misleading indicators that take no account of the actual degree of toxicity of the substances and that discriminate against organic farming. The denunciation comes from the promoters of the European campaign Save bees and farmers, together with Pan Europe, Ifoam Organics Europe and Global 2000.

pesticidi
The aim of the European Union's Farm to Fork strategy is to halve pesticide use by 2030 © iStock

Natural substances vs toxic pesticides: the indicator takes no account of the difference

Under scrutiny, specifically, is the harmonised risk indicator 1 (HRI-1), adopted by the EU in 2019 and long contested by Pan Europe as well as judged improvable by the European Court of Auditors, since the indicator is said to reflect a reduction in pesticides that is actually due to a decline in sales of no-longer-approved substances rather than a genuine decrease in pesticide use.

Furthermore, according to a document by Global 2000, HRI-1 would overestimate the risk of natural substances used in organic farming relative to synthetic substances. For example, HRI-1 measures a risk 800 per cent higher for a single application of potassium bicarbonate — a natural fungicide classified by the European Commission as a low-risk active substance — compared with difenoconazole, a synthetic fungicide with toxic properties.

pesticidi
35 different pesticides were found in a single sample of strawberries © iStock

"One of the main misconceptions of HRI-1 is that it establishes a causal link between the quantity of pesticides used and the resulting risk, largely ignoring the existing differences in terms of toxicity and treated area," explained Helmut Burtscher-Schaden, a biochemist specialising in pesticides and adviser to Global 2000. "The indicator would assign exactly the same risk to one kilogram of quartz sand, sufficient to protect five trees from gnawing by wild animals, and to one kilogram of pyrethroid insecticide, sufficient to kill every living insect across 200 hectares."

"Relying on a misleading indicator to measure pesticide reduction is both ineffective and unfair to organic farmers, who are the ones striving to find alternatives to toxic synthetic pesticides," said Eric Gall of Ifoam Organics Europe. "It is also at odds with the EU's objective of reaching 25 per cent of agricultural land under organic farming by 2030." "Member States must stop delaying action to reduce toxic pesticides," added Martin Dermine of Pan Europe.

Another indicator is possible: the call to include it in the new pesticides regulation

Environmental NGOs and the European organic movement also explain that it is possible to use a better indicator that does not discriminate against organic substances, and are calling for it to be included in the proposed revision of the regulation on the sustainable use of pesticides to be presented on 22 June, so as to bring about a drastic shift towards a chemistry-free agriculture based on the health of soils and biodiversity.